2.0
Quality4.5
Difficulty14%
Would Retake205
Reviews14%
Would Retake
205
Reviews
Rating DistributionOfficial
5
18
4
19
3
23
2
49
1
96
What Students Say
“please avoid her classes”
151 - 1.0 rating“Collete Hyman is one of the worst professors I have ever had”
HIST151 - 2.0 ratingClass Info
Attendance Mandatory
93%
Textbook Required
70%
Grade Predictor
Your expected effort level
Predicted Grade
B-
Grade Distribution
Common Tags
Rating Trend
Declining
-0.46 avg changeRatings by Course
WOMENSHISTORY
5.0
(1)HIST385
5.0
(1)HISTHIST
5.0
(1)HIST400
4.5
(2)HIST212
4.0
(1)Difficulty by Course
220
5.0
NOMATTER
5.0
HST122
5.0
WESTERNCI
5.0
HIST341
5.0
Reviews (205)
No Comments
Interesting class. Doesn't really clarify what she wants, kind of shades away from giving answers. I noticed girls who read the material usually get higher grades then guys who read the material. Coincidence????
shes tough
worst prof i ever had
This woman is quite possibly the most one-sided, feministic, and liberal woman I have ever encountered. If you are thinking of taking a class with her, especially if you are not a girl or not a liberal, run for the hills. She's awful
No Comments
No Comments
She definitely tries to impose her views onto everyone else in the class. If u don't know much about history, and u can act like u know what your talking about, she'll like u and give u a good grade. Argue with her as much as possible.
This teacher is the worst I have had so far. She rambles on for the entire class time. No one is able to understand what her point is.-- stear clear of her!!
I am a boy and I passed this class... I don't know how, but I did. Make sure you read and do everything for class, or you WILL be kicked out and she will hate you for the rest of the semester... Good luck
Professor Hyman is unclear, not helpful. She is also very itimatating when asked questions aloud in class.
hmm. i didn't like her. i was afraid to participate in class for fear she would totally yell at me for not agreeing with what she says. i guess if you don't mind being yelled at for having a different opinion go ahead and take her classes.
Worst teacher ever! Grades hard, unclear, wants class participation but yells when you answer wrong, have to read every day and answer tons of questions, surprise quizzes, boring...
The worst teacher at this university. Hypocritical in the fact that she expects everyone to be as prepared as she is, yet she will get assignments to you late, and forget things lots, DONT TAKE HER!
I loved professor Hyman she was so great. Not kidding. If you get on her good side she will love you too!!! Yes she yells and makes you feel weak but if you yell back and stand up for yourself she will respect you so much more!!
Maybe not the easiest teacher, and maybe she hates you for just being you, but if you are willing to talk in class and be real, she will give you a real grade, and who knows, maybe she will give you a really good grade.
she scared me so much i dropped the class after one day.
Great Teacher
No Comments
JUST PLAIN MEAN!
I hate Colette for 2 history classes at Winona State. Yes, she is extremely opininated, and tends to dominate class dicussions with her own ideals - but this women is incredibly educated and the goal is to walk into her class with an open mind.
Whoa, scary lady! I was deathly afraid to attend her class. She yells and kicks people out of class for no reason. She intimidates people and then doesn't understand why they won't comment in her class? Hmm..I wonder.
This lady was scary. I dropped her class after a week because I couldn't take her. She's loud and her pacing makes me nervous. She yells for no reason and is very opinionated
Very opinionated, but intelligent and a fun lady to have class with.
She is scary as h*ll at first. However, just do your reading and BE READY TO TALK. Your chances of getting an A are almost zero, but a B or C isnt very hard. Just really listen to her and do what she wants, dont do what you were taught in the past.
I had her for two history classes. I was really scared of her at first, but after awhile she became my favorite teacher and a friend. I think what some people see as scary and intimidating is her way of making you think and learn!
Very difficult class and she's a little scary at first and sometimes I question her sanity, but she's great! You learn so much and she challenges you.
She is a really hard teacher. you HAVE to read. I swear she sniffs you out if you don't. Boys beware, she hates you. I felt bad for the boys in my class. Avoid her class if you can!!
HATE HER HATE HER HATE HER!! She is the devil
No Comments
Horrible woman.
Stand up for yourself she will respect you. READ YOUR MATERIAL. A is possible if you try. She doesn't hate men, she teaches history and history has ignored women, and that is what she is trying to teach. She does not baby anyone, even if she likes you, shw will let you know if she disagrees.
THe worst prof ever!! she kicks you out of class for not knowing a definition of a word. she yells and intimidates. HORRIBLE!!!!
She is a very demanding professor. But she is great and you really learn in her class.
Hardest class I have taken in 3 years. At least a chapter a day, in 2 books. She really intimidated me, I usually speak in class, but was afraid of her bias and pent up anger at men, so I didn't speak, which hurt my grade. BEWARE: she kicks people out, and yells like none other.
She is the most confusing professor I've ever had! Not only does her readings and her daily questions she give to you not make sense, she kicked over 90% of the class out for not knowing what a word meant! She is the devil!
MAKE SURE YOU READ! i dont like her, she grades almost primarily on how much you participate, but if you say something that she thinks is dumb, she'll make sure you know you're dumb for saying it. And if you do take the class, make sure you're on her good side.
She was very unclear and not too friendly!
make sure you know the definition of EVERY SINGLE word in the book or else she'll freak out and kick the whole class out...or she'll walk out herself...how stupid crazy is that.
yeah i registered to take her history 151 and then she came into my work and i said i was in her class and she said "oh your going to fail" so i dropped it. she is totally nuts! very rude to everyone. wasnt she placed on probation for failing alot of students??? im sure if she saw this shed laugh!!
IF you do the readings and are willing to participate in classroom discussions you will get a good grade. Just homework and 3 papers for the entire semester. Lazy people find a different class like one in High School
Very intelligent and educated woman. Do the work, and you have nothing to worry about. Most of the people that complain about her are the types that don't do their homework and expect to get away with it. Welcome to college, idiot.
Hyman's classes are hard but any good history class will make you read and wite alot. My problem was that in Senior Sem. she was a writting nazi who never really helped you improve but never held back on ripping your writting apart. Collette..if you want better writing help your students fix it.
The biggest ****!!! She sucks so bad! She is really hard and grades really mean. If you don't have her exact words you are lucky if you get a C. She always kicks people out of class. I would not take this class with her. ****!!!
she is tough, but good and nice to you if you put in the effort she wants.
nice lady outside of class. Get on her good side. Talk to her outside of class alot and no matter what class, pretend that feminism is your life and she will love you. She dresses so bad it's funny. Please tell me where i can get a pair of those hot pink tights and black leather biker boots!
Horrible teacher!If there is no other openings for the class and she is the only teacher still do not take her.She will walk out on the class if you don't know what "demagouges" means.And if you don't bring her book to class you will get kicked out, don't take her.
Very unpredicable and will start screaming at the class randomly. Frequently kicks entire class out.
just try to get on her good side so she doesn't tear you apart in class...
SHe thinks that she is doing a good job and sometimes is but freaks out over the littlest things. IN the first month of class she kicked us out of the classroom twice. If you don't say exactly what she wants in quizzes you get a C or lower
I'm a Male in her Class so that gives me a bad rep first off. Nice teacher if you aren't a prick to her. Will help you out of class if you need it, she will not look you in the eye though. She expects a lot out of her students. Take if you dare!
Expects alot of her students. You must read everything and be sure to take it in. Harsh grader but it's only because she wants you to do better. DO NOT GET ON HER BAD SIDE! As long as you go to class and participate and do everything she asks of you then you will be fine. Only take if you love hist.
Don't take her whatever you do!!!!! She kicked us out of class twice. i hated the class and would never take it again.
I've never seen a more immature teacher in all of my life. If you don't know something, dont dare to ask, because this **** will **** at you for not knowing everything until the end of the class. And then she will hold a grudge on you the rest of the semester. DON'T EVER TAKE A CLASS WITH THIS ONE
i changed my major to history but she almost made me not do it.
I was assigned to this teacher without a choice, bc the previous teacher was Christa, and then she completed sucide. Hyman is a very unapprochable person, makes a person feel insecure about themselves, favors feminists, DON'T take her. Unclear, & hard grader, even if you do everything that she asks.
Very VERY tough class, prepare to work your tail off for three measly university study credits. MUST READ FOR EVERY CLASS TO DO WELL. Tough tests, long papers...and she treats guys like dirt, and kicks kids out of class.
She expects a lot out of her students and so I actually learned something in her class. It's nice to have a prof who expects you to work hard and meet high expectations. I am a strong Christian and definitely not a feminist ... if she knew that I'm not sure she would have liked me so much
Point Blank the woman is an idiot
I women ever did anything in history I sure as hell dont care about it now! Way to go Hymen. By the way I am female.
One of the most unfair and unpractical teachers ever. Expects every student to LOVE history as much as she does. She doesn't realize some people are just there cuz they have to be. Also, has no respect for students, especially guys. Wouldn't recommend her to anybody.
No Comments
This will be part one of many. I loved the information, so informative and from a different side of history that you never get to reach. Hyman knows her stuff since she has written about it in countless articles and books. The only problem with her is that if you are not a feminist, liberal, woman or just a woman who is over 40 and openminded.
This lady is an idiot. I love history but she is absurd. She is not very clear when she speaks, she does not know much about European history, and frankly is not very nice. She also thinks that her class is the only one that you are taking. There is homework every night in some very strange history books. Try to avoid taking her.
I've never felt so degraded in all my life! She makes statements like "You're pathetic", "You cannot be blamed for you're own ignorance", and "Mommy and Daddy are paying for your tuition." These statements were not to just me, but to the entire class. She also will kick people out of class (or entire class) if they cannot answer her ?s. Avoid her!!
She is one of the most irrational teachers I have ever come across. She demoralizes all students in the class, never before Hyman have I been afraid to attend class for fear of being humiliated.
class is by no means easy she expects alot out of you. however it is not impossible to get an A i'm one paper away from doing it and am actually proud of myself. go to class, sit in front(scary but do it), answer or ask a few questions, and suck up a little. if you follow all these things you'll do just fine, it worked for me!!!
I thought this class would be easy, but she makes it more difficult than it needs to be. She makes you answer quesitons and come up with your own questions. If you dont answer a question or dont do your homework she will kick you out! If you dont suck up or get on her good side the first couple of weeks in class, good luck the rest of the year!
It's ironic: she assumes mommy and daddy are paying all our tuition? well, she's protected by her taxpayer protected roost in the ivory tower, and she takes total advantage of that. this is what happens when a professor goes unchecked in their power and authority. Orwell warned us against tyrannts like her. She's the biggest hippocrite.
Colette Hyman is not an easy teacher but the only reason most students don't like her is because she expects to perform at a high level--a level that teachers SHOULD expect of a college student. The work is hard but not impossible. She pushes you to do the work to your full potential and teaches you how to TRULY critically analyze what you read
Horrible instructor. If you want to go to class and get your intelligence insulted every day, go for it. She expects that you know everything about everything you were required to read, but yet come with questions. Does not make sense. Avoid her like the plague!!!
She makes you do things the hard way because she is not intelligent enough to learn a new way. Even though she is educated she is not intelligent.
Yes, Professor Hyman is extremely hard but if you apply yourself, read and thinkg about the texts and put forth honost effort in class you will come away with much learned. Of all the history professors I've had she has taught me the most. I've learned to critique evidence more thoroughly and respect the history profession even more because of her.
A great teacher who cares about her students. You need to go to class and go prepared because if you don't you will be asked to leave. As long as you care about being there and learning something you will be fine. Professor Hyman is tough but fair.
Strict and mean is different factor. Strict teacher gives us knowledge and skill, so he/she is helpful at last. However, Hyman is just mean. She demands us being "perfect." She has totally forgotten we are in her class because we are NOT perfect. Once she kicked us out. Once she told me to give F to me. I don't take her class any more.
listening to her talk was like nails on a chalkboard. do yourself a favor, and take a nicer history prof that won't constantly ridicule and degrade you, unless your stress level is low enough for you to take it!
She was very hard on all of the students. Be prepared to be called Ignorant, if you defend yourself she kicks you out.
Worst teacher I have ever had. Everyone is ignorant and if you dont have a question or dont answer her questions the way she wants you will get kicked out of class.
Yes Professor Hyman is a tough teacher and yes she kicks individuals and sometimes even the whole class out from time to time. Yes she makes me angry sometimes when she calls us ignorant. But she's really nice to you if you do the work and are prepared. She's also really nice outside of the classroom so go see her if u need help. And look up words!
Psycho, I learned nothing from this class other than I'm ignorent and worthless to this world as a human being, our entire class got kicked out numerous times for not knowing some word that she made up, kicks out individuals also, she mean, sarcastic, annoying, boring, must have been beaten as a child.
I strongly recomend not taking any of her classes unless you like endlesse reading, stupid New York TImes assignments due every friday, surprise quizes ( that almost no one gets an A on) and being called ignorant, swore at, and kicked outta class for simply not knowing the answer to a question or not having a question prepared for the reading.
Yells, wants participation, you need her exact words otherwise she will treat you like****. Worst experience I've ever had in any class in my life.
kicked people or whole class out at times... for not being 'smart' enough. she is really mean. but she will help outside of class if asked. has tenure so i think she stopped caring if she was a good teacher or not... or maybe she has always been a cold heart less old lady DO NOT TAKE
Professor Hyman is...confusing, irritating, angry and liberal. She kicks one out of the classroom if they are not prepared, which doesn't seem too hard to be..but it is in her class. I don't recommend taking her class if your stress level is even close to high. If you do..read everything and look up every word you don't know. Good luck.
Terrible Teacher!!!! She was the worst teacher i have ever had! She kicked people out of class if they werent prepared for class. She yelled at someone in my class because he shared a book with someone across the table and she got upset because he "wasn't able to read across the table". None of the class made any sense! DO NOT TAKE THIS CLASS!
Let's just say I enjoyed getting my teeth pulled more than going to her class! This woman has no right being a teacher. Whatever you do avoid this evil creature at all costs!
I took her class for about a week. I figured it was time to drop her class when she yelled AT US for the city newspaper having a typo! Avoid this class, seriously.
I really enjoyed Prof. Hyman's class. You will get what you put into it. She is a very intellegent prof who you can learn alot from. I wish I had her for more classes.
A very demanding Professor! It is a challenging class.If you don't like to read critically avoid this class like the plague! She is a very nice person outside the classroom but she is a shark ready to strike in the classroom!!
She is Horrible!! She calls us Ignorant and Naive almost everyday. If you didn't read the chapters I wouldn't go to class. She leaves class if your unprepared. DONT TAKE THIS CLASS UNLESS YOUR PREPARED TO TAKE HER ON!!!
Left class one day because students didn't know what the word collusion meant, kicks students out of class if you have not looked up random unimportant words that are not part of the history reading vocab words. Calls the class children and that she will only teach adults. Tells us we're never prepared to her standards.
Don't take this class! Kicks you out if you don't have have a question on the work or don't contribute to the conversation, no multiple choice tests or anything, just essays that will easily not be up to her standards. Whatever you write will suck....in her eyes. Stay Away!
She is CRAZY! Kicks people out of class for answering questions wrong, not knowing definitions and tells class how we have been failed in our lives. However, there are only essays to do and no tests. She is totally different at office hours, very nice and approachable. Expects a ton of commitment to the class and will spaz if you don't do it right!
I consider myself someone who has always enjoyed history, however this class took so much effort. HOURS of homework for every class. You use class time discussing everything you read as hw so don't think you can get by w/o doing it. While I did not appreciate her style of teaching, I did learn a lot. Lots of papers too.
This professor makes you very stressed out and feel stupid. She will actually call you stupid for not answering a question to her standards. DONT take this teacher. but if you do, here are some tips. participate EVERY class, suck up, go to her office hours for help and write down def. and write down notes, and try to have questions to ask her.
If you feel like being insulted for an hour three days a week take this class. She will make up words and expect you to know them. She will kick you out of class for any reason she can find. Impossible to believe she is still a teacher, she should be as far away from a university or people in general as possible. DONT TAKE THE CLASS
worst professor at winona. she is never wrong even if you prove her wrong with a fact in one of the books. kicks people out whenever she wants. DO NOT TAKE
Decent woman outside of class, a lot of reading to do but if you pay attention you will learn alot. Kicks people out of class, but there is a way to avoid it...do the work or ask questions. If you ask a question she will talk about it for ten min. No tests, only quizzes when people do not ask questions.
BEWARE! I get along really well with Prof. Hyman, but I would advise others to stay on their toes in her class. She is very demanding and expects you to talk. She will be downright mean to students who are not prepared for class.
The only way anyone can do decent in this class is by talking in class. She is bad at explaining the things you read and getting a good grade on her papers is only possible if she likes you. Wouldn't recommend taking her, she just insults her students all hour.
WORST PROFESSOR I HAVE EVER HAD! She treats her students like they are all ignorant. I don't think she is really happy about her teaching career cause it really shows with her mood. Overall, if you want to be interrogated at least once in your life take her. Doesn't teach the students anything because of her poor personality. Never wanted to go!!!
DONT TAKE HER!!! She is by far one of the worst professors at WSU. You will most likely learn nothing and waste a lot of money doing so. She should not be a professor!!! Period!!!
WORST PROFESSOR I HAVE EVER HAD! She treats her students like they are all ignorant. I don't think she is really happy about her teaching career cause it really shows with her mood. Overall, if you want to be interrogated at least once in your life take her. Doesn't teach the students anything because of her poor personality. Never wanted to go!!!
DO NOT TAKE HER!!! She is the worst professor by far. I think she hates her job. I wish WSU would get rid of her. If you don't answer her question exactly the way she has in her head then you are basically a dumb ass! She is very rude, inconsiderate, belittles all students. She doesn't teach a thing. All you do is get riducled by her
Words cannot describe how much of a b*tch she can be. Her attitude towards her students and how she treats us disgusts me. It's true that we lean A LOT from her, but when students are afraid to go to her class it's pathetic. Her grading literally depends on her attitude and how her week has been going. AVOID HER AT ALL COSTS! TOO MUCH STRESS!!!!!!
!!! AVOID IF POSSIBLE !!! At first I thought the class would be fine and I could handle her, but two weeks into class, she has already sent a kid out. It is a very heavily reading outside of class kind of course with discussions daily. If you can't sit down and read a history book for an hour or two, don't take her class.
Avoid, she is a lady that means well but is a complete b****. Awful at teaching and expects that we live our lives dedicated to her class. If you have 3 hours a night to do her assignments and want to feel disrespected go ahead. Worst professor I have ever had.
She is a horrible women! I usually put in 2-3 hours each night per assignment, and I still go to class the next day being criticized by her telling me that I didnt put any effort into my assignment. I wish I would have went to this cite before I took her as a teacher! DO NOT TAKE HER!
DO NOT TAKE!!! Her class emphases is discussions, but she singles students out and blames them for not reading. She clearly states how no one belongs in college and that we are all ignorant. Your quizzes are an automatic F if she is in a bad mood and expect your one page papers to take hours to achieve a high C.
If you want the worst semester of your life, feel free to take a class with this woman. She's the most disrespectful, hateful and evil woman I have ever met, I was told prior not to take her class and I figured I could handle her, the truth is, no one can, she is without a doubt in my mind, the worst professor I've ever had!!!
Words cannot describe how much she can make you hate her and her class. She is totally disrespectful and treats her students like crap. I would never recommend her to anyone, ever. I hope she reads this and tries to understand how much she really "means" to her students and attempts to change her crappy behavior and teaching skills.
Many people do not get along with her. If you show up to class,do the readings and participate you should be fine. YOU MUST DO THE READINGS!!!!!!
possible to get an A,u just REALLY have to work for it-and suck up and talk to her in her office. u can spend hrs on a 2page paper & get a c, but she lets u make corrections.do EVERY reading, if u dont and she calls on u in class,u will be on her bad side,which =F.talk inclass everyday & ask ?'s.do all optional papers.she treats it like a 300 class
This Class was SO difficult. I took it as a first year freshman which made it even worse. However if you get to know her on a one to one basis she seems to like you more. You have to be at every class and read a ton! If you are in this class form a study group because you'll need it!
While she undoubtedly has high expectations for her students and holds them to a high standard, nothing about those standards is unreasonable. You must always be prepared for class, but that should hold true for EVERY class you attend, regardless of the professor! Her goal is not to "torture" her students, but to give them an excellent education.
Great professor! She is always more than willing to help students who want to learn. Always come to class prepared, ask good questions, know the vocab, be polite, and you will do fine!
Tough but helpful, and she truly cares about her students. I learned more in this class than all my other classes put together.
Amazing professor- definitely makes the study of history fun and interesting. She is very dedicated to teaching, and I would definitely recommend her classes.
Do not take her!!! She is one of the worst professors I have ever had. She expects from her students to treat her with respect but does not do the same for them. She thinks all students are ignorant and never do their work. For a 100 level course it was very hard and her expectations too high. Took the fun out of history for me!!
Impossible teacher. Do not waste your time taking her classes unless you really love the topic and you have no problem understanding the subject. She belittles students and tries to call you out in front of the class to embarrass you.
I'm rather amused at all the raters who seem to think that Prof. Hyman is evil incarnate. This course is definitely challenging, but she's a good teacher and always makes sure that everyone is clear on what she expects for assignments. She's also very helpful and a fair grader.
People actually found her hard? LOL! Just show up and participate in class and you won't find any issues with this teacher.
DO NOT TAKE HER!!!!!!! She talks down to everyone like we dont know a thing. She is inconsiderate to anyones time. She will call you out in front of everyone if you dont do something right. She demands way more than any prof. ever should.
Hyman is not an easy teacher, and she has high expectations. But seriously people, we are in college. If you do the readings and go to class prepared, you will be fine. She likes people who participate and ask questions! Hyman is very knowledgeable and passionate about the course topic. And yes, she CAN be nice. Just don't get lazy!
Everyone seemed like she was the worst teacher on campus; however, I was going through some rough times during my freshman year and had it not been for her I would have quit. She was very understanding and accommodating! With that being said DO THE READINGS SHE ASSIGNS AND ASK QUESTIONS!!! Good Luck :)
Great professor. Teaches you to think critically. the book choices are always interesting. Not boring classes. Great conversations and debate.
Very rude teacher. Calls people out and embarrasses people. She will stop lecturing and call you out if you yawn in class. She expects you to look up every word that you do not know in the dictionary. If you dont know what a word means then she will have a random quiz on the word meaning. This class is mainly writing papers Avoid at all costs!
She was not good, hard and random quizzes on vocab! Read the chapter and write down and look up every word you dont know!
Don't take her. Class requires tons of reading and theres always something you don't know that she expects you too. A random word in the reading could be on a quiz. I don't know if she actually wants you to be successful either. Were all just stupid college students and if you don't know as much as her, (a history professor) your not doing enough.
Don't take her. She's rude, and isn't compassionate. She expects way to much and calls out people just for answering a question the "wrong way". Everything has to be her way.
Don't take her.She asked me to rewrite a 5 page paper because I didn't exceed the requirements, She isn't a mean person but her expectations are unreasonably high. She gets mad at the class if no one answers her question after 10 seconds,she has pop quizzes if the class is quiet that day, or if not a lot of people show up.
Impossible to get an A in the class. I felt like it was impossible to get an A on a paper. She is an insanely hard grader and has pop quizzes that you will fail if you don't ask questions or if the class is quiet. She embarrasses students if you answer her questions wrong. There are no tests so there was no reason to listen to her in class. AVOID!!
This class will be by far your worst class that you have ever taken at WSU. It made me hate my first fall semester because of the amount of work she had us do. She expects so much out of you and will embarrass you in front of everyone if you answer the question wrong or not paying attention. I would avoid at all costs; not worth it in the long run.
Was looking for an easy class to start my freshman year of college after serving 6 years in the military. The course itself is simple. After doing 6 years Army I know when I am being disrespected. This professor doesn't treat her students with respect but demands it from you. She has double standards and was 12 minutes the first day of class.
Professor Hyman is the worst professor I have ever had after being in college for three years. She is disrespectful and rude to students. If a student says the wrong answer to a question she calls them out in class and is not understanding at all. If you don't agree with her opinion you're out of luck. I would avoid her at all costs.
She was the worst teacher I have ever had. I would recommend staying away from any class with her as a professor. She is very disrespectful to students and you have to have her point of view otherwise you are wrong. She points you out in class and is very rude to students. I wouldn't not recommend her for any class at all. Ignore if possible!
DO NOT take this class if you are not a history major. :/ You will be expected to read her material in depth and ask insightful questions in class - this is very difficult for science majors! On top of this, she is very intimidating, disorganized and expects A+ work at all times. I will not be taking classes from her again.
Professor Hyman is literally one of the worst professors I have ever had. You have about a paper due at every single class period (MWF). She is very tough and very rude. Not compassionate or nice to students. She calls you out and if you answer the question in your opinion it is wrong. It has to be in her opinion and to her standard.
Professor Hyman is very tough and at times rude to students, but you learn a lot about the material and life in her class. You MUST come to class prepared or you will not like her or the class at all.
She is rude, and asks a lot. But it's not a hard class, I barely read, and barely tried on the papers and I got 78% in the class. I wouldn't suggest taking her, but everyone says she's worse than she actually is.
Honestly this class made me doubt my major. The class itself wasn't hard but her expectations from freshman are way to high. I do agree at times she can be rude and incredibly intimidating. One on one she's a great person. In class she's a different story. She doesn't like her students opinion's. I won't be taking a class instructed by her again.
Well you had better be prepared every day, otherwise if not she won't hesitate to kick you out of class. Very inconsiderate, its her way or the highway, no opinions other than hers will even be considered. Also she thinks the only thing worth learning is any material involving Native Americans or women's rights. please avoid her classes.
Collete Hyman is one of the worst professors I have ever had. She disrespects her students and expects her students to give her the utmost respect. Hyman is one of the hardest graders I've had while taking a 100 level course. This course should be called "Civil and Women's rights in U.S. history". Because this is literally all she teaches about.
I wouldn't recommend taking her but if you have to its not horrible. You have to read a lot of boring books. She calls on students and your answer has to be correct otherwise she keeps asking why? This class has a lot of discussions. I got an A and I barely read the books but I did the papers.
Professor Hyman requests the utmost respect, but disrespects students every class period. You will need to attend three on campus events, she DOES NOT care if you have other obligations. What Hyman says, goes. Prepare to be cut off mid sentence when asked to answer a question. Do not take Hyman under any circumstance. You will not learn anything.
Professor Hyman is a very tough grader. Not a good class to take at all. You will have homework to do everyday of class and many papers to write based on out of class activities. You must have the reading prepared always because she will target you in class and continue to target you if you answer her question wrong. Not very understanding at all.
Professor Hyman is probably the worst professor I've ever had she has no respect for you. As well as she assigns more essays than english, she doesn't respect your opinions and it was such a stressful class and I would avoid her classes at all cost.
Do not, I repeat, DO NOT take this class with her. Makes you feel like a complete idiot if you don't answer her question EXACTLY the way she wants it answered. Also, if you didn't completely finish the work or reading assigned for that day, don't bother coming to class as she will not hesitate to call you out and proceed to kick you out of class.
Professor Hyman is the absolute worst professor I've ever had in my time here at WSU. Very inconsiderate and does not have a heart at all for her students. I understand that this is college and we must be able to do college level work but her expectations for a 100 level course are ridiculous and unrealistic. Avoid her classes at all costs.
She may not be the easiest professor but she is nothing compared to your next boss. Taking her classes which I have taken multiple times teaches one to think critically so think before he or she speaks, and that your ideas maybe shut down if they are not good enough. This is college and you should be prepared to be an adult.
Read read read. Ask questions during office hours if asking during class seems intimidating. I learned so much from her. Take notes while you read, and then have your notes open during class discussions.
Do not take her, she is bad. I would rather delay graduation by a semester then take her again. She will go on rants about how students are not worthy of her lectures. Don't laugh when she does this or she will kick you out of class.
Hyman is an amazing human being but she is a very demanding professor. She can be very demeaning towards her students. She likes letting students know that she is smarter than them so they feel dumb. Do not get on her bad side or she will make your life in her class miserable.
The first thing you must know about that class is that it is more of an English class than an American History class. Normally of love history classes but this is the exception. She will target you in class if you answer a given question wrong. If you come to class without the study questions answered, she will lecture the whole class!
By far the worst professor you could ever have. She uses her big vocabulary to ridicule students if they answer a question or ask one in a way she doesn't agree with. Very liberal, which gets annoying fast. Stay away from Collette Hyman. My friend tried to get me to drop the first day, took my friend and half of a semester to realize he was right.
This was by far the hardest class I have ever had. You have weekly writing papers and other major papers. She is a very VERY tough grader and will take many points off if you have more than one error per page. Very frustrating feeling like you'll never do well, many tears were shed. I would rather take a test than write papers weekly. Do NOT take!!
Dr. Hyman is not worth your while. Don't get me wrong, she is a very smart individual but she consistently puts her students down and expects a lot from you. Her class is all writing and she's a very difficult grader and doesn't explain what you are doing wrong. She is quoted many times saying that we were "pathetic and sad". Do not take her!
Dr. Hyman is the absolutely the worst professor at WSU. She will make you fell like you are nothing if you answer a question wrong. She has no heart for her students. She is not afraid to kick you out of her class if you did not do the hw. she is a very tough grader and the rubrics aren't clear. Overall, I recommend avoiding her at all cost.
Dr. Hyman makes you feel like an idiot if you don't understand the reading or just a topic in general. If you don't agree with her opinion on something than don't open your mouth. Very rude and doesn't care about her students in the slightest. Lots of reading and study questions that she won't even get to in class. Stay clear of her for any class.
I'd have to agree with others when I say that I will NEVER take any of Professor Hyman's classes nor would I recommend her to anyone ever again. She is very rude to her students openly. I at one point in the semester was struggling mentally and went to her office to talk to her, and she proceeded to yell at me and demean me. Should be fired.
She is just mean. If you don't agree with her opinion you won't pass. You have to do a lot of reading, and write a paper each week. She will yell at you if you don't know the answer. Also, if you are not paying attention, or did not do the homework you will probably be kicked out of class. She doesn't care if you pass the course.
She is by far the worst professor I've ever had. You get multiple papers a week, she will call you out in class and degrade you in front of everyone, she will kick you out for disagreeing with her. I asked about a midterm, she said we didnt have one, then D2L popped up that we had a midterm paper due for her class in three days. RUN, FAR AND FAST.
her course is more like a Q and A about the textbook, than an actual lecture. and she assigns study questions that do not relate to the readings. she put all the wrong books on the site and the wrong schedule, so we spent $120 on textbooks not required for the class. also she is incredibly rude to her students and will gladly point out your flaws.
No tests, grade is solely based on papers you write about the readings. There is a lot of reading assigned, almost a new assignment every class. Each textbook was used for maybe a week each. Will not hesitate to single you out if you don't get the correct answer. Stay away if possible.
I got a B with her without trying all that much (ignored most of the reading), and she knows the material well, but her attitude can sometime be off-putting enough for me to not recommend taking her courses.
By far the worst professor you will ever have. she doesn't care if you pass or fail. She grades based on papers you write and discussions you have. If you don't understand a concept she will NOT explain it. If you have a different opinion than her she will most likely fail you. Also, if you get a question wrong during a discussion she WILL yell!
I would never recommend taking this course with her. She is extremely disrespectful towards students. Your grade is solely on your writing skills. If you don't give the exact answer she is looking for she will yell at you in front of the entire class. She also will not help you when you have a question. Overall, its her way or the highway.
She does a great job of answering her way around questions without actually answering. She is smart in what she teaches that is obvious (I am not taking anything away from her PHD.) But she talks down to students for no reason. If you happen to answer a question in class that is slightly off she will cut you off and belittle you. SHES A BLAST! not.
Graded on weekly writings and longer papers (0 quizzes/tests). Very much a critical thinking and active discussion class, even for an intro-level course. You had better have the correct answer and an explanation before you answer. Grading criteria for papers is rather unclear. Insists you use your notes even if topic wasn't discussed in class.
If you don't participate she will get mad. If you say something that is incorrect she will let you know you are wrong.
She seems to know what she is talking about but doesn't know the right way to teach others. Her grading criteria is unclear, and she does not do well at answering questions. Class discussion is a huge part of your grade, but if you answer wrong or with a different opinion than her she will get mad and belittle you invfront of the entire class.
Dr. Hyman does not know her boundaries and treats her students like little puppets she can play with. Would not recommend her class.
You're better off changing your major, literally. Like everyone said before me, she is blatantly rude and treats you like an idiot for not understanding the most complex of subjects and if you ask for help or guidance, you get shut down instantly for even asking. She is verbally abusive and has caused me to have multiple panic attacks. Don't do it.
I cant believe WSU tolerates a teacher like this, you would think after awhile they would do something. Colette Hyman will make your life as hard as she possibly can. She is of little help to students and makes assignments that are very vague in instructions, she expects you to write papers that of Harvard level quality in an intro level class.
The worst professor that I've ever had, history is something that I enjoy learning but she made me hate the class because of the way she degraded her students. The class is based solely on your writing skills but when asking for help on papers in her office hours, she will yell at you and won't offer much assistance.
absolutely god awful woman. Please do not take this class, she is very dissrespectful and has no care for her students at all. she gave us probably 15 papers but only graded 3 in the end of the semester so all that work is for nothing. worst teacher i ever had DO NOT TAKE!
She hates President Trump and refuses to acknowledge any of his accomplishments. She's an all around bad teacher, and if you're conservative at all, you put a target on your back immediately.
Changed my major as a senior and this class was required and was looking forward to it because I love history. NOPE! She is by far the rudest teacher I have taken in my time here at Winona. She treats every student so terrible for minor slip-ups. She acts as if her class is the only class we should care about. Disrespectful, Rude, Terrible AVOID
I personally really liked Professor Hyman. She expects a lot out of her students, but I learned a lot from her and respected her. Do what you need to do, read the readings, turn in your papers, and participate in class. She was always clear and straightforward with what she expected.
She has expectations that nobody meets. DO NOT TAKE!!!
She is the absolute worst professor I have ever taken. She told me that I was going to be unsuccessful in life in front of the class because I didn't answer a question the way she wanted it to be answered. She has made me cry multiple times and others as well. We started with about 17 in the class and ended with 3 people. DO NOT TAKE!
If you participate you'll be on her good side. Write good papers and do your homework and you'll be liked by her. She gets mad easily and forces her own political beliefs through her touchings on students.
very intimidating professor. For a 100 level class, she expects too much from her students. teach yourself from the book. She words her questions very oddly and if you do not respond in the way she wants she will belittle you in front of class. Not understanding of personal issues and believes her class is superior to anything else going on in life
She is an awful person who is not willing to hear anything other than her beliefs. If you don't say exactly what she is thinking you are wrong and she will let everyone know it. She openly yells at and degrades students who cant answer her questions. She grades on a few papers with her own grading system. She will fail you and not tell you why.
Just don't take a class with her. She will give you a terrible grade and make you feel stupid. :)
NEVER TAKE HER. I am an all around good student, I have a 4.0 and do pretty well in school. As a future teacher I have no respect for how she treats her students and how she makes them feel. She will make you feel stupid and treat you like crap. AVOID AT ALL COSTS. If you have to take her, good luck, get on her good side fast.
Shes a very opinionated professor who pushes her agenda for the entirety of the semester. She takes every chance to call out students and make them feel inferior. She gave terrible feedback on papers and expects perfection in a 100 level class. She hates athletes. I am and athlete and she picks on me constantly and told one of my teammates to drop.
Do not take her. At first I read all of these ratings and thought Oh, college kids are just whining nope. Theyre right on the money with Hyman. She is terrible. She harasses students for trying to come up with their own answers to her absurd questions (3-4 at a time) when she asks them. DO NOT TAKE HER.
Disgusting. Horrible. rude. yeah that is about it
She is by far the worst professor I have had yet. She gives you a book for all the homework to go and read. Then you come to class and have discussions. She will randomly call on you and discourage you all she can. Her essays she gives out are very political and I had to go against my beliefs to fulfill hers. DO NOT TAKE!
If you enjoy history, take this class! I truly believe that she has the potential to be an amazing professor, however her cocky and arrogant attitude gets in the way and makes class almost unbearable. Be prepared to be publically humiliated if you say something she doesn't agree with. If you think you don't have to read, you're wrong.
She's very intelligent and knowledgeable in her field. I'm not surprised that only three or four people show up to class daily because nobody wants to deal with her. The class itself isn't overly difficult but she makes it difficult by asking questions in a confusing way and going out of her way to berate students for things they could learn from.
By far the worst professor I have had at WSU. She berates students and humiliates them for not being able to answer and awkwardly phrased questions. Be prepared to have PTSD for participating in discussions.
Her expectations seemed unclear in her lectures, but if you went to her syllabus or docs explaining assignments, everything was spelled out exactly how she wanted it, you just had to pay attention to the DETAILS within her written directions. She was available to make clarifications and to discuss any questions or concerns. Come to class prepared.
As long as you did the reading and were prepared for class, class was great. You definitely got the grade you earned with the effort you put forth in class and maintaining contact with her for questions and further clarifications. She would even look over assignments to see if you needed adjustments before turning in for the final grade.
She is an unbelievably mean professor. I dropped after one class - I hadn't done the first assignment cause I was out with covid and figured I would show up to learn in class. (she knew I was out with covid). she belittled me and yelled at me in front of the class then took me to her office and yelled at me. NEVER TAKE THIS PROFESSOR - PTSD
People like to judge knowledgeable women harshly in academia, so I ignored these reviews. However, she is a great example of a professor that inspires you to become the exact opposite of her as a teacher. She publicly humiliates students when they misunderstand her vague questions. There is a reason her courses are always empty. Do not take.
Liberal.
I have read every review on Dr. Hyman and they're not wrong. She will call you out, she will belittle you if you don't know the answer. But if you try, she will see it. Somewhere in her tough heart she does see you trying. I did the homework and she liked me. She taught me a lot and I actually felt like I learned something in her class. Just try.
Took this class my first semester of college, the experience I had made me want to drop out.
Hyman pulled me out into the hall and told me I would not exceed as an adult. She is rude and every time I bring Hyman up to any other prof they know and agree with me. So why wont WSU do anything about it. Worst prof on campus, avoid at all cost.
When the class started, there was 18 of us or so. at the end of the first month, it was only two. She is rude, confrontational, and if you don't answer her vague questions exactly right, she ridicules you
She is a really tough grader that makes you think about the questions between the lines. Like she creates study questions and asks many questions with multiple build-off questions. She does not give test, but give many essays in compensation, also with really tough grading.
Took this class in 2020 and have since graduated. Prof Hyman left a big impression on me and made me question my views, the language I use, and my work ethic. I credit a lot of my success in college to this professor. She sees when you're trying and pushes you when you need reinforcement. She won't be your friend - she‘ll make damn sure you learn.
I'm 99% sure most if not all of her positive reviews are just her anonymously boosting her abysmal ratings. All she has taught her students is what not to be. Rude, confrontational, vague yet asks for perfection, and unhelpful. She has retired from WSU and I honestly hope for the sakes of future history student, she stays retired.
Class Info
Attendance Mandatory
93%
Textbook Required
70%
Grade Predictor
Your expected effort level
Predicted Grade
B-
Grade Distribution
Common Tags
Rating Trend
Declining
-0.46 avg changeRatings by Course
WOMENSHISTORY
5.0
(1)HIST385
5.0
(1)HISTHIST
5.0
(1)HIST400
4.5
(2)HIST212
4.0
(1)Difficulty by Course
220
5.0
NOMATTER
5.0
HST122
5.0
WESTERNCI
5.0
HIST341
5.0