3.2

Harvey Poniachek

Economics - Baruch College

3.2
Quality
3.5
Difficulty
10%
Would Retake
150
Reviews
3.2
Quality
3.5
Difficulty
3.2
Helpful
3.1
Clarity

10%

Would Retake

150

Reviews

Rating Distribution
Official

5

59

4

20

3

16

2

16

1

39

What Students Say

I regret not checking this website before taking his class

FIN9781 - 1.0 rating

Hands down the worst professor I've ever come across at Rutgers Business school

FIN2234 - 1.0 rating
Class Info

Attendance Mandatory

59%

Textbook Required

95%

Grade Predictor

Your expected effort level

LowHigh

Predicted Grade

A-

74% confidence
Based on 8 grades
Most common grades:
A (4)
Not sure yet (2)
B (2)
Grade Distribution
A(5)B(2)C(0)D(0)F(0)A-/B+(1)
Based on 10 reported grades
A: 4
Not sure yet: 2
B: 2
A+: 1
Common Tags
Get ready to read (4)
TEST HEAVY (2)
GRADED BY FEW THINGS (2)
GROUP PROJECTS (1)
Inspirational (1)
Participation matters (1)
SO MANY PAPERS (1)
Tests are tough (1)
Rating Trend

Declining

-1.06 avg change
May
Jul
Aug
Dec
May
May
Last 6 months
Ratings by Course

4910

5.0

(1)

FIN4920

5.0

(4)

MA9700

5.0

(1)

FIN4030

5.0

(1)

ECON101

5.0

(1)
+18 more courses
Difficulty by Course

FINAN4910

5.0

MANDA

5.0

FIN9759MA

5.0

FIN4390

4.5

FIN9788

4.2

Reviews (150)
3.0
3.0
IN4910
May 14, 2005

Did anyone take him before?

3.0
4.0
FINECO
May 18, 2005

Does anyone know anything about this professor?

3.0
3.0
FIN
Aug 8, 2005

I found his rating in Pace http://www.ratemyprofessors.com/ShowRatings.jsp?tid=373165

5.0
2.0
4910
Nov 2, 2005

while professor poniachek is well intentioned his lecturing will bore the class into a state of complete apathy. he insists upon incessant repetition of material previously covered in lectures which in turn was covered in depth in the prerequisites, over two months into the semester we're still waiting to hear something new.avoid if u want 2 learn

1.0
4.0
FIN9786
Jan 25, 2006

Horrible! Very boring and sometimes rude to students. Seemed like it was his first time teaching material. He could not explain concepts well and struggled through examples, but exams were still difficult...

1.0
3.0
FIN9786
Jan 13, 2006

Simply the worst professor ever!! Does not know how to teach, often confuses himself, no partial credit, horrible!! Wasted my time, ruined my interest on the subject.

1.0
4.0
FIN9786
Feb 24, 2006

Horrible so far! He is boring and rude to students. He cannot explain the matterial, struggles through examples, nothing good to report.

1.0
5.0
FIN9786
Mar 9, 2006

Simply the worst professor you can find on earth!

2.0
4.0
FIN9786
May 24, 2006

About as thrilling as mud in winter. Took the class to knock out a finance and intl requirement together. Prof seems to confuse himself in lectures. Lectures add nothing. No partial credit on exams. Offers no guidance on project, deriving exchange indecies. Didn't know where to find some of his own sources.

1.0
5.0
FIN9786
Jul 6, 2006

Do not take this class if you do not have to! Professor is rude, and arogant. The class book does not support his teaching style. Therefore you are doing 2x as much work to not understand the course material. He is just not a good professor

5.0
2.0
FIN9786
Jul 11, 2006

Better you get used to his, poor, handwriting ASAP. Otherwise he is fine. Has a cute accent and some sense of humar too. Knows the subject and expects students to know the basics. Provides good notes, examples etc.

5.0
2.0
FIN9786
Dec 28, 2006

Tough material, but professor explains it well. Midterm easy b/c he gives you the types of questions that will be asked. The final is tougher and you need to study. Go to class, you'll get the benefit of the doubt on the grade.

1.0
5.0
FINAN4910
Mar 18, 2007

dont take

5.0
1.0
FIN4920
Jun 2, 2007

Prof.Poniachek is one of the best Prof. I have taken. He gives some smart replies to your questions, but nevertheless, he is very knowledgeable and fair in his grading.

2.0
5.0
FIN9786
Jun 27, 2007

Avoid by all means.Terrible teacher.His lectures are extremely confusing,he jumps from one subject to another leaving you totally lost.Final exam is very difficult and different from class problems.

1.0
5.0
FIN4910
Jul 3, 2007

No Comments

5.0
1.0
FIN4910
Jul 10, 2007

Others think he is biased, but I am of a different race than he is and I still got an A.He loves participation and he faovrs those who sit in the front.If you do not make yourself known, he will not know you. All I did was participate ALOT and study previous exams that he hands out bc they are the same, only yhe numbers is what he changes. Take him

1.0
5.0
FIN9786
Jul 12, 2007

BEWARE! BEWARE!Don't take this class, ever..if you want international course..take any other but this one..you will regret your life, your opinion about baruch will change completely in selecting right professor. Professor has no knowledge about the subject, will confuse you, textbook and his words don't match, final is so hard that you will scratc

1.0
5.0
FIN9786
Jul 17, 2007

Warning: DO NOT TAKE THIS CLASS! It is extremely convoluted. Hard to keep up with prof and his lectures often conflict with what the book says. He probably knows his stuff, but he is not a good teacher. Will turn you off Finance!

5.0
2.0
FIN4920
Jul 17, 2007

Great professor! I wish more of the faculty were as enthusiastic about teaching as he was. I had a very enjoyable time during the semester. The class covered a lot of material, but it was very rewarding. I highly recommend.

5.0
2.0
FIN4920
Jul 17, 2007

Outstanding professor! Everyone should teach like him. He was always open to questions and answered them very thoroughly. The class covered a lot of material, but it was very rewarding. I highly recommend taking a course by him for anyone interested in developing their financial skills and analytic ability.

4.0
3.0
FIN4910
Jul 20, 2007

He does have a bad hand writing, but you can get use to it. At first it seems like the class will be a nightmare, but at the end you really notice that you have learned a lot. He is helpful if you want help. Having an attitude is not going to get you anywhere. You have to remember that this is a hard material and you have to spend some time on it.

3.0
3.0
FIN4910
Jul 20, 2007

He knows his stuff, maybe not the best professor Baruch has, but still pretty good. I really learned a lot in his class. You can get used to bad hand writing after few sessions. Heavy on e-mails and very helpful if you show you care.

5.0
2.0
FIN9786
Jul 24, 2007

He’s a knowledgeable professor who has real experience in industry. He’s expecting students understand the basics and come prepared for his class. Otherwise, some students may find it difficult to follow his lectures.

2.0
5.0
FIN9786
Aug 14, 2007

No Comments

5.0
3.0
FIN9786
Sep 24, 2007

No Comments

4.0
3.0
FIN9786
Sep 24, 2007

He covered a lot of material in a short time, but did it well. The class was extremely interesting. He is very helpful if you ask insightful, intelligent questions.

5.0
4.0
FIN4920
Oct 5, 2007

great professor, you must keep up with his class ...but his class will make you think and help you in your future goals in finance

4.0
4.0
FIN9786
Dec 31, 2007

He will post a lot to read. But if you listen to what he says and keep up with the readings, the exams should not be difficult. The case studies are interesting, but involved. Overall, good class, a lot of work, but in the end, it pays dividends!

4.0
4.0
FIN9759
Dec 31, 2007

Excellent class - very high learn factor. Not easy but very recommendable!

5.0
3.0
FIN9759
Jan 1, 2008

The Professor is very dedicated to his teaching. Takes pains to collect newspaper articles and site them as examples in class. He is very understanding and patient. Desires that the students be well prepared for his class. Posts extensive reading material on the blackboard. Offers an excellent insight into Mergers and Acquisitions.

3.0
5.0
FIN9759
Jan 1, 2008

This is an excellent course but a difficult one. The professor is excellent but you have to do the readings (book/articles posted) before the class otherwise you loose track. Prof. P. always tries to help and explain but you have to do your reading first. I've taken 2 classes with him so far and its been great.

5.0
3.0
FIN9759
Jan 3, 2008

I think this was one of the best classes I've taken. Professor was very helpful and well prepared for every class. He almost always brought new newspaper articles to support his material which made this class much more relevant and interesting. I definitely recommend it.

5.0
1.0
FIN9759
Jan 4, 2008

The class was excellent, truely one of the best I have taken at Baruch. It was mostly based on cases and actual events. There is a lot of reading. I must admit I didn't read more than 10% of it, (a lot of case material, you dont need the book) but if you pay attention to the dicussions in class its easy to learn and understand the material.

4.0
1.0
FIN9759
Jan 13, 2008

If I could choose, I would decide to take the course again but not with this professor.

5.0
4.0
FIN9759
Jan 27, 2008

The class was extremely interesting. The professor is very knowledgeable and you will learn a lot. Note, that the prof. covers a lot of materials and post a lot of readings but if you attend the class he will focus you on the important materials (so you are safe). If it counts for you, he is also very nice person (for me it does).

3.0
4.0
MKT9759
May 21, 2008

Nice guy. His tests are odd. He doesn't focus much on technical or math matters. If one criticism its that he spends a lot of time on details that will be pretty useless in life unless you work in m&a.

5.0
4.0
FIN9759
May 25, 2008

This Professor knows his subject well and clearly explains it to his students. By no means is he a spoon feeder, he pushes you to learn through readings and case studies. This was both one of the more challenging and rewarding classes taken as part of the MBA program. I recommend this professor and this course to anyone who wants to truly learn.

4.0
3.0
FIN9759
May 25, 2008

This is an excellent professor. The material he reviews in class is relevant to the case studies he requires students to write about outside of class. I would recommend him.

5.0
3.0
FIN9759
May 29, 2008

I had professor Poniachek for mergers and aquisitions. He exhibited such a genuine passion for the subject and mastery of the material, that in my experience, is unrivaled amongst your colleagues at Baruch.Crystal clear on what he wishes you to know and amazing professor. Do yourself a favor and TAKE HIM, you wont find another better at Baruch.

5.0
3.0
FIN9759
Jun 2, 2008

I took Merger & Aquisition with Prof. Poniachek. The course was great. Professor knows his area very well and keeps his students abreast of the latests in M&A. Course is mostly case based and one gets a good hands-on practice of company valuation, and other key elements of M&A process. Both course and Prof. highly recommended.

5.0
4.0
FIN9759
Jun 2, 2008

Although there is a lot of reading and the case studies are very involved, the professor's enthusiasm for the subject matter and interest in his students makes up for it. In addition, you will learn so much that by the end of the class you really feel that you could valuate a merger between two companies. A highly recommended MBA class to take!

5.0
4.0
MA9700
Jun 4, 2008

Maybe this class should be required for all MBA students - at least those in finance. It sort of put things all together for me. It was a great class to take the last semester, though there is a fair amount of work and reading.

5.0
4.0
FIN9759
Jun 24, 2008

Great teaching style. Very informative. Teaches in a way that makes the students actually understand and are able to practically apply the material.

2.0
3.0
FIN4910
Jul 2, 2008

Took it during the summer 2008...... my friend and i laughed the whole class, he is funny in a none funny way. Has the worst handwriting ever.... and doesnt teach anything that he test....He gives big curves and makeups

5.0
3.0
FIN9786
Jul 13, 2008

I took International finance this summer. Professor Poniachek did an excellent job explaining clearly in such a short time span advance finance topics such as currency and interest rate futures, options, Eurodollar markets, parity conditions etc. His teaching and professional experience gives students the opportunity to learn above and beyond what

5.0
1.0
FIN4910
Jul 13, 2008

I took Fin4910 over the summer and got an A. I found the prof. to be pretty funny which helps when learning the concepts. Exams weren't hard..he lets you bring a formula sheet and he reviews whats going to be on the exam. Overall if you listen in class and review the assigned problems..you should do very well.

5.0
3.0
FIN9786
Jul 13, 2008

a textbook can provide. For each topic he provided us with supporting documents and examples that uses in class to explain better a topic. He is open to questions and I found him very responsive to out of class communication too.His exams are fair asking questions for topics that he has covered in class. That was a true MBA class! Great professor!

5.0
2.0
FIN9786
Jul 14, 2008

The content is pretty advanced. I had some prior knowledge, even then I had to study hard, partly because of the little duration of the entire semester (1 month). The professor is knowledgable, helpful and eager to take care of the individual needs of the students. If you go through his classes and notes seriously, you will definitely land up in A

5.0
4.0
FIN4910
Jul 18, 2008

This class is interesting, though not an easy one, especially when you take it during the summer. The professor is knowledgeable and always willing to help. His exams are challenging, but he curves. Overall, if you read the book and pay attention in class, you'll be fine.

5.0
1.0
FIN4910
Jul 31, 2008

Tests are curved and makeups are possible. Lot of review. Material is covered slowly but necessary to do some practise questions at home. The newest book is definitely not needed. An older edition will suffice. Humor is used frequently.

4.0
4.0
FIN9786
Aug 26, 2008

Professor is knowledgeable. Read the book and do the exercise and it should be fine. Book is a good read. However, class can be confusing because of content.

5.0
1.0
FIN4930
Jan 2, 2009

Excellent Professor. Every class we talked about current news and topics. Everything was clear in the handouts and in his lessons. If you're passionate about M&A then it's an easy A.

5.0
1.0
FIN4930
Jan 2, 2009

Class discussions started right out of the day's paper. Read the handouts, come to class, skim the book. Fun class, great professor.

4.0
3.0
FIN4930
Jan 3, 2009

He is a very nice person and the class was enjoyable. Everything we learned was also discussed on the examples of current events and it made things clear. 2 group projects, 1 mid-term and a final.Projects are time consuming but fun to do. If you are interested in M&A topic take him- you will learn a lot! Even though class was late- was worth it.

5.0
2.0
FIN4930
Jan 19, 2009

Prof. knows so much! Interesting discussions on today's events. But study a lot to get a good grade: both, handouts and the book. If you present, your grade will be higher, so participate and volunteer to do presentations. Two group cases, so get a good team, because the cases are HARD! the final is cumulative even is it marked as NOT. Good luck!

2.0
3.0
FIN4930
Jan 22, 2009

Read handouts to memorization levels. Smart team selection mandatory. Never really know until on team, but you can tell. Pick wisely or crash/burn! Fun class. Projects biggest pain.

3.0
3.0
FIN4930
May 7, 2009

Two case studies and two exams. Not very hard, but definitely annoying. Adds nothing to the class aside from irritation. Many better Finance electives out there.

5.0
4.0
FIN4930
May 25, 2009

Extremely knowledgeable, helpful and interesting professor. He ties in real world events out of paper, so be prepared before class & you will learn a lot. Wants you to build professional skills & is very big on presentations, so be sure to do them. He really cares about his students and is always willing to talk about class or your career.

5.0
3.0
FIN4930
May 25, 2009

Extremely knowledgeable, helpful and interesting professor. He ties in real world events out of paper, so be prepared before class & you will learn a lot. Wants you to build professional skills & is very big on presentations, so be sure to do them. He really cares about his students and is always willing to talk about class or your career.

5.0
3.0
FIN9759
May 31, 2009

One of the best professors at Baruch! Was looking forward for the classes! Very knowledgeable, a really nice person and approachable. His class is highly engaging, a blend of textbook material, case studies and discussions based on real world scenarios. I am very glad I took this class and I highly recommend it.

4.0
4.0
FIN4930
Jun 7, 2009

A 4000 level professor! Covers current events and applies material to real world. 2 exams, 2 group case studies, and volunteer for presentation. Slides are most important, and you can read up on the book if have time.

1.0
4.0
FIN4910
Jun 30, 2009

avoid! he's out of date and exams weight more than a ton each. if you mess up then you MESS up! very dry and boring for a not so bad subject. take another prof for this class. this one is on the line for retirement soon

5.0
4.0
FIN9786
Jul 7, 2009

I Couldn?t disagree more with the below comment. Professor Poniachek is by far one of the best (if not the best) professors at Baruch. He is extremely knowledgeable, cares about his students, and is hilarious too. He did an excellent job teaching given the accelerated nature of summer class. I highly recommend this professor!

5.0
4.0
FIN9786
Jul 7, 2009

Couldn?t disagree more with the below comment. Professor Poniachek is by far one of the best (if not the best) professors at Baruch. He is extremely knowledgeable, cares about his students, and is hilarious too. He did an excellent job teaching given the accelerated nature of summer class. I highly recommend this professor!

5.0
3.0
FIN9759
Jul 8, 2009

Prof. Poniachek is personable, approachable and knowledgeable. He treats his class like a meeting between financial professionals. You?ll get a basic understanding if you attend class and review his slides. But the discussions and lectures become more interesting if you really challenge yourself to learn the material.

2.0
3.0
FIN9786
Jul 11, 2009

Ok person, approachable before class, but not after or out of class. Assumes a lot of prior knowledge, extremely disorganized with notes and course plan, and he does not follow either, which makes the class un-engaging. Makes simple concepts difficult, terrible handwriting, messed up midterm grading, no one knew what was going on most of the time.

3.0
2.0
FIN4910
Jul 11, 2009

It's not a hard subject. Professor is somewhat boring but he's pretty easy. He also has horrible handwriting. Make sure you sit in the front if you want to learn. The most important thing to have is that study guide. I'd say about 80-90% of his exam questions were from it.

2.0
1.0
FIN4910
Jul 11, 2009

Professor Poniachek is a smart man who knows alot about the finance and has years of work and teaching experience. His handwriting is bad though, and sometimes you will get confused. The exams are very fair though, and he gives a nice curve.

5.0
1.0
FIN4910
Jul 12, 2009

This professor is very knowledgeable of what he teaches and he makes the class fun. Most of all he goes over the notes in a way for you to understand and give lots of examples.If you practice the problems,study his notes and come to class, you can get an A.

4.0
3.0
FIN9786
Jul 13, 2009

The subject itself is very hard but Prof HP was really helpful! His exams are not easy but he curves a lot! NOT an easy A. Have to attend classes,study a lot on your own and make sure you understand the material to do well on his exams.

5.0
4.0
FIN4910
Jul 13, 2009

the professor is extremely helpful and knowledgeable. he is always available out of the class. read the text book, slides and do some problems to get A, not easy but achievable. sometimes handwriting is not clear. that's the only negative feedback. will recommend him for FIN4910. take him during the full semester, because the course is interesting

2.0
3.0
FIN9759
Jul 14, 2009

I was always wondering how he gets such good ratings here while being such an awful professor. Well he emails all his A and A- students asking to give him a good rating on this website. Yep! I know! Other than than he is super boring, unengaging, exams are ok though ridiculous amount of material covered. Would never take him again!

4.0
3.0
FIN4910
Jul 15, 2009

I enjoyed the class a lot. I learned so many different things about International Financial Markets. I knew a few from previous classes but Professor Poniachek provided an in depth understanding of the subject. Leaving this class, I am taking away knowledge that I will retain for years to come. If you like being challenged, take him.

1.0
5.0
FIN9786
Jul 16, 2009

The only thing worse than an awful professor is one that tries to hide the fact. Sad face and thumbs down to balance those fake reviews stemming from his e-mail review requests.

4.0
4.0
FIN4910
Jul 31, 2009

it's easy to complain rather than to accept your own mistakes. if he's so confusing and can't teach, so why a decent number of people got As. maybe, they are geniuses? it's not an easy class, you HAVE to read material before coming to class and after if you don't get it. 25% couldn't finish projects 'cause they're so lazy to read what it's about!

5.0
4.0
FIN9786
Aug 18, 2009

This professor is excellent. Extremely smart and brings forth much practical experience. Exams and material can be very difficult, so you must stay on top of the leasons. Overall, very good class. don't beleive the below comments, just do your work and you will get a good grade.

2.0
5.0
FIN4930
Dec 5, 2009

Prof Poniachek is good. You could learn a lot if you put a lot of effort in it and read the textbook. Not a easy professor and not a easy A. If you just want to boost up your GPA, don't think of it.

5.0
3.0
FIN4930
Dec 25, 2009

Excellent professor! Professor Poniachek makes the M & A lectures fun and interesting. He continuously covers current events so students learn how to apply theory to the real world. Read his pp slides before the class, participate in discussions, and choose a good group for case studies. I highly recommend this class!

5.0
3.0
FIN4930
Dec 31, 2009

He is a very good professor. He starts the class with a daily discussion of the financial news from Wall Street Journal and other major newspapers. He is helpful and very precise with his lectures. I enjoyed the class and learned a lot from him and also got a good grade, what more could I have asked for?

4.0
1.0
FIN9759
Jan 4, 2010

m&a course, I came in with no knowledge and came out with all expected info. very fair exams, 3 case studies are fun, great learning environment.

5.0
3.0
FIN4930
Jan 26, 2010

Great professor! Professor Poniachek covers all aspects of M&A in a way that students can relate to it. He also discusses current events, encourages students to participate, and provides very helpful slides. Put in the work, and you will come out with lots of knowledge and a good grade. This was definitely one of my favorite classes at Baruch!

5.0
3.0
FIN4030
Jan 26, 2010

Great professor! Professor Poniachek covers all aspects of M&A in a way that students can relate to it. He also discusses current events, encourages students to participate, and provides very helpful slides. Put in the work, and you will come out with lots of knowledge and a good grade. This was definitely one of my favorite classes at Baruch!

4.0
3.0
FIN9759
May 31, 2010

Overall good class. This class requires you become independent. Make sure to read and learn every single page of the textbook. Don't be passive for this class, but be smart. I got out of this class with full of knowledge.

5.0
4.0
FIN4930
Jun 1, 2010

Prof Harvey is a true expert in the realm of M&A. The course is not easy, but he provides you with the tools necessary to succeed. You complete 3 real world HBS cases, where you implement what he teaches in class and further strengthen your understanding of M&A. Overall, it's a challenging class, you will learn a lot, & Prof Harvey is a great prof.

5.0
2.0
FIN4930
Jun 2, 2010

Prof. Poniachek is genuine and provides you with real life examples in class. Be prepared to not only read the material discussed in class but know about whats happening in the industry. If you have a sense of curiosity and are prepared to work (read/study), you will walk out learning so much!He is one of best professors at Baruch.

5.0
4.0
FIN4930
Jun 30, 2010

Great professor! Class was fun, and there was a guest speaker from Colgate.

1.0
4.0
FIN9786
Jul 7, 2010

No clear guidance, doesn't follow the chapters he assigns, doesn't provide helpful feedback. He knows the subject matter and explains it in a way that makes it difficult. Make sure you read the book. Most of what he gives you is useless including the formulas in class because he doesn't explain what the symbols mean or why you're doing them.

2.0
4.0
FIN4910
Jul 14, 2010

not a good professpr at all!!!...........dont understand howcome all these good comments had come out of students...........he doesnt even answer any question in class........but good luck if u r taking this gentleman!!!

1.0
5.0
FIN9786
Jul 19, 2010

Absolutely HORRIBLE. Many of us were fooled by his good ratings on this site. He is NOT helpful and doesn't teach anything. He reads straight off the notes or textbook and isn't able to answer questions efficiently. He is rude and disrespectful. We were ALL miserable in this class. I would NEVER take him again. Worse grade in graduate school!

1.0
5.0
FIN4910
Aug 16, 2010

Rude and uncaring. Fibal had nothing to do with the material taught in class although the first exam was hard but fair. There are worse professors however that is hardly something to be proud of.

5.0
2.0
FIN9786
Oct 15, 2010

Professor Poniacheck was one of the best professors I have had. He demonstrated a mastery of the material and reviewed many additional examples to assure no one was left behind. He let us know every topic for the exam greatly aiding in our preparation. I enjoyed his teaching so much I am now taking another class he teaches this semester.

3.0
4.0
FIN9759
Dec 18, 2010

M&A class is interesting, despite him. Rude and insulting. Slides and handouts are usually in ALL CAPS, which everyone in the world (but him) knows makes things 10x harder to read, like the material isn't challenging enough. Handwriting is incomprehensible. He's not helpful at all. That said, if you keep up, you might learn a lot, no thanks to him.

5.0
3.0
FIN4930
Dec 22, 2010

I learn a lot from this class. Prof.Poniachek is a good one. Take him.

5.0
4.0
FIN4390
Dec 24, 2010

Professor Poniachek was a great professor. Prior to this class i had no interest in mergers and acquisitions, however after i had more of an interest. I learned alot from this class as well!

5.0
3.0
FIN9759
Jan 14, 2011

M&A is a topic that I was interested in and Prof. Poniachek did an great job discussing the various legal and financial issues in the field while bringing current deals to demonstrate the material in the real world. He is a very fair grader and brings in 3 interesting cases to round out the course (along with a midterm and final); worth taking.

5.0
2.0
FIN9759
Jan 18, 2011

The case studies are very interesting. You learn a lot through it. Professor's lecture notes are important. Invest in the class and it will be more fun.

5.0
4.0
FIN4930
Mar 21, 2011

An engaging class that should be taken by all finance majors. A lot of the complaints are from people who didn't participate and relied on the exams to carry the grade. The different between this class and the others is that there is a bigger emphasis on presentation. If you actually come to class prepared and show it, then you will get that A.

3.0
4.0
MNAFIN
May 12, 2011

He can't teach at all. We had to study about 600 pages just for the midterm plus articles from HBR and now he says the final will be cumulative..... He doesn't explain projects at all so if your group can't read the professor's mind you'll suffer a lot

2.0
4.0
MNAFIN
May 12, 2011

If it's true that he is such a great professor, how come only 1 group out of 7 managed to prepare one of the projects??? Don't ever expect any guidelines. All you'll hear: "everything is on BB"

2.0
5.0
FIN9759
May 12, 2011

Professor Poniachek, please do us a favor and stop posting positive reviews on yourself... Whom are you trying to fool???

1.0
5.0
FIN9759
May 13, 2011

Don't take midterm exam when it's scheduled. Take it a week or 2 weeks later and you will still get the same questions.. That's how lazy your professor is. I guess students know that b/c for some unexplainable reason many students couldn't be in school, on the day of the exam.

4.0
4.0
FIN9759
May 25, 2011

The most interesting aspect of this course was the in class discussion of newspaper articles as they pertain to M&A. The course will require a good amount of self-study and the only way you'll extract value is by attending class with a genuine interest in M&A.

1.0
5.0
FIN9759
Jun 1, 2011

Completely useless, both the professor and the content of the course. Reads straight from slides, no help w/ projects. If you don't kiss up to him, your grade will suffer. SHAME!

5.0
4.0
FIN9759
Jun 1, 2011

Professor Poniachek is really helpful. I didn't expected the class would teach me so much about Finance in depth. Though my grade doesn't show how much i learned in class but still i think this is the only class where i honed my finance skills close to perfection. The material and cases assigned by professor would really help in future at work plac

3.0
3.0
FIN9759
Jun 1, 2011

This is the worst professor I have ever taken. He is lazy and unhelpful. Completely useless. He was in class during teachers evaluations to intimidate students not to give him bad reviews. How pathetic?

5.0
4.0
FIN9759
Jun 2, 2011

Very knowledgeable professor in M/A ..If you want to go into investment banking this is the professor to take it with..

1.0
3.0
FIN9759
Jun 2, 2011

Don?t be fooled by the positive reviews on this site. The professor is posting them by himself. I do not know one person in the whole class that had positive experience with him. Waste of time and money. Very frustrating?

1.0
5.0
FIN9759
Jun 2, 2011

There was no student in my class who could say anything positive about this professor. We were miserable, bored. He repeats what was taught in "Financial Decision Making" and "Managerial Finance" classes. The only addition is history of M&A and lame court cases that no one needs. Plus, he picks on people who tend to skip classes

1.0
5.0
FIN9759
Jun 2, 2011

Avoid at all costs. He doesn't teach, just repeats the content of "Financial Dec. Making" and "Manager. Fin". The only addition is history of M&A and useless court cases

4.0
3.0
FIN9759
Jun 6, 2011

This is not an easy class, but if you want to know the nuts and bolts of M&A, I would recommend taking it. At the end of the course you will have enough knowledge to value a company with a certain degree of comfort.

1.0
5.0
FIN9759
Jun 15, 2011

All the students in my class complained he didn't teach. They said they were fooled by his positive reviews on this site. We figured he had written them himself. We had to study about 1800 pages for the final and all that was useless b/c the questions were out of nowhere. Whomever I know got either a B o B-. This class is useless

4.0
2.0
FIN9759
Jul 13, 2011

Not bad

5.0
3.0
FIN9788
Jul 16, 2011

Professor is very knowledgeable.I had no knowledge of international financial markets. He did a good job in explaining the most important concepts clearly. Make sure u attend lectures and participate in class. Book was also very helpful. Unless u really screw up in exams u can expect a good grade.

4.0
4.0
FIN9788
Jul 17, 2011

Take this course only if you're interested and focused. Professor goes fast because there's so much to cover. Pay attention and do the problems. No need to buy the book. Try to derive the models (CIA, PPP, IRP) instead of relying on the cheat sheet. This is a graduate level type course and the Final exam will challenge you. I learned a lot.

5.0
3.0
FIN9788
Jul 17, 2011

This course was my elective, my major is accounting; Yet, I found it very interesting and useful. The professor is really helpful, smart, and sweet. He went over the topics fast because it was a summer course and we didn't have much time to cover everything. Reading the book and doing the assigned HW really helps, it's not easy an easy class. Work!

2.0
4.0
FIN9788
Jul 18, 2011

This is a class that test your survival ability and self determination. You will not learn anything going to class except the case study. If you wanna do well, you gotta study a lot on your own. No doubt he's knowledgable, but some of his talents didn't translate into his teaching/lecture methods. Take at your own risk.

3.0
3.0
FIN9788
Jul 18, 2011

Prof. is knowledgable, however the short/stressed summer semester forced us to go through the materials really quick. Tests aren't easy, read the textbook !

1.0
5.0
FIN9788
Jul 19, 2011

I studied through book and got an "A". I ignored his teaching as he was nothing but confusing. Worst part, after I did well on exams and got an "A" he wrote me an email and begged that I give him a good review here. He also provided me with a link to this website. Simply pathetic. Avoid at all cost, I learnt nothing. Utter waste of time and money.

5.0
3.0
FIN9788
Jul 20, 2011

The course is challenging & interesting. The professor is extremely helpful & knowledgeable. It's not easy & you must follow the textbook readings & assigned problems. There's a lot of material to cover in a short amount of time. You must work. If you need help, approach the professor as he is available & informative. He's a great & fun teacher.

1.0
5.0
FIN9788
Jul 20, 2011

At least 1 thing is expected from a course:great learning or good grades. This guy gave really hard final but didn't teach anything. So no learning, no good grade. Prof claims not much can be covered in summer class. I think he forgets that while setting exam. Guys Stay away. I bet there would be a positive review after this from prof himself :)

1.0
5.0
FIN9788
Jul 24, 2011

Awful professor, final exam that brought a new meaning to "Academic Freedom"... I have dropped him from my next semester because he is so awful...

2.0
5.0
FIN9788
Jul 24, 2011

The professor gave a reasonable midterm exam, but a very tough final exam. If you want to do well, you must study on your own. The professor does not teach the material well and often unnecessarily confuses the students. He's a nice person, but not very good at explanation things. If you have another option, take another professor.

2.0
5.0
FIN9788
Jul 24, 2011

He was probably my worst professor taken during my graduate studies. His midterm was fair and even quite easy. But his final was night and day from the midterm, extremely hard. Covering materials not taught in class. His "lectures" are not much help, since he doesn't really teach the subjects. I would strongly advise to avoid this professor.

2.0
5.0
FIN9788
Aug 19, 2011

Worst finance professor at Baruch. Grades are pre-decided as he is extremely partial towards women. Cannot explain concepts at all. Sends an email to all A and A- students to rate positively on this website. Have learnt nothing out of this class. He gets nasty in class most of the times and has a very blunt sense of humor.

5.0
3.0
ECON101
Dec 27, 2011

Fine professor - You need to study from the textbook and be able to do all the homework and know the book's major terms.

1.0
5.0
FIN9788
May 7, 2012

the guy is useless yet the attendance is mandatory. Grades are very bad as he doesn't teach at all and the tests are simply ridiculous. it's hard to stay awake during his classes

1.0
5.0
FIN9759
Dec 26, 2012

Does not teach ANYTHING AT ALL!

1.0
2.0
FIN4930
Jun 5, 2013

1 midterm, 2 case studies, 1 final. Exams are fair. 40-50 questions, multiple choice/True & False. Also has short answer part for his exam. Nothing too difficult. Read the book, study the slides and you'll do well. Also, pay attention to the case studies. He allows 1 page of notes so use that to your advantage. As a professor, he's not very good.

5.0
3.0
MA
Jul 6, 2013

He is very knowledgeable and experienced in the field of M&A and brings real life examples to class discussions. The class is challenging and you have to prepare several presentations but this is a graduate level course and it is expected. He is ready to help with any questions. Exams are fair. Lecture notes are helpful so is the book.

4.0
5.0
FIN9759
Aug 27, 2013

Very smart man, I really enjoyed his dry sense of humor and discussion in class. His tests are VERY HARD and I did horribly, but he offers many chances to improve your grade. Speak up in class, volunteer for presentations and do well on the cases.

1.0
2.0
FIN2234
Aug 30, 2013

He is the worst professor I have ever had in my life! He does not teach ANYTHING, he is confusing, start talking about something and changes the subject suddenly... He asks questions that nobody understand what he actually wants to know!!! He is the worst ever!!! Also, there are more presentations than actual classes... AVOID HIM!

1.0
5.0
MANDA
Jan 15, 2015

He is unorganized, and speaks very low, so it is very difficult to understand him. His syllabus is confusing as it requires you to read around 6 different books, and are all very long readings. His slides have grammar mistakes and bc of his vague explanations, you have to teach yourself the material. I did not get anything out of this class sadly

1.0
5.0
FIN4930
Grade: Not sure yet
Nov 11, 2015

GPA Killer. You want to learn but his handwriting is terrible and you could barely hear him. You're 1 minute late and he will put you on the spot in front of everyone. Doesn't even tell you that the test ar based on cases so you lose 15 points because of this. Class is extremely unorganized, unannounced presentation on news article he assigns AVOID

1.0
5.0
FIN4930
Grade: A+
Dec 22, 2015

Absolutely horrible teacher, don't understand how he got this job as a professor.... Please retire or fire this guy ASAP!

3.0
3.0
FIN4930
Grade: A
Dec 23, 2015

He makes M&A very boring. Not very clear and speaks very low. Doesn't take attendance. 2 exams and 2 Harvard case studies. Textbook isn't really required.

3.0
3.0
FIN4930
Grade: A-
Dec 30, 2015

Nice guy, but you have to be really into the subject and follow market to participate in class. Two group projects which take forever... Also he is extremely quiet and if you are not in a first raw, presence on the lecture is completely useless.

1.0
5.0
FIN4930
Jan 4, 2016

How this person got to be the professor of anything is beyond me! He's a sexist and partial to women! He makes sexist jokes. He needs to be fired ASAP! Baruch has the worst professors ever.

1.0
4.0
FIN4930
Grade: A
Jan 5, 2016

He really didnt teach us anything, if attendance wasnt mandatory you wouldnt miss out not showing up to class, just print out his notes, understand the cases like unocal and revlon, do the harvard case studies and youll be fine- midterm and final arent so difficult- look over the slides

3.0
3.0
FIN4930
Grade: A
Jan 5, 2016

I think that he is knowledgeable in the field of M&A and teaches the class case by case which is the right way of teaching it. Many students are not interested in the class therefore they dont read anything at all, and when the exams come Harvey is to be blamed. However, he is nice enough to pass a lot of student who cant really pass the class.

1.0
4.0
FIN9781
May 28, 2016
Wouldn't take again

I regret not checking this website before taking his class. He is really unorganized and has no idea what he's teaching. Changed his mind often. It's absolutely a class where you learn a lot about how to survive in the real world with an emotional and sexist boss.

1.0
3.0
FIN4910
Jul 22, 2016
Wouldn't take again

Probably the worst professor I've taken at Baruch. He makes fun of students, and is just really bad at teaching. Says certain topics will be covered on exams but puts completely different ones. His lectures are pointless and if you ask a question he will belittle you in front of everyone, and still not answer your question. Avoid.

1.0
4.0
FIN2234
Grade: B
Nov 3, 2016
Wouldn't take again

Hands down the worst professor I've ever come across at Rutgers Business school. This professor needs to be retired, he speaks babble, has the worst handwriting ever, have him recorded saying he grades you on how he likes you. He is very smart but has no teaching capabilities, will call you out for being a minute late, WILL RUIN YOUR GPA

Get ready to read
TEST HEAVY
GRADED BY FEW THINGS
1.0
5.0
FIN9759MA
May 30, 2017
Wouldn't take again

This is a self-study course. The professor is knowledgeable, but can be disorganized and lazy. He has little interest in making the course and lecture slides useful and interesting for students. Make sure to read the textbook and his lecture slides to prepare for exams. Final was much harder than mid-term. Try taking another course if possible.

Get ready to read
TEST HEAVY
GROUP PROJECTS
1.0
4.0
FIN3000
Grade: Not sure yet
Jul 13, 2017
Wouldn't take again

Be prepared to teach yourself. You will learn nothing, and regret taking this class

5.0
2.0
FIN3000
Jul 16, 2017
Would take again

Great prof. Very knowledgeable and humorous. Fun class, but u need to read b4 lectures and keep practicing on calculation problems. Although he has accent, bad hand writing, the class itself is not hard. He gives reviews, which are very helpful. Pay attention to reviews. 70% will on the test. Test focus more on calculation.

Get ready to read
Inspirational
GRADED BY FEW THINGS
1.0
5.0
FIN3000
Aug 18, 2017
Wouldn't take again

He grades you based on how much he likes you. He is a horrible teacher. Get ready to teach yourself everything. READ READ READ the textbook. I would not take him again. He is also extremely rude to his students.

Get ready to read
4.0
3.0
FIN4930
Grade: A
Dec 28, 2017
Wouldn't take again

Prof. Poniachek was an ok choice at the end. Midterm extremely easy, worth 30%, 3 case studies and a final worth 50%. Final will surprise you because he is not very specific on the prep for it, and he just assumes that you're going to read all the sections of each chapter despite we did not go over them.

Participation matters
SO MANY PAPERS
Tests are tough
3.0
5.0
FIN2234
May 20, 2019
Wouldn't take again

Don't take him, he doesn't teach at all! He says problems are from HW in the exam, but they are not. If you get F on the first exam then just drop it, it's not worth it to sit through lectures, for another half of the semester. Take him if you all only if you know basic finance, and get ready to read, a lot! Prof is nice, but his lectures aren't

Test heavy
Lecture heavy
1.0
5.0
FIN4390
Grade: B
May 9, 2020
Wouldn't take again

I took his M&A class in 2014 and was extremely disappointed. His class is unstructured, over 3000 pgs of reading but nothing is covered in class. He talks very quietly and reads WSJ aloud for 30 min in each class. His exams are 100% testbanks with the midterm being easy and final hard. His final has long answer questions. Also is a biased grader.

Class Info

Attendance Mandatory

59%

Textbook Required

95%

Grade Predictor

Your expected effort level

LowHigh

Predicted Grade

A-

74% confidence
Based on 8 grades
Most common grades:
A (4)
Not sure yet (2)
B (2)
Grade Distribution
A(5)B(2)C(0)D(0)F(0)A-/B+(1)
Based on 10 reported grades
A: 4
Not sure yet: 2
B: 2
A+: 1
Common Tags
Get ready to read (4)
TEST HEAVY (2)
GRADED BY FEW THINGS (2)
GROUP PROJECTS (1)
Inspirational (1)
Participation matters (1)
SO MANY PAPERS (1)
Tests are tough (1)
Rating Trend

Declining

-1.06 avg change
May
Jul
Aug
Dec
May
May
Last 6 months
Ratings by Course

4910

5.0

(1)

FIN4920

5.0

(4)

MA9700

5.0

(1)

FIN4030

5.0

(1)

ECON101

5.0

(1)
+18 more courses
Difficulty by Course

FINAN4910

5.0

MANDA

5.0

FIN9759MA

5.0

FIN4390

4.5

FIN9788

4.2

Similar Professors