She is a tough cookie,but you leave her class with a solid background in the field of photography.

Absolutely wonderful!! Very tough, but fair. I learned so much, she is very knowledgable and talented in her field. Wish she could be cloned so she could teach all the photography classes.

Very good instruction. Hard critiques, but you end up learning more by doing assignments over, and over and over and over again. Honesty can be seen as an asset or a threat and in her case honesty is her asset and some may be threatened by that.

Edie was a great teacher! She was very difficult and many people didnt like her because she MAKES you learn your stuff and not slide by. She does have a hectic schedule, but who doesnt?! I took 3 classes with her i liked her so much! I know i had a very valuable education from her classes.

Edie was extremely nice and down to earth, but you definitely have to be self-motivated for this class. There wasn't too much going on throughout the semester. I took the online class, so there was even less required! Overall though, I would take her again....as long as I know that it is defintely up to me to complete my assignments!

Edie is an EXCELLENT instructor. I learned more in one of her online classes than I did in three live classes at school. She is very attentive and gives out her personal email and her HOME phone number to call if you have questions. She is the best teacher ever. You have to be self motivated to do well in her classes, but that's a good thing!

I just finished an advanced creative class with her over the summer. I learned soooo much! And I had even more fun! She has great tutorials and because it was a creative class, you really got to go wild and do your own thing. I just wish she taught more advanced classes!!!

I've taken both "live" classes and online classes with this professor. She is way demanding, but she is such a GOOD instructor. I, too, just took her online advanced class, and it was great! Very creative assignments, lots of fun, and she is super sweet & helpful. I miss having her in live classes, tho, cause she is a Hot, HOT, HOTTIE!!! :+P

For half the semester I thought this teacher was a dude.I thought "edie" was "eddie." Whatever, it was a good class.I didn't think it was too easy esp. for a beginner like me.It was good that she gave us enough time to do each assignment & she didn't take her sweet ass time answering my questions, like other profs I've had. She answered right away!

Photo for the right brain - fascinating class! Hard assignments, but a great challenge. You learn a lot about yourself in the process, & how to shoot with more creativity. Instructor has a right on! sense of humor!!!!

i've taken 4 online classes from this instructor. she is the best. very encouraging and passionate about this field. knows her stuff. i totally recommend taking her if you love photography and want to make it your career. she's always available to give advice and is super helpful.

Photoshop for the novice a wonderful class! For the true novice like me it was perfect. Started with the barest of basics and assignment instructions were step by step and easy to follow. Assignments were also alot of fun like we got to make movie posters! I loved this class and I loved this instructor. I'm taking her summer class and two in Fall.

Dr. Edie is the best instructor ever! This is my 4th class w/her, & WebCT problems aside, I LOVED THIS CLASS! (Outdoor Portraiture). The class is not easy, there are tons of assignments, & you will work yr a** off, but she gives excellent instructions & examples of GOOD vs. BAD portraits, & she'll let you redo everything over till you get it right!

The online eval at the school wouldn't let me pst my comments, so I'm doing it here. This is a smokin' instructor and you will learn SO much if you take her! The assgn's she gives are fun and creative and she is lots of help if you have questions. She is the best photo teacher at the whole school!

I have taken several classes from this teacher. She is the best teacher I have had at the college. Edie is very helpful the assignments are fun and you learn alot. I would recommend this professor to everyone.

Shes the best teacher on colud ask for she super laid back...but she means businesss...i will be taking all of her classes she teaches you more on line than u coul learn in the class room she ROCKS.... My favorite proessor

Dr. Edie came highly recommended to me & I decided to take one of her online photo classes. She & the class are friggin' AWESOME! I'm already using what I learned in her class in my real life job & she even referred two PAYING clients to me. She really cares about her students and wants them to succeed. I LOVE HER! I LOVED THIS CLASS!

Wonderful person! Goes out of her way! Would take another class from her.

I am happy with Edie she is a good teacher and a good person. Iwould take anither class with her.

Instructor is very professional and knowledgeable and easy to communicate with. Overall, the class was great and I really enjoyed the assignments. You learn lots of cool tricks and shortcuts in Photoshop which is very helpful. I am going to take the next level class with her in fall semester.

THIS TEACHER IS SOOO AWSOME IT GETS NO BETTER...TRULY CARES ABOUT STUDENTS AND IS VERY ATTENTIVE

This teacher is so excellent I'm taking three classes with her next semester. I can't wait!!!!!

I RECOMMEND THIS PROFESSOR. Edie is very personable, and she would let me ask her questions about ANYTHING. She hadn't even finished grading my assignments, and gave me an A anyway because she knew me well, and I took ONLINE. We've never met, but I feel like I've known her forever! TAKE HER CLASS. And NO TEXTBOOK.

I took Edie based on what I heard from friends & read here. The class was GREAT & Edie is a one of a kind instructor. She is smart, kind, helpful, & understanding. My mom died and I got behind in assignments. Edie didn't treat me as a low life excuse maker & gave me the extra time I needed to finish. I learned a lot & did very well in class.

great class! started out with a point and click camera but got a better camera for my bday and it was so much better! learned alot and am thinking of of making this a career now. im taking the creative class next as i hear that class is awesome with this same instructor!!!

Took the photoshot for the novice class and am going to take photoshop for the creative mind this summer. Photoshop for the novice was a wonderful class if your just starting out and no NOTHING about it! Im very excited to take the next level class. Teacher is the best, no doubt!

PS fro the novice in summer was good. I like that the class is online and that assignments are given out all at once because you need the extra time. recommed this class if you want to learn PS.

I took Photo Shop CS for the Creative Mind. I thought the assignments were very interesting. If you are trying to start your own photo business, this class had assignments that were self promotional pieces, and these were my favorites. She kind of grooms you to be a professional and I really appreciated that. It's not a slacker class. Recommend

I'm continuing on from my last comment on the Photo Shop CS Creative Mind class. Here are some tips if you want to take this class. The instructor is really into "drama." Her comments on my photos were that they were very dramatic and I always got A's on those ones. Dramatic lighting, dramatic pose, dramatic idea, and you will be her favorite.

I took her class online, and I loved Edie. She would let me ask her personal questions, and she would go above and beyond to respond, and encourage me. NO TEXTBOOK FOR THIS CLASS! We had WebCT issues, and she just let me have an "A" even though I didn't get to finish my last assignment. Gives EXCELLENT feedback on your work. TAKE HER CLASS!

This was a good class if you like to work independently and be creative. I enjoyed the polaroid transfer portion of the class. The reason I withdrew was because of issues I was having in her PHO 175 class which I explained in the prior rating. She seemed nicer in this class and in a better mood. I wasn't picked on and harassed in this class.

I took beginning photoshop with this professor. I had mixed feelings about the course, because though the teacher was nice, and the class was easy, I felt it was difficult getting in touch with her (it was online). She seemed distant and she is extremely sensitive to anything even remotely offensive to animals. I love animals and some of these thin

PS CS for the Novice online. Edie seemed somewhat distant for the semester. The emails and grades took awhile for her to respond to, but when she responded you would get lots of feedback, not just good job. I enjoyed her open personality, but would have liked quicker response to my emails. However she did leave her ph# and said to call whenever.

I don't know what the person who commented on 11/25 is talking about because this professor doesn't teach 175. She only teaches the advanced classes, so what drugs are you on? I've had this instructor for three classes and she is excellent. I am taking her new class in spring and I can't wait!!! She absolutely NEVER "picks" on anyone!!!

I've had Edie for live classes and now that I have my degree, I still take her online classes because she is a wealth of knowledge and she is a kind person. Yes, she is sensitive to the plight of animals and thank g-d for that because it makes her a sensitive, kind, caring person all around. All instructors should be as considerate as she is!

I'm continuing this from before. Two semesters ago, when I called Edie crying because my mom had died suddenly of a heart attack, Edie cried on the phone with me. She said not to worry about assignments and that she only wanted me to mourn and heal. She said she would work with me because she knew I was a good student, and that's what she did.

Con't again: Edie's main concern was for me, and she bent over backwards to help me finish class and not fall completely apart emotionally. She let me call her and cry on her shoulder and she never once complained. She became a bit of a savior for me. I have never had another instructor like that so consider yourself LUCKY to have her!

OMG! And for the person who took a class ten years ago with Edie and who is STILL whining about your evil fur coat, YOU ARE PATHETIC! Good thing I wasn't in that class with my red can of spray paint. Get a life, you MURDERER!

I loved this photoshop class. The assignments are very creative and you get to really show your own flair. Plus, assignments are useful because they are things that you can make money at, like photographing and designing Xmas cards, promotional pieces for businesses and for yourself, etc. I liked the prof - she's very smart, creative, and fun.

I just finished finals a bit early & Edie sent me my final grade already. It's true that she does take awhile to get all the grading done, but she is an outstanding teacher in every other way. Her feedback is super helpful, & she gives alot of Xtra credit. She moves heaven & earth to make sure you have learned the material. I love her! U will 2!

And to the person below who said her classes are easy filler classes, your nuts! If you didn't learn anything, you must be stupid, too. I worked hard on the assignments and I've learned more in her classes then any other class I've taken in 2 years. ur just a Hater. And a whiner. There's one in every class. Just go away and Hate on ur own self.

This instructor is the best and you will learn so much in 15 wks that you'll amaze yourself. she hates anything that looks like a snapshot. If you work hard you'll do great. She gives good feedback and is a fair grader. She will give extra credit if you go above and beyond the assignment specs. She really cares and wants students to be their best.

PhotoShop CS for Commercial Photo. I have my degree in photo, but I like to keep my skills fresh. This is a good class for that. It's the best class I've had at CSN. Assignments are not easy, but you'll learn mad skills in this class that aren't in any other class at CSN. Edie was helpful and patient. I couldn't ask for a better teacher or class.

I took an online History class and it was awful! There was ZERO interaction with the teacher. So, I was skeptical about taking a photo class, but I ended up loving it! She had no problem talking to me on the phone for hours explaining things ;) I highly recommend her. When you have a really good teacher, it makes a big difference.

Photoshop CS for commercial photo is an EXTREMELY hard class with an EXCESSIVE number of assignments that are EXTREMELY difficult, EXTREMELY time intensive and EXTREMELY technical. The class leaves NO time for anything else. I LOVED EVERY SINGLE MINUTE OF IT! I can't wait for la deuxième parti! =) I HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS CLASS AND THIS PROFESSOR!!!

Hard class for the summer six weeks but instructor is really understanding and good about giving extra time on assignments. All in all I liked it and learned alot. Have a good camera for this class tho bcause point-n-click cameras will make it hard to do many of the assigemnts.

Like the other person said, this was a hard class to do in six weeks, but I still really enjoyed it. The instructor will let you call her any time of day or night and explain things a hundred times to you until you get it and I thought that was pretty cool. I would definitely take another class with her.

This was a great class but beware that the assignments are varied between different versions of CS. If you have a different version than the assignment, you might have trouble or you won't be able to do the assignment at all. I have CS2 and there were 2 assignments I couldn't do, so she posted two different assignments specific for CS2 users. She d

...continuing from my last comment because i got cut off. I was saying that she goes out of her way to make sure you get the most out of the class and is very accommodating. I've taken several online classes at CSN and this is the best instructor I've had. She's honest about critiques, a very fair grader, and a genuinely nice person.

I'm glad to know you can continue your coments here because I have a lot to say. In the middle of the class, I shot a wedding. I called Edie to ask for some pointers, which she gave me a lot. I shot thousands of photos and I thought they were great, right up until I opened them in my computer. TBContintued.......

Location Portraiture. really liked this class. It opened my eyes to details that never would have occurred to me before. Instructor is GREAT. She shows how makeup, lighting, wardrobe can make or break a portrait. She explains why your portrait is good or why it is bad, but her critiques are fair & just. I might take it again just for her feedback!

Loved this class! Assignments are fun and creative. She encourages you to be creative and come up with your own ideas in addition to the assignments and gives extra credit if you go above and beyond her directions. She is always available to help. Gives her home number to the whole class and says to call her anytime with questions. SUPERB teacher!

She is good at what she does and she knows how to inspire confidence and encourages you to put your own personality into your work. There are no "cookie cutter" assignments in her classes. This is an instructor who really cares and spends her time to help you if you need it.

I love this professor! She is smart and is always available to help you with problems. She goes out of her way to make sure you understand the concepts. She is the only professor I've ever had who will spend hours using Photoshop on your work so you can see exactly what she means on how to make it better. Then she will hold your hand while you do j

I loved this summer class! I'm an older learner and I had never taken a distance learning class before. I was anxious, really anxious, about being able to do the computer part of it. But Miss Edie made it very simple for me. I must have called her a dozen times and she was very patient with me. I am definitely taking another class with her.

I love this Prof. Had her for 4 classes, & learned so much. I feel the need 2 defend her against stupid people. DimWit who never got a reply email: she gives out her HOME PHONE NUMBER in the syll & on emails and says 2 "call her ANYTIME" u have no excuse 2 say she doesn't help students. Any other Prof ever give u their HOME #s? No? Didn't think so!

Took her online class great professor, she leaves her personal phone number if you need to contact her, only thing is it takes her 2 days to return my phone call. She lets you turn in your assignments whenever but trade off is she takes her time grading,she very easy when it comes to grading.if she doesn't like it she makes you redo the assignment

She is amazing! Assignment directions were step by step and she gives great tips for improving your photoshop skills. I took this class because of all the great recommendations and was not dissapointed.

I took this same beginning class online with a different instructor last semester and it was the worst class I've ever had.Then I heard about Edie's class.I took it this summer-huge difference! She is amazing, you can call her at her home she will explain for hours.I learned so much more, the assignments were so much better.I recommend her highly!

There are a lot of good things about this teacher/classes. 1 of the best is her crits.Very thorough,tells you exactly what's good, what's not good, how to make it better, she will even taking your photo and redo it in her photoshop to show you what she means.NEVER had a teacher take that much time and interest! DEDICATED!!!

If she loves your photos, she will rave over them & even give you extra credit if she thinks you went above & beyond the specs. That kind of encouragement MAKES you want to do better & better. If she hates your photos, she'll tell you that too, but nicely, give you a 100 tips to make it better & let you redo it till its perfect. AWESOME! You LEARN!

Also-she never has you do an assignment blind. She shows you past examples of good and not good pics. You always know what she expects. She also has documents attached to assignments with photos to visually show what she explains in writin, so you can SEE her lectures. WORTH EVERY PENNY OF YOUR TUITION!

Last thing, I promis.350 words isn't enough! The fact that you can call her at home anytime & she will sit on her computer while you're on your computer & walk you thru step by step, answer all your ???s & not hang up till she's sure you got it. I spent hours with her on the phone & her dedication blew me away. I learned SO much! She is THE BEST!

Refreshing teacher.Other photo profs want u to do it all their way. Their ideas= right, ur ideas=wrong. Edie guides u in the direction of "good" photography & she made clear her likes & dislikes, but she told me over & over to put "ME" in my shots, make them my own. Develop MY style. NEVER had a prof concerned w/ what I wanted to learn. Loved class

Edie had some crazy technical problems this semester and that caused a backup in grades. I still loved her class. It's my third one w/her. I've had tech issues and she's been understanding, so it's only fair to give her a break. I wouldn't hesitate to take another class w/her. She is still the BEST!

Took Edie's photoshop gone wild class and had a blast. she is way cool and the assignnents were awesome. my husband is an avid golfer and i did one using him playing golf it turned out so utterly cool i blew it up poster size, framed it and gave it to him for xmas. he LOVED it and hung it in his office at work and his golf buddies LOVED it too!

Outdoor portraiture online class. This was a pretty intense class and a lot of work. The professor is kind of picky in grading and I had to redo some assignments but overall I thought it was a good class and by the end, even I was impressed with my work. She's tough, but I'd take her again if there was a outdoor portrait II class.

AWESOME in every way!

It's been 27 years since I've taken a class and I was petrified, especially because it was online, which I'm not good at. But Dr. Edie was great. She spent alot of time helping me. This is a great class for beginners, and Dr. Edie is a top notch instructor. I'm taking two classes with her next semester and really looking forward to it.

Great class. Very technical. The best part about it was speaking with the prof on the side. She was full of fun, cheeky conversation but most of all she gave solid advice about the real world. I learned as much from her on the phone as I did in class assignments. Loved her, loved the class.

Fun Photoshop class. Great assignments , some hard ones but very cool results. Recommend!

This class was very artistic. My favorites assignments were where you got to use alot of self expression and the ones with the really "out there" special effects turned out pretty insane.

She was excellent for me. Helped me out when I didn't understand something. Highly recommend her. Work load was never extreme. Gaps allowed for other class work to get done. I learned a lot in her classes also took Pho 198. Loved her.

Creative Portraiture. Most AWESOME class ever! Assignments were pretty challenging but fun and very creative. Black light portrait anyone? Hope she comes up with a part 2 to this class, and soon! I'm ALL in!

Agree w/ other reviewers. Great class. Some assignments were really challenging and at times I got frustrated but in end I was really happy w/ how my work turned out. I had fun, I learned a lot and best of all I got a beautiful portrait of my daughter that I will cherish forever. Prof was very cool and gave honest feedback. I'd love another class!

Very technical class harder than I thought it was going to be with shutter speeds, F-stops, etc. but I learned how to use my camera much better and got some of those cool shots I thought you could only get using photoshop. All in all, worth every penny. Dr. Edie is nice (tough, but nice) and very helpful. I very much liked the class.

The one annoying thing is that she doesn't grade anything in a timely manner. Semesters almost over and I haven't receive one single grade. Rediculous.

This class didn't require a textbook for this class which was a relief. Dr. Chiarappa is very welcoming, and she's willing to help if there's any questions. The class wasn't too challenging but I still learned a lot. I would definitely recommend taking this professor.

Enjoyed this class. Prof is very helpful, a fair grader, gives extra credit, & I got to work with a pro photographer as an assistant & got extra credit for it because pros call her all the time looking for help & she turns it into a real life situation where you have to interview & show your work. You get "hired" based on that. AWESOME EXPERIENCE!!

Edie was the 1st to inspire me in my collegiate profession. She is an amazingly skilled professor who is always available to her students but challenges you to bring your A game. I learned so much about Photography from this course and took every other possible web course she gave as a follow-up. Students willing to work won't regret taking her.

I loved Dr. Chiarappa. Her grading is pretty easy and all she asks for is no photos related to rodeos, head mounts, or anything related to animal cruelty, which doesn't narrow down photo ideas whatsoever. Just don't do the projects too last minute, as some of the projects are very time consuming, but totally worth it.