3.0

Alan Kirshner

History - Ohlone College

3.0
Quality
3.5
Difficulty
N/A
Would Retake
89
Reviews
3.0
Quality
3.5
Difficulty
3.1
Helpful
3.0
Clarity

N/A

Would Retake

89

Reviews

Rating Distribution
Official

5

25

4

18

3

15

2

11

1

20

What Students Say

“Lectures consisted of him rambling on about his many "great life accomplishments"”

PS102 - 2.0 rating

“I am surprised that this guy hasn't been sued”

POL101A - 3.0 rating
Class Info

Textbook Required

100%

Grade Predictor

Your expected effort level

LowHigh

Predicted Grade

A+

56% confidence
Based on 2 grades
Most common grades:
A- (1)
A (1)
Grade Distribution
A(1)B(0)C(0)D(0)F(0)A-/B+(1)
Based on 2 reported grades
A-: 1
A: 1
Rating Trend

Improving

+0.69 avg change
Oct
Nov
Dec
May
Sep
Feb
Last 6 months
Ratings by Course

HISTOY

5.0

(1)

GOVT

5.0

(1)

HIST103

5.0

(1)

POLSC02

5.0

(1)

POLI102

5.0

(1)
+23 more courses
Difficulty by Course

POLY101

5.0

HIST

5.0

HISTORY104B

5.0

WESTCIV

5.0

HISTORY

5.0

Reviews (89)
3.0
3.0
PS102
Apr 7, 2003

His approach to teaching is interesting but I feel like I'm wasting time in his class. Maybe because I don't like Political science and am only taking it because it's require?!? It's hard... but sometimes he's funny but can be anal about some st

3.0
4.0
PS102
Jun 2, 2003

Kirshner is unique. You either love him or you hate him. Be ready for a lot of bad humor and boring stories and you'll do ok.

2.0
4.0
PS105
Jun 7, 2003

Kirshner sucks! He wrote his own damn book which he makes you buy for $50 on top of a textbook! The lectures end up having nothing to do with the readings.I got a D in this class, retook it with P. Hannan and got a 102%. Now does that add up to you&#63

2.0
4.0
POS102
Nov 4, 2003

His lectures do not pertain to the course material and his midterm and final are essays and if he doesn't like the way you write, you are basicly screwed. People who didn't go to class ended up with better grades then those who did.

5.0
2.0
PS102
Dec 2, 2003

Very little homework, and easy homework at that too. Tests are hard, but if you pay attention and memorize the word list, the tests are no problem. Grades hard on the essays, but will change grades. Plus, he's funny and goes off topic a lot.

4.0
4.0
POLISCI
Dec 9, 2003

I recommend taking ENG103C before taking this class. The essay is a large percentage of the exam grade and critical thinking is necessary. Sometimes gets off the track in class, but it makes the class more interesting. Not easy, but I learned a lot.

5.0
3.0
HIST104A
Dec 20, 2003

WestCiv self paced is easy, you can complete in a week if you go nonstop, it's all 2 page essays on each chapter, it'll make you good at writting, and the tests are essays which you just want to include a lot of info

1.0
5.0
POLY101
Feb 11, 2004

if you don't agree with him and fight him on the issues that he brings up, he will fail you. in this class its either his way or your wrong and your grade will reflect it.

1.0
5.0
HIST104A
Mar 5, 2004

Without a doubt the worst teacher ever! If you take him be ready to hear hours of liberal propaganda.

1.0
5.0
PS102
Apr 15, 2004

An idiot who writes his own book with tear out pages so you can't re-sell them. He makes you buy 3 of them and his lectures are just far out dumb and lame. I've never hated a professor this much in my life. He has a napoleonic comlex! BEWARE!!!

4.0
3.0
PS102
Apr 22, 2004

I think he's cool?

4.0
3.0
PS102
May 19, 2004

A professor who can easily be disliked. He has strong opinions. Overall, his teaching style is different which is why students are apprehensive of him. He will make you think and that will only further your education.

5.0
3.0
PS102
Jun 2, 2004

Kirshner is not for everyone. He does tend to go off on tangents, but they're interesting and informative. Always opinionated, but always fair, I would reccomend Kirshner, but it's helpful to know as much as you can beforehand.

3.0
3.0
HIST104B
Aug 20, 2004

i took the selfpaced course over the summer and it was a lot of work. his classes seemed fun if only i could've attend them. watching them on tape was so boring.

5.0
4.0
PS102
Sep 18, 2004

It's a hard course, but he's fair. Memorize the word list. You will learn a lot about politics if you pay attention. Seems to take pride in having a tough course.

2.0
3.0
PS102
Sep 30, 2004

All he does is talk amount random stuff rather than talk about History...His class is somewhat easy, but he still doesnt cover everything he should. I dont recommend him

5.0
1.0
HISTOY
Nov 22, 2004

I never showed up to this guys class, got an F+ on some group test but still managed to get A. I don't know what these people are talking about, but take him. BTW my book had torn out pages too and could not sell it back and I like his liberal propaganda. Pretty amusing guy.

3.0
2.0
PS102
Dec 11, 2004

No Comments

4.0
3.0
PS102
Jan 5, 2005

I think he is a great Professor who is very knowledgeable, and as long as you read the books you will do fine. Going to class helps a lot, but he also has lectures on his website. He lets you use prior book editions, and submit interfaces online.

5.0
3.0
PS102
May 7, 2005

He is exremely informative. The class is hard but not if you pay attention and make sure you understand exactly what he means. He is extremely liberal but I know it doesn't get in the way of his teaching cuz I'm pretty conservative and am still passing! TAKE HIS CLASS if you want to learn something

3.0
3.0
PS102
May 31, 2005

lecture are a bit boring and so is his book. study the things that he emphasizes and don't waste your time on the whole vocabulary list. study the vocab from his lectures and in his book and you'll be fine. he's a good guy even if his lectures are boring. he has some interesting stories and comments about politics though.

1.0
4.0
GOVERNMENT
Jun 20, 2005

If you're into professors who don't actually teach very much, and who expect each student to do all their learning from the text rather than the class itself then by all means take his classes. If you're like me, however, and you expect the teacher to teach rather than bs about his kids and other unrelated things, tehn get the f' outta there.

1.0
4.0
WESTERNCIV
Jul 2, 2005

He didn't do any of the teaching...and the tests were pretty horrible...rather time consuming. Answering one essay question...everything depends on one answer being right. Lame class...a waste of time pretty much.

2.0
5.0
HIST104A
Aug 2, 2005

This was a self paced class with no assistance whatsoever. He led his students to believe that he would be of some help, but in all actuallity he wasn't around this summer. Because he wasn't around, we had to suffer.This ended up being an online class.This class isn't impossible, but frusterating and stressful. You have to be okay with no help.

1.0
3.0
HIST104
Grade: A-
Aug 22, 2005

This guy needs to find something new to do because he is obviously tired of teaching. Look at his latest reviews...enough said! I couldn't agree more!!! Do not take him!

5.0
2.0
GOVT
Aug 24, 2005

no term paper, 2 essays, easy A......if you do your job and study. he assumes you know the stuff, so if you don't...ASK! over all easy class. great guy too.

1.0
5.0
PS102
Grade: A
Aug 31, 2005

Dr. Kirshner is by far one of the worst teachers of my life. he tells you to to buy his books so that he can make money off of you, and then lectures from his own point of view. he has an unbalanced view of american government. his exams are essays and are extremely hard to get a grade higher than C. he either likes you or not like you. Stay Away.

1.0
5.0
HIST
Aug 31, 2005

No Comments

1.0
5.0
HISTORY104B
Sep 8, 2005

I have never met a teacher that was so into himself. The class should be titled "The Life History of Kirshner" He is NOT an easy teacher, his classes are EXTREMELY boring and he does not focus on the topic that he assigns. I had more found counting the hairs of the person sitting in front of me!

3.0
4.0
POLYSCI
Oct 17, 2005

Can anyone say EGO? Watch out, he wants you to regurgitate his version of HIStory, filled with "Kirshnerisms" and whatever HE thinks is meaningful. You even get to buy his OWN book for $90, to read his manifesto on himself through the filter of political science. Why don't you just get his autograph on it too, to complete your Kirshner experience?

1.0
5.0
WESTCIV
Oct 20, 2005

Mr. Kirshner, excuse me, Dr. Kirshner is a lowsy piece of piece of work who needs to retire because he's getting sloppy and loves talking about himself more than the subject at hand. I mean, he's ruined a perfectly good subject!

4.0
3.0
PS102
Oct 23, 2005

I really enjoyed his class. He's Hard but fair and always willing to help you understand a lesson. I would take His class again. He has an ego, but It's fun hearing him talk about it in class. The interfaces aren't too hard, but it's better than an extremly large amount of homework. Plus you can turn in the interfaces anytime the day they are due!

1.0
4.0
AMERICANGOV
Dec 18, 2005

No Comments

1.0
3.0
HIST104A
Dec 23, 2005

His lectures are incredibly boring and off topic.Once he talked about the history of chess for 3 lectures in a row. His grading is very biased, if he liked you, you could write absolute crap and still get a decent grade.He's not hepful,I asked him to give me an example of an A paper and he told me to go look for someone he gave an A and ask them.

1.0
5.0
HISTORY
Dec 26, 2005

He makes you buy his book and take some pages out so you can't sell again. OK we know all about your chess and your family and blah blah blah can we learn a little history!You know what we paid for!If your thinking of wasting your money on him, then fine that's your problem, just don't bother buying the book cuz it's kirshner history!!!

1.0
5.0
HIST
Dec 27, 2005

This instructor is evidence that dinosaurs once roomed the earth, egoistic dinosaurs! Oh god is his class boring. My laptop fell asleep while I was using it. Everything falls asleep in his class my feet, hands, to stay awake in his class try closing one eyelid at a time. Oh lord, I'm falling asleep talking about him.

1.0
5.0
HIST
Dec 27, 2005

If your thinking of taking his class here let me sum it up for you. Blah blah blah...chess..blah blah...Kirshner...Chess..Kirshner kids..blah blah blah chess...chess. Kirshner blah blah blah. Any Questions????

3.0
3.0
AMERGOV
Jan 4, 2006

Gets off topic quite a lot. Grades difficult on essays. Has an ego the size of Texas. Can be amusing but also boring.

5.0
2.0
POLISCI
Jan 30, 2006

Dr. Kirshner is a great professor. It is true he does get off topic during his lectures but it is usually something way more interesting than what the lecture was about anyway. he is also an easy grader on essays. have to write complete bullsh*t to get a bad grade.

1.0
5.0
PS102
Nov 6, 2006

No Comments

5.0
3.0
HIST104A
Dec 11, 2006

I took the online 104A class. If you are an older/working student like me then take this class. Dr. K is a good guy. Introduce yourself before the start of the class (if you can) stick to the deadlines he sets, get the papers in on time and you’ll do fine.

1.0
3.0
PS102
Dec 20, 2006

DO NOT take this class if you are really expecting to learn anything about politics. 90% of class is spent talking about all kinds of other stuff (chess, his kids, etc.). He is also very boring and really full of himself. HUGE EGO, little man.

5.0
1.0
PS102
Feb 9, 2007

Kirshner is a good guy. Ask the man questions, engage him. He works hard to make his class easy to pass; do the interfaces and study the word lists and the class is a breeze. And if you find his class boring or off topic, you're not intelligent enough to understand or relate what he's talking about to the course material.

5.0
4.0
PS102
Sep 11, 2007

Great Teacher!!!! I took him again for Western Civ

4.0
4.0
HIST104A
Nov 19, 2007

No Comments

5.0
4.0
HIST103
Nov 21, 2007

One of the best professors i've ever had. all the complainers probably dont have the writing skills of a 5th grader (all thats needed to pas really). His lectures are interesting and informative, hes very knowledgeable of the material, and u get 100 pts practically free (just attnd) Very fun person to talk to, would definitely take him for poli sci

5.0
3.0
HIST104A
Jan 25, 2008

Dr. Kirshner is probably one of the best professors on campus. I loved his classes. Very easy-going. Lectures were interesting. I had 3 in class essays and free 100 points for group meetings. Even if you just attend class and listen, you will retain information. Not an easy grader, so you have to know how to write.

5.0
1.0
HIST104A
Jan 28, 2008

Work hard, pay attention, come to class, take notes, do the required assignments, and you'll earn what you deserve!

5.0
1.0
PS102
Jan 28, 2008

One of my favorite professors. His obscure humor, strange stories, and over-the-top sarcasm are just some of the elements you can look forward to. Grading is fair and an 'A' is easily attainable as long as you are well-versed in the material.

4.0
4.0
HIST104
Apr 13, 2008

I have taken 3 classes with Dr. Kirshner and loved everyone. If you want to do nothing and have the information fed to you then do NOT take Dr. Kirshner's classes. However if you want a college level course where college level work is demanded and learn about history or American Gov. then take Kirshner's classes.

4.0
2.0
HIST104A
Apr 28, 2008

I have took both Poli sci, and history 104 with professor Kirshner, and it was very easy if you just read the book and pay attention in class.

5.0
2.0
HIST104
Oct 9, 2008

Very good teacher, very funny. He seems intimidating though, not sure yet, but 100% sure going to take another class with him. He comes off as pompus, and full of himself at first--but thats because HE KNOWS HIS STUFF!! So do your work and respect the guy. We are lucky to have him as a teacher at ohlone. Almost to good...

3.0
4.0
POL101A
Nov 1, 2008

I am surprised that this guy hasn't been sued! Maybe he has. His liberal propaganda is way out there. He once said that he is not a Republican because they are involved in too many sex scandals with little boys! I really don't want to slam any teacher especially since I plan to be one and will be at the receiving end of these some day,but this guy!

2.0
4.0
PS102
Dec 19, 2008

This is the worst profesor ive ever had. I did not learn a thing from this class. The worst part about it was he wrote the damn textbook. If you have any common sense you will not take this class.

4.0
4.0
HIST104A
Jan 7, 2009

He is no joke. He is a smart man. Each test covers 4 chapters of the book and lecture. The tests are a choice of three prompts. Read the book and attend the lectures. Go to the group meetings. It's best if you come into this class already knowing how to write well. Get to the point. Class was fun with his wise-xss comments.

5.0
2.0
POLSC02
Jan 15, 2009

I took Dr. K's course on a whim my first year at Ohlone. I found it to be a blessing and a curse. A blessing for all I learned (I took two more of his courses)and a curse because now I am forced to judge every other teacher by comparing him to Kirshner. None, so far, have come close.

4.0
2.0
HIST104A
Jan 23, 2009

I took his self-paced class, and it's tough. If you have a lot of time on your hands during the semester, then you can pass easily. Otherwise, it's a challenge. But I did learn stuff about West Civ. that I'd never think about. However, I suggest that if you can, take the lecture instead, as I hear that he can be entertaining.

5.0
4.0
PS102
Feb 2, 2009

I've known Dr. Kirsher for more than five years now, and I've taken both of his western civilization courses and his American government course. The man treats every one of his students as if they were his own children- He accepts you as who you are, but simultaneously he expects you to do your best. If you want to better yourself, take his course.

1.0
2.0
POSCI102
Apr 15, 2009

Worst teacher ever!!!! The sad thing is that based on class discussion I think most high school civics teachers know more about today's political issues than this guy. And he has a Ph.D. I don't see why they let this guy teach a course as important as this. We already have a bunch of uneducated citizens. I felt dumber after taking this class.

2.0
5.0
PS102
Jun 7, 2009

I took Kirshners class last semester and it was one of the worst classes ive ever had. He is extremely liberal and if you dont agree with his way of thinking he marks you down for it. The class was extremely boring, all he would talk about was how he was so great at the game of chess. Stay away from this teacher!!

1.0
5.0
POL101
Jun 19, 2009

this teacher blows

5.0
4.0
HIST104
Jul 29, 2009

I do not understand people are having hard time with his classes. I took both of his western civ. and his PS class; all that is required of student is to do their readings. Dr. K is great and he definitely knows his stuff. I can tell you right now there is nothing called easy A. However, you will definitely benefit from the lectures. Highly recomme

4.0
3.0
HIST104
Aug 10, 2009

I very much enjoyed taking Dr. Kirshner's class. His western civ course is harder than his poly sci class I admitt, but he tells you that up front. I love his lectures although they do not cover much material from the textbook.Just make sure you read the chps!And he is always in his office ready to help his students

4.0
4.0
HIST104
Aug 10, 2009

Dr. Kirshner is a very good teacher. His western civ classes are challenging. You just have to know how to write unlike most people at Ohlone. Reading is helpful, although you can do quite well just from studying lecture notes. You just have to get over his arrogance and sarcarsm. It's actually quite entertaining. Doc K knows his stuff

3.0
3.0
PS102
Sep 25, 2009

He's a nice guy but OMG, he's one of those teachers that don't really have a lesson plan and just go with the flow. If your good at just listening and hearing it's2 one to take but if your like me, someone who needs organization and blunt explanations then, do not take this class!

5.0
1.0
HIST104A
Nov 30, 2009

amazing teacher omg! if you love to hear lectures that make reading the textbook interesting listen to him! if your a little twit who needs everything listed out straight from the book he doesnt do it but his way is extremely helpfull when it comes to memory

3.0
3.0
PS102
Dec 12, 2009

This teacher is hard and easy. I never went to class, did the homework, read the textbook, studied hard for the final and got 71 on my mid term. He said I did better than most people in the class. This class is all about memory and rewriting his ideas.

3.0
4.0
HIST104A
Dec 23, 2009

If you are going to take this class, take it self paced; our grades were significantly higher than the people who took him in class. Do 3 mini-theses that are 10 pages long and well written, and do all the assignments on time, and you should do well. I'm a history major and narrowly got an A. He grades hard: be warned!

3.0
5.0
PS102
Dec 25, 2009

He is extremely knowledgeable and has high expectations from his students. He grades very hard but if you are ready to work very very hard, you'll get an A. Take his online class and attend all the chats and submit all assignments on time (if you miss even one assignment, it will affect your grade!). You'll learn a lot.

2.0
4.0
PS102
Feb 19, 2010

This guy... all he has online are his lecture transcripts, lecture VOICE recordings, and a few lecture video recordings. No slides, no organization, no handouts. He writes his own book and wants us to regurgitate his own ideas. Terrible.

4.0
4.0
HIST104
Apr 10, 2010

Professor Kirshner got me interested in school like few other teachers have. Following his classes I was prepared for my transfer to UC Berkeley. So, if you're biggest goal is an AA you've probably got the wrong teacher but if you'd like to join me at CAL pay attention and sign up. Even after CAL he would be my second favorite lecturer ever.

2.0
5.0
PS102
May 12, 2010

Terrible. He babbles about his life during class. You'll learn more from his TA at the study sessions. GO TO THOSE.

2.0
5.0
PS101
May 14, 2010

Kirshner tends to only go on about his family. Gives you a syllabus but doesn't stick to it. You're expected to give his answers for your opinions, if you give your opinions, you are docked points. He makes fun of everyone and everything, sometimes not so nicely. Class is nap-inducing. Not fun.

3.0
3.0
HIST104
May 14, 2010

This is more of a question than a rating. I need to take this class and don't understand how it works. It is self-paced and lists a classroom but not any meeting times. Do you do all your work there in the classroom? I need to take this class at night. When does it meet? Any information would be appreciated. Thanks!

4.0
4.0
HIST104B
Jun 3, 2010

After taking self-paced History 104B with Prof Kirshner, my only complaint (other than my last rating for 104A) is the boring material. The textbook on humanities gives no history while emphasizing the arts, architecture, literature, etc. I signed up for a history class, not an arts class. Other than that, do 2400 words for each exam for an A.

3.0
3.0
HIST104A
Jun 4, 2010

The book is all about art and religion. I gave my own opinion in a assignment based on what I read and got a 0 for the assignment. He is very self involved. He writes his own books and you have to buy them for his class. I am not afraid of hard work but you shouldn't have to memorize a 800 page textbook for a 3 unit class.

4.0
4.0
PS102
Jun 11, 2010

I took his online class and it was a really good class! however, it's no cake walk. Kirshner makes you work for your A, so be prepared for a lot of critical thinking. but don't let the workload discourage you. the class is completely worth the effort, it really prepares you!

5.0
3.0
POLI102
Apr 8, 2011

I took both western civ and american gov't with Kirshner. Really good teacher. would definitely recommend taking his classes. for his tests the essays can be kinda hard because you need to provide good information and not just completely generalize. good speaker and ive always thought he kinda sounded like Kevin Spacey. weird

5.0
2.0
HIST104B
May 16, 2011

Funny and entertaining lecturer. You don't need to read the book to pass, but because I read the book and attended lectures I never had to study and got As. Tests are based completely on his opinions so just reciting them will get you a good grade.

4.0
2.0
PS102
May 18, 2011

Well he has a lot of knowledge of what he is talking and yes he kinds of get out of topic but he is a great professor. If you really like politics you are going to enjoy his class. Another point is that he barely gives you homework.

2.0
3.0
POSCI102
May 18, 2011

HUGE ego!!! It's all about DOCTOR Kirshner. Role up your pant legs: It's deep. Got an A, but would NEVER take his class again. There is no way I could stand hearing his lame stories again. Bottom line: take someone else.

5.0
3.0
PS102
May 31, 2011

AMAZING! I loved his class and I always looked forward to going to his lectures. If you read the book, and do your vocab....you'll be fine! I read the chapters and studied for a day or two for the midterm/final and did pretty well. If you ACTUALLY do the online homework, you'll be fine since thats like 33% of your grade. Overall, I enjoyed it :)

1.0
5.0
POL102
Oct 27, 2011

I'm sorry but this guy is not a good teacher. I swear I had high school teachers that taught better than him. STAY AWAY!

4.0
5.0
POL102
Nov 6, 2011

All I have to say is you better know your sh*t, when you're messing with Kirshner. You either swim or drown. This New Yorker aint no joke! My advice to anyone who takes his class is to take notes during lectures,because this is very important. Do all your on-line essays and read as much as possible.Good Luck!

4.0
4.0
PS04
Nov 14, 2011

Charlie!! (; One of my favorite teachers at Ohlone. Although his lectures are long, it amazes me how he doesn't have to use a study plan. Extremely knowledgeable. I'd say you have to be a good note taker for his class. Flashcards saved my life for his mid term and final. Extremely helpful, has a TA. I got the grade I deserved and was very content.

5.0
5.0
PS102
Dec 22, 2011

Dr. Kirshner is an awesome teacher. I had the privelage to take both his Poli Sci class and his Western Civilization class. I knew almost nothing when I started and now I know my stuff! I worked really hard in both classes and got A's. He's tough and provides you an open door to to come and talk to him if you need any help.

5.0
3.0
HIST104A
May 4, 2012

Tests are in class essays which aren't too bad if you pay attention. He gives you the choice of questions from lecture, book or combination of both.

2.0
3.0
PS102
Sep 11, 2013

Lectures consisted of him rambling on about his many "great life accomplishments". His self authored textbook was much the same as his lectures, and never seemed to focus on a central topic. Most the time we had no clue if he was just telling stories or trying to actually teach us something. Always felt unprepared for tests. Take online if you must

3.0
4.0
PS102
Feb 3, 2014

Dr. Kirshner was the worst history teacher that I had while attending there at Ohlone. Too many stories. Also, he talked too fast. So fast that I could only write down half a page of notes during his lecture. Finally, he was not friendly especially after I revealed to him that I had been diagnosed as having a learning disability. Very rude.

Class Info

Textbook Required

100%

Grade Predictor

Your expected effort level

LowHigh

Predicted Grade

A+

56% confidence
Based on 2 grades
Most common grades:
A- (1)
A (1)
Grade Distribution
A(1)B(0)C(0)D(0)F(0)A-/B+(1)
Based on 2 reported grades
A-: 1
A: 1
Rating Trend

Improving

+0.69 avg change
Oct
Nov
Dec
May
Sep
Feb
Last 6 months
Ratings by Course

HISTOY

5.0

(1)

GOVT

5.0

(1)

HIST103

5.0

(1)

POLSC02

5.0

(1)

POLI102

5.0

(1)
+23 more courses
Difficulty by Course

POLY101

5.0

HIST

5.0

HISTORY104B

5.0

WESTCIV

5.0

HISTORY

5.0

Similar Professors