Tends to get behind schedule, but he's a cool, reasonable prof. Try him.

Davis Scott is a very laid back, down to earth guy. He's a bit unorthodox, but

interesting and engaging, seems like he loves what hes talking about

No Comments

He's great!! I love his lectures and he's funny too.

In-depth. In whole-year 100 level phil class we studied at most six philosophers

nice guy will to discuss anything until everyone understands

No Comments

Scott is a random guy but he is a really genuine person who loves what he's doin

funny, explains everything well, great guy

Good course, and a cool teacher. Smart guy...

Boy howdy... Dave's a tough nut to crack, but once you catch on to what he's actually saying its pretty mindblowing. Don't underestimate him. Cool dude.

Very thorough and clear. He initially seems like he has no clue, but don't be fooled. Leads you to the answers and inspires plenty of criticism. Made an otherwise painfully boring class pretty interesting.

DR SCOTT IS THE HOTTEST PROF IN THE PHILO DEPT. DONT LET THIS DISTRACT YOU FROM WHAT HE HAS TO OFFER INTELLECTUALLY...HE'S ONE OF THE FEW PROFS WHO IS ACTUALLY WILLING AND HAPPY TO HELP WHEN YOU NEED IT

At first Dr. Scott seems vague and many of his comments seems unecessary, but once you do the reading and pay attention you realize that he is handing over brilliant comments on the material, making clever jokes, and is really helpful outside of class.

Dr Scott's class is however easy or difficult you make it. He doesn't force you to work or to learn but if you pay attention to the issues he raises, although they may seem mundane, may hold more than meets the eye. Very helpful prof.

I graduated a couple of years ago from UVic and still remember the absolute pleasure of taking a Rationalists class with him. I can honestly say he's one of the best profs I've ever had. Fascinating guy, excellent teacher.

Great phil prof. Makes the issues clear. Fair marker. (I found it helped to take notes in class and look back)

Brilliant

natural-born actor, very good at explaining abstratc concepts. Well-organized lecture and willing to help.

Good Guy, very helpful. Class gets a little confusing but if you pay attention and ask questions it shouldn't be too difficult. Fair marker and actually marks stuff himself instead of the TAs doing it.

Scott takes great time (often long pauses) and care to find the right words. He is intensely analytic and is inclined to depth analysis of a few key passages; he is incompatible if you like to gloss over the material. Expectations on tests and papers can be unclear, but he is extremely helpful in office hours.

Had him for 303+306 this semester. Outstanding teacher. So he mumbles a lot and writes a lot of random lines and arrows pointing nowhere on the blackboard...who cares? He doesn't spoon-feed students, you need to want to learn to learn from him. If you go to class and pay attention, you'll take a lot from his classes. I fully recommend Dr. Scott.

Excellent introduction to Aristotle. Scott set up the philosopher's system as something total and all-encompassing. The class actually built towards a climax (beginning with the categories, physics, and then building towards the de anima, metaphysics, and ethics). It was a very satisfying method to learn Aristotle as holistically as one can.

This man is permanently flustered. If nothing else, come to class for his failed attempts at pop culture references. I eagerly await the day he writes something legible on the board. WHERE ARE ALL THE ARROWS POINTING?! Still, he makes many interesting points and does a great job at explaining difficult concepts. You can't help but find him adorable

One of the best profs in the department. Lectures are energetic, learned, hilarious, riveting, wise. As a friend says, David doesn't teach; he does philosophy. In case you think me a flunky, here are my bona fides. I'm at the end of my philosophy degree. I'm a full blown naturalist antipathetic to rationalism. My grade in this class is not great.

Anyone who doesn't like Prof. Scott is not a good person. It says something about you if you don't like Prof. Scott, not him. He's charming, charismatic, energetic, lively, insightful and just mesmerizing. As someone already said, take good notes, if you don't do well, you're not intelligent at all, get out of University and learn a trade.

Hes a great teacher. Laid back and into his teachings

Goofy and endearing, makes difficult concepts as clear as possible and develops your love of Philosophy to the level of his own. I don't know how you could not like him an his genial demeanor.

The best professor in the department. Brilliant.

Phil majors should take 306 with David. His lecture style is indirect but all the more instructive for that. He makes an art of close reading, selecting a few key paragraphs that he tills deeply through the term. He's one of the three most memorable profs of my undergrad career. Rigorous, caring, insightful, modest. A+.

Disappointed by the negative reviews on here-Scott is a wonderful prof, passionate and eager to help. His classes do require some critical thinking on your own part, but it's a third year philosophy course, soo... Highly recommend his class, it's fun and engaging. Do the work, participate in class, and you'll do fine.

He is one of the few professors in the Philosophy Department that make philosophy fun. I will grant that his lectures may seem like he goes off topic and talks about random things, but in reality everything he talks about is important in the class.

I must reaffirm a previous commenter, if you did not like David Scott it says more about you than Scott. A wonderful man. Really passionate about his class, willing to challenge students. Although his classes may seem disorganized initially they will become clear with time. A+

David Scott provides an impressively unbiased explanation of the readings listed in the class syllabus. His lectures are quite interesting and provide clarity on the readings from when you first read them and don't know what language they predicate. Attend lectures most of the time and participate in class discussion and this class will be a breeze

One of the best profs I've had. I have learned more from this one class than I have in most others taken together. If you want to learn what philosophy is all about and how it is done, take any of his classes. His lectures explore foundational, taken-for-granted concepts, and as such you will use what you learn here everywhere else (I know I did).

One of the few profs who actively fosters intellectual autonomy in their students. Gives choices between open-ended essay topics, which encourage you to grapple with ideas presented in class. Approaches material in multiple ways so you're bound to catch his drift eventually. Provides a balanced account of opposing positions. Gives precise feedback.

I can see why some people really do not enjoy his course... the lectures seem completely unguided and all over the place, and can be hard to follow. That being said, this man is incredibly well versed in his field, and if you stick it out it is well worth your while. Workload was easily manageable.

While it can seem like you are taking notes forever, David is very knowledgeable, and has a great sense of humour. Even though this is a year long course it is very easy as long as you put in the time and effort. The essays are handed out at least a month in advance, and exam questions are given before hand to prepare for.

I am a UVic philosophy graduate. David Scott was, by far, the most influential professor in my journey from philosophical neophyte to who I am today. He is thoughtful and brilliant. There is probably no person who has inspired me more than David. Take his class - you may not like it, but it may change your life. It certainly changed mine.

May well be best instructor I have had while pursing 2 degrees at three universities. By far he exhibited the greatest fundamental knowledge of the subject material. He doesn't hand you the material on a silver platter. You have to think about it and work at it but the level of understanding and knowledge I gained was deep and thorough.

Skipping is absolutely not an option. This guy doesn't post any slides so the only way to understand the readings the way he wants you to is to goto class. His lectures seem very unstructured, but I still learn a lot in his lectures and find him very engaging.

Professor Scott is incredible. He's extremely passionate and informative and gives the most thought provoking lectures of any of my profs. He speaks clearly yet is extremely comprehensive and intelligent. If you actually like and are passionate about philosophy you will love Professor Scott. If you take Phil for easy credit you will not.

One of the greatest profs I've ever had and definitely my favorite in UVIC's philosophy department! He's witty, funny, approachable and just brilliant. He doesn't spend time on power points, which I think, are only distracting (esp in philosophy). His lectures are so engaging that it is harder to not pay attention then to pay. Exams given ahead.

Dr. Scott is very intelligent and is easily one of the best philosophy professors at Uvic by my experience. His classes aren’t on easy subject matter but I really recommend him if you’re interested in learning something.

I took PHIL 210 as an elective with Dr. Scott, it was my favourite class of the year. If you are a conversational learner, benefitting from strong discussion and back and forth between professor and students, you will love Dr. Scott's pedagogy. He teaches without slides, which I found helped me focus on what was actually being said/meant.

I was only able to understand his teachings of Aristotle because I took PHIL 100 with him a year prior. He is LECTURE HEAVY + does not use slides. He is quite scattered in his teachings but he knows what he's talking about. Hard marker so make sure to discuss essay assignments with him before they're due. Attend office hours. Quite a funny guy tho.

Lots of people are saying he's a hard marker, but I have been putting his class on the back burner and have still been able to get A's on most of the assignments and tests. He is quite lecture heavy! But most of his lectures are quite engaging, he also posts all lectures on brightspace and writes up a summary of the lecture if you couldn't make it.

Genuinely the most enjoyable lecture I have ever had at UVIC. Sometimes, I don't learn much, and we jump around on a bunch of digressions, but I still have a lot of fun along the way. David is so witty it's unbelievable. Definitely read the material, it makes his lectures so engaging. Also, you won't be able to read his writing on feedback lol

Dr Scott is amazing! He is always cracking jokes and his lectures are super interesting. There is one assignment a week, a paragraph, but that assignment will really help with future in class writings and tests. My only issue was that I felt like he would sometimes not explain things in enough detail but he always answers questions!

8.5/10 would recommend.

Dr. Scott is by far my favourite professor Ive had at UVic. His lectures are super engaging and he is quite funny as well. While the course material may be difficult to comprehend, he does a great job of outlining it and restating the main points of discussion that are of importance to your tests/papers. Definitely Recommend taking his classes!

The best guy.

The material is somewhat clearly conveyed, only because the material itself is composed of very abstrasct philosophical ideas. The course itself is very heavy reading based, and it directly influences his teaching style. In class the readings are reviewed and explained, which is his teaching style in a nutshell, read reading off ipad and discuss.