3.5

Cathy Mestre

Law - Valencia College - East and West Campus

3.5
Quality
4.3
Difficulty
41%
Would Retake
138
Reviews
3.5
Quality
4.3
Difficulty
3.4
Helpful
3.6
Clarity

41%

Would Retake

138

Reviews

Rating Distribution
Official

5

65

4

19

3

13

2

10

1

31

What Students Say

If you must take BUL2241 but you have a full schedule including a full time job, along with taking care of a household don't take her

BUL2241 - 3.0 rating

SHE IS THE WORST PROF EVER HAD IN MY WHOLE LIFE

BUS2201 - 1.0 rating
Class Info

Online Classes

100%

Attendance Mandatory

78%

Textbook Required

57%

Grade Predictor

Your expected effort level

LowHigh

Predicted Grade

B-

95% confidence
Based on 41 grades
Most common grades:
A (12)
Drop/Withdrawal (8)
B (7)
Grade Distribution
A(16)B(8)C(7)D(10)F(5)A-/B+(3)
Based on 61 reported grades
A: 12
Drop/Withdrawal: 8
B: 7
Rather not say: 6
Common Tags
Tough grader (30)
Lecture heavy (21)
Skip class? You won't pass. (16)
Test heavy (14)
Graded by few things (14)
Get ready to read (10)
Tough Grader (9)
Participation matters (6)
Rating Trend

Declining

-1.50 avg change
May
Nov
Feb
Apr
Oct
Dec
Last 6 months
Ratings by Course

PLA

5.0

(1)

PARALEGALCLASS

5.0

(1)

PLARP1

5.0

(1)

BUSSLAW

5.0

(1)

LAWLAW

5.0

(3)
+30 more courses
Difficulty by Course

PARALEGAL

5.0

LEGALRESEARCH

5.0

LAWLAW

5.0

BUL2100

5.0

PLAALL

5.0

Reviews (138)
5.0
3.0
PLA
Jul 23, 2003

Professor Mestre is one of the best teacher's I've ever had! She is very thorough. If you want to learn and better yourself, she's the most helpful teacher.

5.0
5.0
PARALEGAL
Feb 23, 2004

She is the best professor...EVER. Tough, but fair. She does not play favorites and will kick your butt into gear and make you a great writer. You will not forget what you learn in her classes. Excellent, A++++ teacher.

1.0
5.0
PARALEGAL
May 9, 2004

Worst teacher I have ever had. It is a shame that she is a teacher who teachs adults because she discourages you to continue on with your education. She allowed one of her interns to write the final exam for our class and she never checked it.

5.0
4.0
PLA2203
Jan 18, 2005

She is definitely the best teacher I have ever had!! She knows what she's talking about and she is very helpful. She really takes time to get to know her students!!!

4.0
3.0
PLA1611
Jun 1, 2005

great teacher. you need to go to every class and take notes. she will test from them and the handouts. she helps people who want to learn and is very nice. you can learn alot from her.

3.0
5.0
LEGALRESEARCH
Oct 12, 2005

Try to make this professor the only class you are taking and dont get sick or have anything else to do but her class. it was very hard adn her grading was very strict. she forms opinions about her students quickly and if she doesnt like you your screwed.if you have absolutely nothing else to do in life. no work,family,other classes

5.0
2.0
BUL2241
Jan 7, 2006

She was very help full and she showed she cares about her students just talk to her and she'll help you!

5.0
3.0
PARALEGALCLASS
Jan 13, 2006

She is amazing! Explains well, very cool to students, but be aware: her tests can be tricky and she is demanding on writing quality. Other than that, simply an A+ professor! ^_^

5.0
4.0
BUSLAWI
Jan 31, 2006

She's a good teacher & I passed w/an A amazingly. Just go to class, take notes, & learn the study guide cause the quesetions are exaclty from there. Make sure you do the oral presentation cause it really booses up ur grade. Good luck!

5.0
1.0
REALPROPERTY
Apr 3, 2006

She is a GREAT professor. I have an "A"! You have to study because there is nothing such things as a free ride with Mrs. Mestre. BRING A RECORDER TO CLASS! Everythings she says out her mouth is on the test! She never test out of the book!!

5.0
5.0
LEGALRESEARCH
May 22, 2006

Professor is hard BUT she prepares you for the real world! I have never learned so much in my life. My writing has improved 100%. She makes it very clear what she expects and you get a chance to correct all your assignments before turning them in for final grade..AWESOME!!!!!

5.0
3.0
BUL2241
Jul 5, 2006

Professor Mestre's Business Law was extremely informative, while retaining a simple, easy to follow class structure. The only thing you must do to earn an A in this class is enjoy the subject matter.

5.0
3.0
PLA1611
Nov 2, 2006

Her classes are not easy unless you come and listen to her lectures. Every word out of her mouth is as good as gold. She is very clear and precise about what she expects of you. It is alot of writing, but I learned that it makes it easier for you to remember. If you really want to learn, take her!

5.0
4.0
PLARP1
Dec 16, 2006

Anyone who dare says that she is a bad teacher is just someone who was to lazy to study, and shouldn't be in the paralegal program to begin with!!! She knows her stuff, and is one of the best teachers I have ever had.

5.0
3.0
BUSSLAW
Jan 7, 2007

Business Law- Great professor. Explained very well. Her tests can be difficult but if you pay attention in her class and follow the study guide an A should be make able. I know I did.

5.0
4.0
LEGALPLA
Feb 23, 2007

She is a great professor, but she does seem to think that you have nothing else going on in your life except this class. And if you do not like group work, do not take her class. She wastes half her time forcing students to work in groups.

5.0
4.0
BUS2201
Mar 10, 2007

No Comments

5.0
1.0
PLA1611
Apr 27, 2007

Best Professor at Valencia. You will hate or love her there is no in the middle. She is thorough and expects the best from everyone. Her class is crazy easy if you attend every class and take good notes. BUY A TAPE RECORDER!!! And you will be fine, if you are a lazy person who came to Valencia to sleep and get an A you will hate her. Take Her!!!

1.0
5.0
LEGALPLA
Jun 11, 2007

What else is there to say?

2.0
3.0
BUS300
Sep 25, 2007

Well, a went to Valencia to obtain my second degree later in life. Mrs. Mestre was the worst college professor that I ever had. The reason why: She did not teach! Granted, I grew up valuing education and that is why I went to a private college to get my B.A.; however, I made a mistake and left Valencia because of Mrs. Mestre. Mestre is a waste of $

5.0
5.0
PLA1611
Dec 8, 2007

Be ready to write! Lots of notes! She is very strict on when items need to be turned in, but that only prepares you for this career. She was a good Professor. Just didn't care to hear about her perfect life. I recommend her if you want to learn, but she is not an easy A. A's don't mean anything in the work force, only knowledge.

4.0
2.0
BUL2241
Dec 19, 2007

Business Law Online. Easy class that covers basics. Study for the exams, esp. the last one. Grades exam on curve. Barely used very expensive book $190 - only for a couple chapters at the end. She provided notes. Mestre was decent: always available and easy to talk to. Overall, informative class with steady pace & light workload.

2.0
4.0
PLA1114
Jan 11, 2008

This teacher makes mistake and fails students for her mistakes beware. She has no heart. She is not human.

5.0
5.0
PLA1114
Apr 11, 2008

I have taken Prof. Mestre for RPI, RPII, Legal Research I & Legal Research II. If she taught other classes, I'd take them too! She IS hard, but she IS FAIR. If you're lazy, don't take her, you won't like her. She treats you like the COLLEGE student you are. This isn't high school anymore, time to grow up!!!!! I'm really going to miss her.

5.0
5.0
LAWLAW
Jul 8, 2008

she is the best

5.0
5.0
PLA1104
Aug 15, 2008

I loved this professor. It is NOT an easy "A" at all, but I really enjoyed the challenge. On a lecture day, be prepared to write write write! Her tests are multiple choice, but don't let that fool you, they are really tough. You will learn so much from her. Some say she forms an opinion of you from the start, I didn't experience that personally.

5.0
4.0
PLA1611
Nov 9, 2008

I love her, even though she is kinda hard, she's awesome. Assignments and exams are straight from her notes. Attendance is important because we take A LOT of notes in her lectures. Any questions you may have she answers to the best of her ability, she's just great. But be warned, if you are not a good note taker, consider another teacher.

5.0
4.0
PLA1104
Nov 11, 2008

Prof. Mestre is an amazing teacher. She is extremely knowledgeable and accessible. Her courses are demanding, but I feel incredibly prepared to enter the legal field! I have taken or am taking every class she offers. You have to work in her classes, but it only prepares you for working in a law firm!!!

5.0
5.0
BUL2241
Nov 21, 2008

Prof. Mestre is amazing! I was very concerned with taking Business Law I online, but she has really taken the time to outline the course where it is very informative & easy for the students to stay on track. Dont get me wrong, you must work hard to earn a good grade, but above all, she is extremely fair. Probably the best teacher I've ever had.

2.0
5.0
BUL2100
Dec 12, 2008

This class was horrible to take online. All her assignments are pointless busy work. Her tests are ridiculous and she is flat out a jerk when you ask her questions. I would never take her again.

4.0
5.0
PLA1104
Dec 20, 2008

Hard class & you spend a lot of time in the library. I recommend taking this class late in your program; not for a Freshman. Be prepared to write a lot, take good notes it will be in the test. Ms Mestre is very strick on the writing so you have to be careful. Overall good professor & I learned a lot. I recommend her for those who like a challenge!

5.0
5.0
PLAALL
Feb 5, 2009

I have been luck enough to have her for BusLaw I, Real Prop I & II, Leg Research I & II. VERY CLEAR in her expectations. VERY FIRM, but fair. You have to work hard, but she makes it interesting. Willing to meet with and help EVERYONE! (Learn where her office is since class time is completely filled with notes!)

3.0
5.0
BUS2
Feb 22, 2009

Gordon and Mestre have an askewed view of the legal world, probably because they haven't been in it for years. Good teachers, but mostly impractical, which is the norm with most teachers. You do the dance, get the job, then learn how to really do it. I work with Judges and lawyers every day,not in some made up pristine legal world that they created

5.0
5.0
PLA1104
May 5, 2009

I took this teacher for both pla 1104 and 1611 in the same semester. She is a good teacher and willing to help, but make sure you study a lot your life is bascially her class. she expects everything you give her to be perfect. she sometimes belittles you, but i got over it and got an A in both classes. Just study really really hard!

5.0
2.0
BUL2241
May 19, 2009

Great professor. I am a science major and took this class online last fall as an elective. Very clear expectations, very easy class. Expects decent writing skills, which everyone should have by the time they reach a college level. If you cannot write, take a remedial class. Professors should not be expected to teach you basic life skills.

5.0
5.0
BUL2241
Jul 22, 2009

I took her online. There are 3 tests EACH is worth 25% of your grade, the last 25% is assignments. The assignments are easy they involve research. The exams are taken on campus on scheduled days and you MUST at the very least study her study guide hard core. The tests are curved but even so they are hard. She is nice and very helpful!

5.0
5.0
PLA1104
Nov 1, 2009

I attempted this class while working full time DO NOT TRY THIS. Had to drop after the midterm. Every week there is a research assignment that must be done in the law library, will take at least 5 hours per assignment. The midterm and final are TIMED research exams out of the law library HARD! Take this course if you have a lot of time for it!

5.0
4.0
BUL2241
Dec 18, 2009

Professor was very upfront and forewarned us of the heavy workload in the class. Online modules were very clear & easy to follow. Knowing the expectations upfront prepared me for the class. Study guide was very helpful.

5.0
1.0
PLA2433
Feb 11, 2010

She is an easy teacher and runs through the material rapidly, which I enjoyed thoroughly! I would recommend her if you really want to be a Paralegal, because she is one of the best professors you will find in the program and she teaches a lot of different classes, so be prepared to work hard and enjoy the fruits of your labor!

5.0
5.0
LAWLAW
Mar 18, 2010

Best teacher that I have evr had. I took her last term for three classes, RP I, Bus Org, and leg research. I was happy to get the b's. You need to attend class, take notes and pay attention. She is hard as heck but you will learn a lot. DO NOT take her if you are lazy. Her tests are hard and you HAVE TO study hard. I think she rocks!

3.0
5.0
BULL2241
Jul 9, 2010

Mestre is a STRICT professor! Not an easy class at all! She is very passionate about law. This class was difficult. You HAVE to do all your assignments on time, you HAVE to read the chapters, you HAVE to read the study guide and memorize it! This class was very hard for me to get into.

4.0
5.0
LAW101N
Aug 3, 2010

She is a really tough teacher. Don't expect much help from her. With her, either you get it or fail! Expect hours of homework each week. I wonder if she realizes that most of us have other classes that need our attention as well?

2.0
5.0
LAW1234
Aug 6, 2010

Not a great teacher, very demanding and gives an unreasonable amount of work. Only take her if you have to.

5.0
5.0
PLA1104
Oct 27, 2010

She is a tough teacher, but fair. Don't get behind on assignments and you'll do fine. Excellent lecturer. Very easy to understand Don't buy the book. Take good notes and ask for help if you need it. One of the best professors Valencia has to offer.

4.0
5.0
PLA1104
Oct 29, 2010

Her class assignments are very time consuming, and require great attention to detail. Take good notes of the lectures because the test is all about the lecture. She is very strict on grading but if you put in the effort you will pass. She is brilliant, and is not for everyone. C students should look for another teacher.

5.0
5.0
LAWLAW
Dec 18, 2010

If you want to be babied and have your hand held, don't take her. If you realize this is college and that we are adults trying to learn a difficult subject, TAKE HER. By the end of the semester you WILL know the material. Her lectures are fun, she is extremely smart and helpful and I've gotten A's in everything I've taen with her, because I try.

5.0
5.0
PLA1611
Jan 7, 2011

I love Professor Mestre. She is not easy! If you are not willing to work hard for your grade do not take her! As a matter of fact, if you are going into the Paralegal field do take her because if you can't handle her as a teacher you can't handle being a paralegal. She will treat you as an attorney in the work force will. Will take her again!!

5.0
4.0
PLA1104
Feb 14, 2011

If you're looking for an easy A, she's not the teacher. She is demanding and expects alot from you but on the flip side, she is extremely nice, very fair and gives you the tools to learn. You need to work for your grade. If you dont do outside studying, you are doomed.

5.0
3.0
BUL2241
May 6, 2011

She is awesome! You are sure bound to learn a great deal of material. There is work to do in her class and she requires commitment: it's college after all! She is super nice and will go out of her way for you. She is not impossible for students who are willing to put college-level effort in her class.

5.0
3.0
BUL2241
May 15, 2011

She is very clear in her expectations. She tells you from the very beginning that the first 2 exams are fairly easy (true)and the final is hard (true). The assignments are straight forward and require your time. If you want to leave the class knowing you learned something, this is the prefessor to have, if you want an easy A go elsewhere.

3.0
4.0
LAW2241
Jul 2, 2011

I am a very good student. I work really hard and have above average grades. I DO NOT recommend this Professor! Ridiculously demanding and WAY too much work. I am not lazy but did have other classes that needed attention as well. I dropped the Para legal program because of her!!!!

5.0
4.0
PLA1104
Jul 27, 2011

Mestre is a hard teacher there is no doubt on that i passed her class...but i do have to say i had to struggle a lot but at the end i must confess i learn a lot even though it was though class...she is a very nice person but she is very strict and very demanding but overall a great teacher!

5.0
5.0
PLA1104
Dec 15, 2011

She is a good professor, but very demanding. Expect to work very hard in this class. Follow the syllabus, ATTEND classes, DO THE HOMEWORK, and study study study and you will do well. Very practical coursework, but difficult if you fall behind. She is demanding but the level of work she expects is what is expected in the law office. Great class!

5.0
5.0
PLA1611
Dec 15, 2011

This was a challenging class, because the material is unlike anything else I've ever studied. The professor teaches and tests from her notes. ATTEND CLASS, TAKE GOOD NOTES and study hard and you will do well. She is demanding, but the level of work she expects is what you can expect working for a law firm. Very practical, and very informative.

5.0
5.0
BUL2241
Jan 4, 2012

I took Business Law 1 online over the fall. This was by far the hardest class I have taken. This class is very demanding. There are 3 test and they are worth 75% of your overall grade. STUDY,STUDY, STUDY or you will not succeed in this class. Very difficult but you learn a lot.

5.0
5.0
PLA1611
Jan 12, 2012

Wonderful person and teacher, but you must attend every class to do well! Do not buy the book, it is not used at all. Tests are from notes, which is why you MUST attend every class.

5.0
4.0
PLA2433
May 5, 2012

The class was very practical, and quite tough. Get the note packet as all of her tests come straight from the book. The tests are all multiple choice, but that doesn't mean they're going to be easy. My only complaint is that she didn't post grades on blackboard. Other than that I would recommend taking her.

5.0
5.0
LAWREAL
Jun 20, 2012

GREAT TEACHER YOU TAKE WHAT YOU LEARN WITH YOU. HER TEST ARE DIFFICULT BUT IF ONES STUDIES HER NOTE IT PASSABLE

4.0
5.0
PLA1104
Aug 2, 2012

This is my second time taking Mestre. I will not be taking her again. She is very difficult. Nice lady, but the work load is too much for someone that has a life outside of her class. Only take her if you absolutely have to.

3.0
5.0
PLA1104
Aug 6, 2012

Her lectures are structured well and she is real thorough in explaining the lessons. She has an assignment every week that all accumulate to 20% of your grade, a mid term and final worth 40% each. If you do not do well on one, you are out of luck. She could care less if you pass her class or not. Don’t take her if you don’t have too!

3.0
5.0
LEGALSUMM
Aug 29, 2012

If you can take someone else's class do so. Few chances to pass the class. Midterm and final, only 20% for homework. Long homworks, little incentive.She does not care if you pass, fail or withdraw. After midterm, 50% of class withdrew from class because there was no chance to make the grade. Any other professor would have been worried.

5.0
3.0
LAWBUS
Oct 15, 2012

She is an excellent professor! She is hard (it is college) but you will learn so much if you just study. I absolutely love her style of teaching and the amount of effort she puts forward on helping you pass the class. TAKE HER SHE'S THE BEST

3.0
4.0
LR1
Apr 23, 2013

I would take her again but you need to work. 1 Homework can take u 6-10hrs in the library. Do not take if you do not have the time. 20% HW, 40% mid and 40% final.

5.0
5.0
PLA1611PLA1104
Apr 26, 2013

She is a great teacher but very difficult. As tough as she is everyone seems to like her and take her again. She really does care about her students do well and tells you ahead of time what she expects. Be prepared to work hard but A's are attainable if you do what she asks. She is always available in her office and replys to all emails.

4.0
5.0
BUL2241
Jan 5, 2014

HARD HARD HARD. Must have LOTS of time to study her notes. I'm an A student and struggled. I took her online class-watch the online lectures, incredibly helpful! Quick to respond, hates being questioned. No joke when says 3rd test is hardest. STUDY!! Good teacher, but expects a lot. Don't procrastinate. I won't take her again. I did get a B+ though

5.0
5.0
BUL2241
Feb 26, 2014

Absolutely excellent Professor, cannot rate her enough. I took the class on-line. Watched all her videos of in-class studies which was the most helpful. It is like being in class with her. Take her notes, study all of them as they relate to the tests. 3 tests taken in an approved campus, study hard and you will get an A :-)

5.0
4.0
PLA2433
Grade: C
Dec 10, 2014

Professor Mestre is one of the toughest Professors I've ever taken. She is funny, witty, and expects success from her students. She is crystal clear from the start that this is a hard course, and whats needed to pass. Her tests are extremely tough, however, I'm leaving this class with so much knowledge and confidence. I will be taking her again!

5.0
4.0
PLA1611
Dec 10, 2014

Mestre is a great teacher she may be hard, but you learn a lot from her! midterm and Final exam are heavily weighted so make sure you know the notes well, I would recommend studying them before you know the test is coming because too much info. she is a great Professor i will take her again, just try not to take back to back classes in one day.

5.0
4.0
LRII
Jan 7, 2015

Most students sum up Professor Mestre with one word... HARD. I disagree. While the assignments given can be challenging, if you pay attention and follow the course work, you will pass. Mestre is clear about expectations, instructions and requirements. If you listen, take thorough notes and ASK questions when needed, you will do fine.

3.0
5.0
BUL2241
Grade: Drop/Withdrawal
Mar 24, 2015

If you must take BUL2241 but you have a full schedule including a full time job, along with taking care of a household don't take her!!!

4.0
4.0
PLA1114
Grade: Not sure yet
Jun 12, 2015

Skipping class is not an option. Not gonna lie - this professor is tough. You have to commit to this class. If you do the work required, though, it will pay off. She tells everyone right up front what's expected, so there shouldn't be any excuses. Lots of assignments without a lot of advance instruction, and LOTS of in-class group setups.

4.0
5.0
LEGALRESEARCH
Grade: C
Aug 7, 2015

Incredible individual with lots of experience. She expects a lot from her students. Home works take up to 8 hrs, and her test are hardcore. I'm an older student with vision issues even with glasses, so taking the test while being timed was a very hard issue for me. I failed the mid term, but had A's and B's on my assignments. I got a C in the end.

5.0
4.0
PLA1611
Grade: A
Jan 6, 2016

Professor Mestre isn't an easy teacher. She's also very upfront about that. Her test questions are specific and you really need to read them and go through each answer carefully. Study, take notes, and read test questions carefully and you'll do fine!

5.0
5.0
PLA1611
Apr 14, 2016

Extremely knowledgeable, great feedback and yes, she is STRICT in her grading. But after all it makes sense because the type of course you taking. Prepare to write a lot. Cathy Mestre's test are notorious for being hard, and they are.

5.0
4.0
PLA1114
Grade: Not sure yet
Jul 27, 2016
Would take again

Prof. Mestre, is the hardest professor I have ever taken. However, this has easily become my favorite class I have ever taken. Professor Mestre is witty, intelligent, and challenging. if you are looking for a class to pass without working too hard do not take this class. However, if you are looking to improve your writing and learn, take it!

1.0
5.0
BUL2241
Grade: F
Jul 28, 2016
Wouldn't take again

STAY AWAY FROM THIS PROFESSOR!!!!! She was by far the hardest professor I've ever taken. She does not care about anything outside of her class and the harshest grader. I literally forgot to put a comma in a sentence and she took five points off. All the notes you take in class will be your study guides. She talks fast so try to keep up.

5.0
5.0
PLA1611PLA1104
Grade: Not sure yet
Dec 9, 2016
Would take again

I took 2 of her classes this semester, taking 2 next and i love her. She gives A LOT of information and you are expected to know ALL of it, but it is all practical and has real life applications. Yes, she is a tough grader, but not for arbitrary reasons. If you're looking for an easy A, this is not the class for you.

Tough Grader
Respected
LECTURE HEAVY
4.0
5.0
PLA1104
Grade: A+
Dec 11, 2016
Would take again

Mestre is by far one of the most difficult professors I have ever had. In saying this, you learn so much from her that it is worth it. If you work hard in this class (legal research 1), you will pass it. Heavy lectures and quite a bit of library time for homework. The book helps TREMENDOUSLY and I recommend reading each chapter before every class.

Tough Grader
Skip class? You won't pass.
TEST HEAVY
4.0
4.0
PLA1611
Apr 23, 2017
Would take again

She is a great professor but you have to work hard in order to pass her class. There is no way you will pass a single test or assignment if you skip class, everything on the test is from class notes. She gives very hard tests and you have to think about everything you know and you really earned your grade.

Skip class? You won't pass.
GRADED BY FEW THINGS
LECTURE HEAVY
5.0
4.0
PLA1611
Grade: B+
May 1, 2017
Would take again

Professor Mestre is not a professor that is here to hold you hand and get you through college, that it Your JOB. You want the Grade, you will listen, take notes, good notes, study and do the homework. Her classes are not hard, intense yes, but in the end you'll earn the grade that you worked for,

Gives good feedback
Skip class? You won't pass.
Clear grading criteria
1.0
4.0
BUS3601
May 21, 2017
Wouldn't take again

Very nonstructural organization with assignments. If you are taking on a full course load and working to pay through school, she is not the professor for you. Her teaching method requires 100% attention, 100% of the time in order to pass her course.

Tough Grader
Get ready to read
Skip class? You won't pass.
1.0
5.0
PLA1104
Grade: Rather not say
Jun 22, 2017
Wouldn't take again

Absolutely horrible, do not take this class. Very few assignments for grading and poor instructions on how to do them. When you ask she will set you up for failure. The Midterm/Final are extremely hard, gives too many options for answers. Ex: all the above, none, A and C, C and B, just A. You have to study 24/7 . And will still fail.

Tough Grader
Skip class? You won't pass.
GRADED BY FEW THINGS
4.0
4.0
PLA1104
Grade: A
Jul 20, 2017
Would take again

Knows her stuff.

4.0
4.0
BUL2241
Aug 2, 2017
Would take again

I truly enjoyed her class. Yes she's tough. Yes she makes you work for your grade. But if you are taking this class for a law degree, having her would really make you see how bad you want it or not. Looking forward to having her again.

Tough Grader
Gives good feedback
Skip class? You won't pass.
4.0
5.0
PLA2433
Grade: B+
Oct 4, 2017
Would take again

Mestre is an extremely tough and knowledgeable teacher. You NEED to attend all the classes to pass, as all tests are from notes (and given study guide). She will instruct you better than anyone else, but will also demand much of you. Outside forces, beyond emergencies, do not affect her high grading standards. Prepare for hard tests and homework.

Tough Grader
GRADED BY FEW THINGS
LECTURE HEAVY
5.0
4.0
COS126
Grade: A
Nov 10, 2017
Would take again

Great teacher.

Gives good feedback
Respected
Amazing lectures
5.0
5.0
PLA1611
Feb 3, 2018
Would take again

Ive taken multiple classes by this professor and she is my favorite! Come to class and take notes, you will not be successful if you dont. Record the lectures and re-listen to them before the exams. She tell you everything you need to know and you will have no trouble if you are careful and read the questions slowly. You will learn in her class!!

Tough Grader
Skip class? You won't pass.
LECTURE HEAVY
4.0
5.0
PLA1114
Grade: A
Sep 25, 2018
Wouldn't take again

Mestre is extremely difficulty no matter the class. In general, she hands out a large note packet which she compliments with lectures; and demands you know it verbatim by exam time. In Legal Research 2, she gives a relatively brief lecture and gives an project which is reviewed next class, and due the following. There is a large final proj as well.

Tough Grader
SO MANY PAPERS
GRADED BY FEW THINGS
2.0
4.0
BUL2241
Grade: Drop/Withdrawal
Oct 4, 2018
Wouldn't take again

She is not very helpful to her students. I was extremely disappointed in this class and professor. Her video lectures are extremely old which make studying for tests hard and confusing.

Tough Grader
TEST HEAVY
4.0
4.0
PLA1104
Grade: A
Apr 27, 2019
Would take again

I've taken a few classes with Mestre - if you work hard you'll pass. Research assignment every week - one lecture (gives you notes/directions) & one library class to research. Make time to research inside and outside school for assignments, exams and sometimes there's only one book for assignments, can't stress this enough, that's why i passed.

Respected
Skip class? You won't pass.
Tough grader
3.0
4.0
PLA2433
Grade: C
May 3, 2019
Would take again

Cathy Mestre is a good professor. I learned a lot and her logic behind everything she does makes so much sense because especially with the assignments, she makes sure you know how to do them perfectly because when you go to be a paralegal, you will have to know how to do them. HOWEVER, she is very very tough. Her tests are super hard aswell!

Skip class? You won't pass.
Caring
Tough grader
5.0
4.0
PLA1104
Grade: A
Dec 19, 2019
Would take again

She has a great teaching method, she quizzes you on exactly what she mentions in her lectures. I RECOMMEND RECORDING ALL OF HER LECTURES. I cannot stress enough the importance of recording every single lecture, it is the best way to study for her tests. Also, make sure you have enough time to spend hours in the library completing the homework.

Lots of homework
Skip class? You won't pass.
Lecture heavy
2.0
5.0
PLA1611
Dec 21, 2019
Wouldn't take again

very hard test grader. If you don't take very GOOD notes recorded it. Her tests are very confusing. Very seldom will one of her test questions be easy. She likes using always, sometimes, never on her tests. Be prepared to be graded on assignments by a very detailed professor. She will find all your mistakes. She does provide good information.

Skip class? You won't pass.
Lecture heavy
Tough grader
3.0
4.0
PLA1611
Grade: B
Apr 2, 2020
Would take again

Real property was an okay course but if you have this class with her then you better be ready to write until your hand is numb.

Skip class? You won't pass.
Clear grading criteria
Lecture heavy
2.0
5.0
PLA1114
Grade: Rather not say
Apr 7, 2020
Wouldn't take again

This teacher and class will take up a lot of your time. If you miss a class and don't get a copy of the notes you will not pass the test. Her test are very hard and at times very confusing. If you make any mistakes when asked to cite a case for example if you miss a space between letters you miss 50% of the question.

Skip class? You won't pass.
Lecture heavy
Tough grader
1.0
5.0
PLA1611PLA1104
Grade: F
Oct 23, 2020
Wouldn't take again

Not many assignments but she wants you to memorize her lectures and notes. We are going through a pandemic some of us with kids at home while trying to go to school ourselves and she doesn't care. This teacher gives an extra heavy load of information to memorize and doesn't let you use notes for the test. Its overboard.

Get ready to read
Lecture heavy
Tough grader
5.0
4.0
PLA1611PLA1104
Grade: A
Nov 17, 2020
Would take again

Taking a Mestre class is a great way to stimulate thinking and growth. This is a healthy challenge that some students take as "too much work" when really, the small number of assignments given all but really help one for their midterm/final. Students are provided with EVERYTHING they need to succeed. The class structure is very well organized.

Gives good feedback
Respected
Amazing lectures
1.0
4.0
PLA1611PLA2433
Grade: Rather not say
Dec 17, 2020
Wouldn't take again

Even after reading all the notes, and listening to her lectures, there was too much material to memorize for the final. The midterm and final were the worst experiences Ive had with a professor, and online class, honorlock was used, this program made me uncomfortable while taking my exams, and to be honest it shouldnt have been necessary.

Test heavy
Lecture heavy
Tough grader
1.0
4.0
LAW1234
Grade: B
Feb 10, 2021
Wouldn't take again

Worst online experience ever. She says shes a hard teacher more times than actually explaining the material. Has no patience, when asked questions does not provide extra information than what she already gave. Zero empathy or understanding. All she cares about is having a hard teacher reputation (mentions it like 50x within the first week).

Lecture heavy
Tough grader
1.0
5.0
PLA1611
Grade: Drop/Withdrawal
Apr 15, 2021
Wouldn't take again

I would not recommend this professor to ANYONE. She doesn't help you at all when you need help, and she doesn't even teach a thing. I had one assignment where all of my answers were correct but she gave me a 62% on it because I didn't write my answers a certain way on a multiple part question so it would be easier for her to read seriously a joke.

Lots of homework
Lecture heavy
Tough grader
5.0
4.0
PLA2433
Grade: A
Apr 30, 2021
Would take again

Prof Mestre is extremely fair and very accessible. Her grading criteria & due dates are in the Syllabus. Mid term and final count for 66% of your grade. She post weekly lectures and notes and has an optional weekly 30 Min. Talk Time where you can ask questions. You will do well if you don't get behind. Watch lectures, read notes & book, etc.

Participation matters
Graded by few things
Amazing lectures
1.0
5.0
PLA1611
Grade: Incomplete
Aug 4, 2021
Wouldn't take again

Listen, take this professor at your own risk. DO NOT go into this class thinking you will get an A. She has weekly lectures and notes, four assignments and a midterm and a final which are both taken with HonorLock where you will be video and audio recorded. YOU CAN NOT USE THE NOTES or you will receive a "0". Class is made difficult for no reason.

Get ready to read
Graded by few things
Test heavy
1.0
5.0
PLA2433
Grade: Drop/Withdrawal
Aug 4, 2021
Wouldn't take again

Just choose a different professor. If you can take this class elsewhere DO IT! You must have time time to dedicate ATLEAST 8 hours a week to her class. STUDYING IS MANDATORY. Do not waste your money and save yourself the hassle. Test are hard. Please do not think I am an "angry student" I actually passed the class. Prof. will give you bad anxiety.

Test heavy
Lecture heavy
Tough grader
1.0
5.0
PLA1104
Aug 6, 2021
Wouldn't take again

Be prepared to review the material constantly. You have to pass the final and the midterm in order to pass this course. The final and midterm are hard and she does not provide a study guide and the tests are monitored. She is not reasonable for grading material pertaining to the assignments. Please do not waist your time and money.

Get ready to read
Test heavy
Tough grader
1.0
5.0
PLA2203
Grade: Drop/Withdrawal
Aug 6, 2021
Wouldn't take again

This class is structured by heavy lectures and notes. After reviewing all the material there is just too much information to retain for the midterm and final. This course is mainly set up to where you must pass both the final and midterm monitored by Honorlock otherwise, she will fail you. This was by far the worst online experience Ive had.

Participation matters
Graded by few things
Lecture heavy
1.0
5.0
PLA1611
Grade: F
Aug 10, 2021
Wouldn't take again

I am not saying this as an angry student but simply to help the next student out. If you can take this class different prof. DO IT. You would think dealing with COVID she would at least ease up a little. Do not waste your time or money or go into this class thinking you will get an "A". All I am going to say is take at your own risk. Good luck

Get ready to read
Skip class? You won't pass.
Graded by few things
4.0
4.0
PLA1611
Dec 1, 2021
Wouldn't take again

Her lectures and note packet are well done and easy to understand. Although having 66% of your grade depending on the midterm and final exam is hard, what she does with the learning curve is helpful. The one thing I dont like about her is her "You need to study, I am a difficult professor, no extracredit" vibe.

Test heavy
Lecture heavy
Tough grader
1.0
4.0
PLA1611
Grade: B-
Dec 4, 2021
Wouldn't take again

Take another professor if you can. She focuses too much on being known as the "hard professor" than actually wanting to help her students. Proudly brags that only 5-10% of her students get A's in her class. Her exams are honorlocked and she watches every single student take their tests, and then get upset when you talk aloud to yourself.

Skip class? You won't pass.
Graded by few things
Tough grader
5.0
4.0
PLA1114
Grade: A
Dec 8, 2021
Would take again

Take this professor seriously and take this class seriously. Make sure you attend, take notes and do the work. Students are negative about this teacher because she is tough and doesn't take a bunch of BS, but if you do the work you will actually learn! She is trying to help you become a professional paralegal, where a mistake can be very costly.

Participation matters
Skip class? You won't pass.
Clear grading criteria
5.0
4.0
PLA2612
Grade: A+
Jan 4, 2022
Would take again

Professor Mestre uploads lectures and notes which go hand in hand . You will not pass unless you stay up on both. She is very caring and provides all the tools needed for success but you must use them (lectures, notes, and weekly time to ask questions via Zoom). Mid term and Final are worth 66% of your score with only 3 projects/assignments.

Graded by few things
Amazing lectures
Lecture heavy
5.0
5.0
PLA2612
Grade: A-
Apr 18, 2022
Would take again

Professor Mestre is the reason why I entered the paralegal program. She is an outstanding professor! I took three of her classes and have a command of the material in my career. She's compassionate and loves her students. You will have to work very, very hard in her class, but you will be 100% prepared for the paralegal field. Please take her!

Amazing lectures
Inspirational
Accessible outside class
3.0
4.0
PLA2612
Grade: B
May 14, 2022

Professor Mestre is caring as others have said. However, I would recommend taking another professor if you can. The lessons are note-heavy, there's so much stuff to read. There aren't many assignments, the tests are worth a lot of your grade. She is strict and the constant talking about honor lock and reviewing the test can make students anxious.

Tough grader
Get ready to read
Lecture heavy
1.0
5.0
PARALEGAL
Grade: C+
Jun 23, 2022

Professor Mestre is HARD to understand. Her grading is UNFAIR Whatever she explained is NOT in the test EXTREMETLY HARD GRADER NOTHING IS GOOD ENOUGH ALL THE FORMS WERE WRONG IN HER EYES THE MIDETERM & FINAL ARE A TOTAL NIGHTMARE DO YOURSELF A FAVOR DO NOT TAKE THIS PROFESSOR EVER

1.0
5.0
PLA2433
Grade: Rather not say
Jun 24, 2022

Reads off her notes for the lectures. No examples of forms just gives us the assignments and expects us to know. If you do well on your assignment y grades are based on the midterm and final. I did my best have no idea what I learned. She is knowledgeable but more keen on hoping you withdraw.

Tough grader
Get ready to read
Lecture heavy
1.0
5.0
PLA1611
Grade: F
Aug 5, 2022

DO NOT DO IT! I wasted my WHOLE summer trying to please this professor and it was still wrong. I DO NOT RECOMMEND. If you can take this class elsewhere or with a different professor DO IT. Do not waste your money. It is either her way or the highway. I have NEVER had a professor that pushes you to withdraw. Take her at your own risk.

Tough grader
Get ready to read
Test heavy
1.0
5.0
BUS2201
Grade: F
Oct 24, 2022

DONOT TAKE HER. SHE WILL FAIL YOU. SHE IS THE WORST PROF EVER HAD IN MY WHOLE LIFE

Tough grader
1.0
5.0
PLA2433
Grade: Drop/Withdrawal
Nov 2, 2022

This Professor has multiple styles of teaching and testing. I received A's on all of my homework. I prepared for the midterm and failed. Using Honorlock caused undue stress in a field that won't require memorization. I learned more retaking the class with Prof. Higgins and got an A.

Tough grader
Group projects
Test heavy
2.0
5.0
PLA1611
Dec 15, 2022

She will not give back exams to let you see what you got right and wrong. I am sure that I got correct some of the answers that she marked wrong. Also, exam questions are extremely tricky.

Test heavy
Graded by few things
1.0
5.0
BUSLAWI
Grade: Drop/Withdrawal
Feb 2, 2023

not helpful! won't offer any guidance or further explanation to TEACH you. She loves to belittle those that do attempt to engage in lecture. It was awful to watch how she spoke down to others just trying to learn from her. I became too scared to ask questions myself. the other professors classes fill up fast cause everyone is trying to avoid her.

Graded by few things
1.0
5.0
PLA1611
Grade: Not sure yet
Feb 28, 2023

Professor Mestre has no understanding of how an actual law office works. This teaching style is absolutely counter intuitive to how you are expected to operate as a Paralegal. She will also require a win or take all approach regarding how the tests are weighed with 2 tests making up 60% of your total grade.

Lecture heavy
Test heavy
Graded by few things
1.0
3.0
PLA1611
Grade: Drop/Withdrawal
Mar 20, 2023

I have 2 degrees from VC. 1st time I dropped out because of a prof. Day1 she says online students cheat! She mentions cheating daily before the online proctored exam! Her emails, in large CAPS, repeats she will be watching us on camera. Her PARANOIA creates anxieties unnecessarily. Her obsession with cheating is alarming! She is self-projecting.

Tough grader
Get ready to read
Lecture heavy
5.0
4.0
PLA1611
Grade: A+
Mar 28, 2023
Would take again

Professor Mestre is a fantastic professor who structures her class so that her students learn and retain the material. Her class contains very well-rounded and applicable material. Course is challenging because property transactions require extreme attention to detail and precision. If you are dedicated to being a successful paralegal take her!

Tough grader
Clear grading criteria
Graded by few things
2.0
5.0
PLA1611
Grade: B
Apr 26, 2023

Difficult tests! The Midterm and Final are each 1/3rd of your grade. She also uses Honorlock, which as a nervous test-taker, only makes me more nervous. The test will have a lot of questions like: "Which of the following are false?". And there will be answer choices like "a and b", "a and c", "a, b, and c". So you really have to know your stuff!

Tough grader
5.0
4.0
PLA1114
Grade: A
May 9, 2023
Would take again

Prof. Mestre is an excellent professor. She gives detailed lectures which helps you understand the course. It's important to be present at the zoom meetings because she will explain everything in the meeting. You can ask her questions and she will help you. She wants you to grow, so it's not easy, but if you put effort in it you will succeed.

Participation matters
Gives good feedback
Lots of homework
1.0
4.0
PLA1611
Grade: B
May 13, 2023

Unpleasant experience. Ms. Mestre was clear from day 1 that online students cheat, and from there it became a weekly harassment about our tests. She details how we should behave in front of the camera during tests and she says she will watch you like a hock. Why so much obsession over this, instead focus on good teaching.

So many papers
Test heavy
1.0
5.0
LEGALRESEARCH
Grade: D-
Dec 4, 2023

She was one of the worst professors I have ever had during my time at Valencia she's extremely picky and unrealistic with some of the things she expects of her students. Her tests are super hard and you're timed she knows her students will not finish in time yet she gives you 1H to finish a final that's worth 40% of your grade DON'T TAKE HER.

Tough grader
Participation matters
Lots of homework
1.0
3.0
PLA2612
Grade: A+
Dec 20, 2023

I believe that Cathy does not know how to teach this class constructively she will grade you not on a correct answer, but if she "LIKES" your answer. That's a problem because nothing about this course is arbitrary. If you work or have a life outside of school, she will not work with you. I believe the high ratings for her are dishonest.

Group projects
Lecture heavy
Graded by few things
1.0
5.0
PLA2612
Grade: B
Feb 1, 2024

The WORST professor at Valencia. She tries to make the class as hard as possible. You only have two tests that are worth 66% of your grade and she will take questions from the article she attaches not the notes. Other teachers do not respect her and advised me not to take her but she's the only one that teaches this class.

Tough grader
Group projects
Lecture heavy
1.0
5.0
PLA2433
Grade: Rather not say
Feb 21, 2024

Professor Mestre ma

Tough grader
Graded by few things
2.0
4.0
PLA1611
Grade: D
Apr 25, 2024

This professor is so test heavy. she uses honorlock for online classes and the 4 assignments total for the whole semester are worth so much, if you don't do good on one assignment its crazy hard to bring your grade back up. doesent really teach more so gives you the info to earn and study it yourself.

Tough grader
Test heavy
Graded by few things
3.0
4.0
PLA1611
Grade: C
Apr 30, 2024
Would take again

2nd time I have taken this course with Prof.Mestre 1st time I was not that dedicated. This time I focused on her lectures and kept up with the notes and lectures. She was very helpful with questions and assisted another classmate to understand part of the lecture. Notes are based on her lecture. Advised is to keep up with the lectures.

Get ready to read
Clear grading criteria
Lecture heavy
1.0
5.0
PLA2203
Grade: A
May 2, 2024

She treats her students with no respect and prides herself on being a tough teacher. She will ignore questions, belittle you for mistakes, and makes a massive deal out of her highly monitored exams. I highly recommend you avoid her at all costs, because even if you work hard and try to succeed, the experience will be miserable.

Tough grader
Participation matters
Lecture heavy
3.0
4.0
PLA1611
Grade: B
Nov 26, 2024
Would take again

Professor Mestre's class is challenging, but engaging if you stay on top of the material. The exams are heavily weighted, so it's crucial to use all available resources like Unstuck ai to prepare. Attend lectures and take detailed notes to succeed.

4.0
4.0
PLA1104
Grade: C+
Feb 14, 2025
Would take again

She is very detailed in her instructions, but does not forgive mistakes, unless you can prove that there may have been a mistake on her part. She was very understanding of my disabilities, and let me make up some work after a seizure.

Tough grader
EXTRA CREDIT
Amazing lectures
4.0
4.0
PLA1104
Grade: C+
Feb 14, 2025
Would take again

She was very detailed in her explanations, and I appreciate her for taking her time and actually teaching. When it comes to tests she does give some leeway, by adding points depending on who had the highest grade. She also let me make up a test after I had a seizure and was very understanding.

Tough grader
Amazing lectures
Caring
1.0
5.0
REALPROPERTY
Grade: A
Apr 8, 2025

Do you want a professor who will criticize and belittle your questions and mistakes? Do you want a teacher that prides herself on being the "tough teacher" so that she has an excuse to nitpick? Take Cathy. You won't be disappointed. Her lectures are good, but interacting with her is like putting a toothpick under a toenail and kicking the wall.

Tough grader
Group projects
Test heavy
1.0
5.0
PLA1611
Grade: Rather not say
Oct 13, 2025

This class has no textbook and only goes off lectures the professor records.. it seems excessively over the top for an introductory course, and this professor appears to take pride in how rigorous and difficult the course will be. The entire grade is weighed on 4 assignments with NO room for error. Overall uncomfortable and terrible experience

Tough grader
Lecture heavy
Test heavy
5.0
5.0
PLA1104
Grade: Not sure yet
Dec 8, 2025
Would take again

I just finished Professor Mestre's PLA 1104, and one of the reasons I took it in person was to show her the kind of student I am, after just barely passing PLA 1161, 1003C due to pure slack. Her feedback can feel harsh at times, but it's like having a mirror held up to you, honest, constructive, & humbling. It pushes you to improve & become better

Tough grader
Test heavy
Graded by few things
Class Info

Online Classes

100%

Attendance Mandatory

78%

Textbook Required

57%

Grade Predictor

Your expected effort level

LowHigh

Predicted Grade

B-

95% confidence
Based on 41 grades
Most common grades:
A (12)
Drop/Withdrawal (8)
B (7)
Grade Distribution
A(16)B(8)C(7)D(10)F(5)A-/B+(3)
Based on 61 reported grades
A: 12
Drop/Withdrawal: 8
B: 7
Rather not say: 6
Common Tags
Tough grader (30)
Lecture heavy (21)
Skip class? You won't pass. (16)
Test heavy (14)
Graded by few things (14)
Get ready to read (10)
Tough Grader (9)
Participation matters (6)
Rating Trend

Declining

-1.50 avg change
May
Nov
Feb
Apr
Oct
Dec
Last 6 months
Ratings by Course

PLA

5.0

(1)

PARALEGALCLASS

5.0

(1)

PLARP1

5.0

(1)

BUSSLAW

5.0

(1)

LAWLAW

5.0

(3)
+30 more courses
Difficulty by Course

PARALEGAL

5.0

LEGALRESEARCH

5.0

LAWLAW

5.0

BUL2100

5.0

PLAALL

5.0

Similar Professors