4.0

Jim Hartley

Economics - Mount Holyoke College

4.0
Quality
3.6
Difficulty
53%
Would Retake
88
Reviews
4.0
Quality
3.6
Difficulty
4.1
Helpful
3.9
Clarity

53%

Would Retake

88

Reviews

Rating Distribution
Official
88 total ratings

5

57

4

9

3

5

2

5

1

12

What Students Say

He was so open to questions and discussion, and going to his office hours helped a ton

ECON100 - 5.0 rating

Hartley ran an amazing class full of intelligent and groundbreaking discussions

COLL145 - 5.0 rating
Class Info

Attendance Mandatory

33%

Textbook Required

75%

Grade Predictor

Your expected effort level

LowHigh

Predicted Grade

A-

86% confidence
Based on 12 grades
Most common grades:
A (5)
A- (3)
B (2)
Grade Distribution
A(6)B(2)C(0)D(0)F(0)A-/B+(4)
Based on 14 reported grades
A: 5
A-: 3
B: 2
Audit/No Grade: 2
Common Tags
Get ready to read (6)
Lots of homework (2)
Inspirational (2)
Hilarious (2)
Tough grader (2)
Lecture heavy (2)
Graded by few things (2)
Test heavy (2)
Rating Trend

Declining

-0.52 avg change
Jun
Dec
Sep
Nov
Dec
Jan
Last 6 months
Ratings by Course

211338

5.0

(1)

ECON308

5.0

(1)

ECO

5.0

(1)

ALL

5.0

(1)

MACROECON

5.0

(1)
+32 more courses
Difficulty by Course

ECON308

5.0

ALL

5.0

MACROECON

5.0

MONEYBANKING

5.0

EC211

5.0

Reviews (87)
3.0
3.0
FRTRL199
Nov 27, 2002

Hmm ... he's really sarcastic and might insult you, but he's cool

5.0
5.0
ECON308
Dec 6, 2002

No Comments

5.0
3.0
ECO
Dec 27, 2002

No Comments

5.0
5.0
ECON338
Apr 8, 2003

He is a brilliant, brilliant man...who is always questioning your ideas, beliefs etc. He is a forceful and energetic lecturer who makes all his classes fun. There was a **** load of reading though.

5.0
4.0
ECON211
Apr 14, 2003

great professor! knowledgable, really really smart and helpful. also very funny - definitely made the class enjoyable. speaks a little too fast :)

5.0
4.0
ECON104
Apr 15, 2003

Awesome... interesting, intelligent and funny. Practically flawless

5.0
5.0
ALL
Apr 17, 2003

he is amazingly helpful and extremely intelligent!

5.0
5.0
MACROECON
May 8, 2003

He's a brilliant lecturer BUT gives the hardest exams!!! and *evil trick* questions :( :(

2.0
5.0
ECON104
Jun 13, 2003

No Comments

5.0
4.0
ECON
Jul 27, 2003

No Comments

4.0
4.0
ECON211
Nov 5, 2003

Great Lecturer. Will never fall asleep in his class. Loves to throw out curves in his exams so be prepared to work your butt off.

5.0
4.0
GREATBOOK
Nov 7, 2003

Great professor, great class. VERY helpful. LOTS of reading.

5.0
3.0
WESTERNCIV
Nov 14, 2003

Hartley talks wicked fast, but he's an AWESOME prof!!! Take a class with him if you can! He expects you to actually do the work and stuff, but it's worth it!

5.0
4.0
211338
Dec 7, 2003

One of best prof's I had at MHC. Memorable lectures (once you get past the pacing and fast talk). Always available outside of class for q's or just a chat. Exams are all essay questions and tough, but they really make you think and help you learn.

5.0
5.0
ECON
Dec 8, 2003

Excellent Professor + Advisor

5.0
4.0
WESTCIV
Feb 3, 2004

Professor Hartley Rocks! He keeps us thinking and we have a lot of fun in class! Highly recommended! be prepared for a lot of work

5.0
5.0
ECON
Mar 24, 2004

he is very hard, but very good

5.0
3.0
WESTCIV
Mar 29, 2004

Hartley is the best! He is so smart and interesting.

5.0
4.0
WESTCIV
Apr 7, 2004

Hartley ROCKS!!! It is a LOT of reading, but is totally worth it. No other class has made me think more. He is completely accessible and always available even to just chat. Take a class from him if you can!

2.0
4.0
ECONOMICS
Grade: B
Sep 30, 2004

Hartley is the most arrogant that I have ever met.

4.0
3.0
GREATBOOKS
Nov 10, 2004

I'm on my fourth year here at MHC and he's still the best professor I've encountered here. I don't like math and was intimidated by the subject, but he made it 100% manageable. He's always willing to re-explain things, and attempts all sorts of entertaining twists to help you understand better.

4.0
4.0
ECON338
Nov 13, 2004

Great class and great professor. He gets you thinking all the time and totally pushes you to learn. He's definetly one of the best professors at MHC. And you can always stop by his office just to chat.

2.0
3.0
WESTERNCIV
Nov 21, 2004

Ok, I knwo a lot of other PPL feel as I do but are keeping quiet for some reason...this class could be great but because of the way Hartley conducts it, I do not enjoy it at all. Sure, the discussions can be funny for a minute or two, but they are always the same and never lead to anywahere. He goes

3.0
5.0
MONEYBANKING
Nov 26, 2004

fun prof!

5.0
3.0
WESTERNCIV
Nov 30, 2004

I love this class and this man. Discussions are not only entertaining but also leave you questioning what you thought you knew. If you're open to it, he'll force you to really think and it's awesome. Almost ridiculously accessible and helpful. Charming nervous laugh; keeps chickens. Take the class.

2.0
4.0
WESTERNCIV
Dec 10, 2004

I cannot fathom how this man has elicited such a great response because his class is not well ordered, he is not a professor of the fields which we are discussing and his an arrogant, ****, offensive man. He has said some horrible things to people he does not apologize for. do not take this class.

2.0
4.0
WESTERNCIV
Dec 10, 2004

You will enjoy this class if you like to call Mahatma Gandhi an antisemite, if you are of the disposition that West. Civ. has done everything for the world in the intellectual sense. He teaches this class to forward his own ideals, not to foster discussion. He is creepy, his laugh is not charming.

5.0
4.0
WESTERNCIV
Dec 14, 2004

I heart Hartley!! He's such a great prof and an awesome person! Though he is a little arrogant, he certainly makes you think and always comes to class very prepared, he even does our homework assignments! Seriously though, ignore those nasty, spiteful comments about Hartley!

5.0
3.0
INDSTY
Feb 4, 2005

Excellent professor, very helpful. Take an independent study with him.

5.0
2.0
REFLECOFWAR
Mar 2, 2005

A hyper, loud, and infinitely aggrevating person. Clearly, don't take a class with him if any of those these things bother you. If you can get over them, you absolutely should, because he'll make you rethink the reasons you believe what you do: fantastic.

1.0
3.0
CIV
Apr 15, 2005

arrogant, obnoxious, not as smart as he thinks he is. not even close.

1.0
3.0
WESTERNCIV
Apr 20, 2005

absolutely awful. DO NOT TAKE WESTERN CIV FROM HIM for if you do, whenever you see his creepy face around campus, not only will you cringe in disgust but actually throw up a little in your mouth. Don't say I didn't warn you.

5.0
3.0
WESTERNCIV
May 30, 2005

I took both semesters of Western Civ with Hartley, and not only have I never thrown up in my mouth while looking at him, I also think he is the best professor at Mount Holyoke. So don't be scared. He's so friendly, and you'll learn a ton.

5.0
1.0
ECON211
Aug 4, 2005

He made me fall in love with economics.

5.0
3.0
CIV151
Aug 31, 2005

I feel so fortunate to have had Hartley first semester, first year. He has been a critical asset to my MHC career- always available for consultation on academics and everything else. He is very knowledgeable concerning professor and course quality. You do not need to be an econ enthusiast to appreciate this man.

5.0
1.0
ECON211
Sep 2, 2005

Very entertaining. Gives easy exams and repeats questions from midterms for the final. His conservatism and political incorrectness are almost refreshing on such a militantly liberal campus. Talks too much about his chickens, though.

4.0
3.0
MACROTHEORY
Sep 16, 2005

I took Macro Theory & Money & Banking w/ Jim. I loved his classes b/c they were never boring. yes he talks really fast & paces around the class room but he will talk about anything econ related or not & he's great at explaining & simplifying things.

5.0
3.0
MACROTHEORY
Nov 1, 2005

prof hartley is an amazing professor. my favorite one at mhc so far. he really makes the material come alive, even it's something as econ. there is never a dull moment in his class, especially with his twisted sense of humor. only in his class can you find out what happens if you die too early or too late. hahaha.

5.0
2.0
MACROTHEORY
Nov 2, 2005

Prof. Hartley is amazing. He loves teaching and is very good at it. I loved his Macro theory class and although the exams were hard, I actually enjoyed taking them. Weird huh!? I am definitely going to take Money and Banking with him next semester too!

5.0
4.0
MACROTHEORY
Jan 5, 2006

The greatest professor ever! He is so passionate about teaching and so aware of what's happening around students, that you can always get a useful advice career and course wise. This was the only class in which I never felt bored.

3.0
3.0
MACROTHEORY
Jan 25, 2006

Hartley is a very engaging professor. class is very interesting. The problem is he only covers the basics of the material. The exams are based on the book and the questions are much more complicated than anything he covers in class. The exams are extremely difficult/almost impossible, but luckily he curves.

5.0
4.0
ECON338
Apr 1, 2006

Funny, Intelligent, Engaging, Challenging.... Better class than I would have ever imagined!!

5.0
3.0
WESTERNCIV
Apr 1, 2006

Hartley is completely fantastic in the classroom, but the best part of all is how accessible he is out of class. He always has time for you, he gives great advice, and he's also just really funny. By far my favorite professor at MHC.

5.0
3.0
I145
Apr 1, 2006

A chili for hartley.

5.0
1.0
FACSHOW
Apr 2, 2006

Jim Hartley deserves a Chili pepper

5.0
3.0
GB0304
Apr 2, 2006

chili peppper material ;) awesome class, really helpful in class and forever after. knows all about classes and profs!

5.0
3.0
GB
Apr 2, 2006

Awesome guy, very helpful, fun class.

5.0
1.0
FACSHOW
Apr 3, 2006

Definitely deserves a chili pepper!

5.0
3.0
ECON
Apr 4, 2006

We need a facebook club to get Prof. Hartley a chili pepper. He certainly deserves it because he is a rockin' professor.

5.0
3.0
ECON100
Nov 28, 2006

I took the Great Books & Economics and it was one of the best classes I ever took. He was quite original in his presentation of the material and made me interested in a subject I never would have otherwise considered. definitely a great professor.

5.0
1.0
ECON101
Feb 21, 2007

Great Professor! Definitely take his class! You'll actually enjoy it more than you enjoy economics....

5.0
4.0
MANDB338
Apr 13, 2007

I heart hartley! An excellent professor- very clear and has a lot of knowledge on the macroeconomy.The readings for Money & Banking are a bit hard but since he doesn't expect u to read it all, it reduces the pressure on us and makes us enjoy class. He is much better than Robinson so pls make him Chair of the Dept!!

1.0
5.0
EC211
Jul 19, 2008

He has an enormous ego that gets in the way of his teaching. He seems very narrow minded.

5.0
4.0
COLL145
Sep 9, 2009

Hartley ran an amazing class full of intelligent and groundbreaking discussions! He always used humor to make our class think in new ways. Great professor!

5.0
3.0
ECON338
Jan 14, 2010

Professor Hartley has a very unique way of arranging his curriculum, relying heavily on non-fiction books. His tests are a bit tricky, but they are open-book. Do the readings, come to class, and take full advantage of his incredible receptiveness to questions. Prof Hartley is my favorite at MHC.

1.0
5.0
ECON103
Jan 21, 2010

Jim Hartley is a very poor professor. He uses his class less to teach economics then to preach an ideology. He has no ability as a teacher and tries to intimidate students. He brags about how hard he will grade and goes out of his way to be unhelpful even if you try to use his office hours. Avoid this professor!

5.0
4.0
ECON103
Mar 27, 2010

Fantastic. Challenging, clear. Really, everything you could ask for.

4.0
1.0
ECON103
Apr 8, 2010

Hartley was the worst professor I've ever had. His explanations are overly simplistic and lack nuance, as well as being exceptionally biased in favor of his political ideology. His lectures were carbon copies of the reading, so class was pointless/boring. His lectures are occasionally humorous, but that was his only redeeming quality. Avoid.

5.0
4.0
ECON101
Apr 12, 2010

Political ideology aside, Hartley is a great professor. He's patient, accessible, knowledgeable and he makes students think. The comment about him trying to intimidate students is ridiculous. You can't find a prof more interested in students' learning.

5.0
4.0
ECON103
Dec 7, 2011

I completely agree with the comment below. He is one of the few conservative professors at MHC, but he refuses to talk about his politics in class. Hartley is a very lively lecturer and comes up with great examples to explain the concepts. He truly loves economics!

3.0
3.0
ECON211
Jan 27, 2012

Avoid him! I didn't get a word of what he said in his lectures because he talked so fast. To make matters worse, he was very unclear about what he was saying. He knows his stuff but he's not good at teaching. He'll confuse you more than clarifying matters. I don't like his grading system.

4.0
4.0
ECON103
Jan 30, 2012

Make sure you use textbook intensively, it really helps for tests. Also all the supplementary reading he assigned, if your lazy make sure youve read half of each. He's very unclear about grading policy, mainly so that you concentrate on nonstop improvement. Even the author of textbook is a conservative, no surprise so he is

5.0
4.0
ECON202
Apr 11, 2012

Best professor I've had. He LOVES what he does and he loves getting to know his students not just in class but outside of classroom too. NEVER miss his lectures they are awesome. Make sure you read and do the problems in the textbook. You have to be highly self-motivated in his class. He doesn't give weekly hw assignments.

5.0
2.0
ECON211
May 1, 2012

THE BEST PROFESSOR EVER. He is soooo helpful, accessible and patient. I love him. He makes you 'think' how the economy functions. You will learn so much from him.For econ majors: You'll regret graduating from MHC with econ major without taking a class with Hartley. TAKE A CLASS WITH HIM!!! ITS TOTALLY WORTH IT. I LOVE HIM HE'S THE BEST PROFESSOR!

5.0
3.0
ECON211
Mar 14, 2014

He is so hot. I love him. He is patient and accessible. Funniest class I have ever taken.

3.0
3.0
ECON338
Mar 27, 2014

Prof. Hartley does not know how to structure a curriculum. There was no incentive to do the readings in this class, and he was very VAGUE about what he wanted from students in the papers. He's also very patriarchal and condescending in class. He is very helpful and is a great person to talk to OUTSIDE of class, but useless as a professor.

5.0
4.0
COMOR299
Apr 1, 2014

definitely gets a chili pepper

5.0
5.0
ECON338
Apr 14, 2014

He is an amazing professor. My favorite professor and class at MHC ever!

5.0
4.0
MACRO
May 23, 2014

Hartley, I never got to say good-bye at graduation! I only took one class with him, which was interesting and incredibly in depth. Such a great guy. And definitely deserves a chili pepper!

4.0
4.0
MACRO
Jan 8, 2015

Great class. One of the best classes I took this semester. He's a great lecturer, and I was never bored at his class. Definitely take a class with Hartley before graduating. He's also great to go talk to during office hours; he gives insightful advice! He's also a fair grader and really appreciates your improvement and effort you demonstrate.

1.0
4.0
COMOR299
Mar 5, 2015

really unclear of what he's teaching. gets annoying after 3 weeks sitting in class talking about stuff that are not important for the sake of humanity.

5.0
4.0
ECON338
Grade: A-
Nov 17, 2015

Hands down the greatest professor I've ever had. He genuinely respects and helps students. Please do not graduate from MHC without ever taking a class with him. At least go talk to him.

5.0
4.0
ECON100
Grade: B+
Jun 10, 2016
Would take again

I took Hartley's intro econ class last semester and although I found the content challenging, I liked the class. Hartley's enthusiasm for both the subject matter and teaching made me always want to come to class, even though the tests were based on the textbook. He was so open to questions and discussion, and going to his office hours helped a ton.

5.0
4.0
ECON211
Grade: A
Apr 27, 2017
Would take again

He's fair. Always there to help. Amazing lecturer. Best prof ever. I would take EVERY class he teaches. Love him.

1.0
3.0
ECON101
Nov 27, 2018
Wouldn't take again

just avoid him.

1.0
5.0
ECON100
Mar 24, 2019
Wouldn't take again

Intro to Econ class was incredibly frustrating because he assigned readings from a really dense textbook, to which he offered absolutely no guidance of what to expect on the exams, therefore the only way to pass the exams was to practically memorize the whole book. Also not good about responding to emails, nor answering questions clearly in class.

Lots of homework
Get ready to read
5.0
5.0
I145
Grade: A+
Aug 20, 2019
Would take again

MOST INCREDIBLE HUMAN. Do you question the state of society, your purpose, or the meaning of life? Read all the books. Ask all the questions. Play the devil's advocate. Read, keep asking questions, he is always available outside of class for existential ponderings. He values intellect that is formed outside of textbooks.

Respected
Inspirational
Hilarious
1.0
5.0
ECON101
Oct 21, 2019
Wouldn't take again

The professor's grading system is hugely unfair. There are only three times of test that matters which means each test takes 30%-40% of the final grade. There is no participation grade nor extra credit. He is not a reasonable teacher compares to others. However, he does talks about things related to eco in class.

Tough grader
4.0
5.0
ECON101
Grade: A
Dec 5, 2019
Would take again

I took Econ101 with Professor Hartley during my first semester at MHC and it was a challenging class. Your grade is determined by 2 midterms and 1 final exam. He is a really wonderful human being and person to talk to outside of class and will go over problems during office hours, but there is a ton of textbook readings and 3 supplemental books.

Lots of homework
Get ready to read
Lecture heavy
1.0
4.0
ECON110
Grade: Audit/No Grade
Dec 10, 2019
Wouldn't take again

Do NOT take him for introductory economics, unless you are willing to spend all your time studying for his class. His teaching method is completely incompatible with the exams, which are the only grades you receive in the course. AND his interactions with students in class were rude and condescending.

Get ready to read
Graded by few things
Test heavy
5.0
4.0
ECON211
Grade: A-
Jan 27, 2020
Would take again

Professor Hartley is an incredible person and an even better professor. His exams are hard, but not unfair, and he curves. The only people who struggle are those who don't read the extra readings (he assigns other non-fiction books as well as textbook readings) and those who don't ask questions/go to office hours. One of my favorite profs at MHC!

Accessible outside class
Skip class? You won't pass.
Test heavy
5.0
4.0
ECON338
Grade: A
Jun 2, 2022
Would take again

Hartley was an amazing professor to have for my senior year. While he assigned lot of reading and a large amount of homework each week, the work was very relevant and he really cared about how we engaged with the material. The longer book readings the week before a term paper, was usually the assigned reading for the longer papers. Highly recommend

Get ready to read
Amazing lectures
Inspirational
1.0
5.0
ECON211
Grade: A-
Dec 15, 2022

I learned most of the materials by myself, and he did not prepare well, especially the instructions after class. He acts like he is very humorous, but his loud voice makes me deaf. Even though his lecture was clear, I gradually got confused because it was kind of repetitive. I mean he made a simple question complicated and sometimes useless.

Clear grading criteria
Graded by few things
5.0
4.0
EOS299
Grade: A
Sep 19, 2023
Would take again

I had him for my first-year seminar and knew I had to take another class with him. Please take one of his "Great Books" courses before graduating! The discussions are fascinating and he's hilarious. He has made me have multiple existential crises. Be warned: He made us read a book a week for my CS Lewis FYSEM and this class, but it was worth it!

Get ready to read
Amazing lectures
Hilarious
1.0
5.0
FYSEM
Grade: Audit/No Grade
Nov 26, 2023

I'll start by saying that I'm typically a great student. I had to go ungraded because I couldn't reach this prof's insane standards. He straight-up told us that a good essay would receive no higher than a 70, but refused to provide clear guidelines for how to achieve a higher grade. He also takes meetings barefoot, which I found unprofessional.

Tough grader
Get ready to read
So many papers
5.0
3.0
FYSEM
Grade: A
Dec 6, 2023
Would take again

I love Jim. His class is ok, but definitely go to his office hours and become his friend - he's the greatest ally you'll make on campus! The grading system can be confusing at first, but it's not that bad. 70 on an essay doesn't mean 70%, it means 70 on the Hartley Scale of Arbitrary Evaluative Numbers. You will be fine.

Lecture heavy
1.0
3.0
FYSEM
Grade: B
Jan 30, 2025

Projects onto students and is unwilling to discuss other perspectives in a course which should be based on such.

Class Info

Attendance Mandatory

33%

Textbook Required

75%

Grade Predictor

Your expected effort level

LowHigh

Predicted Grade

A-

86% confidence
Based on 12 grades
Most common grades:
A (5)
A- (3)
B (2)
Grade Distribution
A(6)B(2)C(0)D(0)F(0)A-/B+(4)
Based on 14 reported grades
A: 5
A-: 3
B: 2
Audit/No Grade: 2
Common Tags
Get ready to read (6)
Lots of homework (2)
Inspirational (2)
Hilarious (2)
Tough grader (2)
Lecture heavy (2)
Graded by few things (2)
Test heavy (2)
Rating Trend

Declining

-0.52 avg change
Jun
Dec
Sep
Nov
Dec
Jan
Last 6 months
Ratings by Course

211338

5.0

(1)

ECON308

5.0

(1)

ECO

5.0

(1)

ALL

5.0

(1)

MACROECON

5.0

(1)
+32 more courses
Difficulty by Course

ECON308

5.0

ALL

5.0

MACROECON

5.0

MONEYBANKING

5.0

EC211

5.0

Similar Professors