3.3

Kate Butler

Law - University of Detroit Mercy Law

3.3
Quality
3.9
Difficulty
N/A
Would Retake
87
Reviews
3.3
Quality
3.9
Difficulty
3.1
Helpful
3.4
Clarity

N/A

Would Retake

87

Reviews

Rating Distribution
Official

5

25

4

21

3

18

2

15

1

8

What Students Say

Mildly entertaining - follow the Product liability & defamation attack outlines

TORTSII - 3.0 rating

Pros: she knows torts, you'll learn torts, gives very few bad grades

TORTS - 4.0 rating
Class Info

Textbook Required

100%

Grade Predictor

Your expected effort level

LowHigh

Predicted Grade

A-

53% confidence
Based on 1 grades
Most common grades:
A- (1)
Grade Distribution
A(0)B(0)C(0)D(0)F(0)A-/B+(1)
Based on 1 reported grades
A-: 1
Rating Trend

Stable

-0.10 avg change
Sep
Nov
Mar
Apr
May
Apr
Last 6 months
Ratings by Course

TORTSIANDII

5.0

(1)

TORT

5.0

(1)

TORTS1N2

5.0

(1)

TORTTOEQ

5.0

(1)

TORTS12

4.5

(2)
+20 more courses
Difficulty by Course

TORTSONE

5.0

TRTII1

5.0

TORTS22

5.0

TORTS106

5.0

TORTII

5.0

Reviews (87)
4.0
4.0
LAW
Mar 24, 2003

very hyper

3.0
3.0
TORTSII
May 2, 2003

Mildly entertaining - follow the Product liability & defamation attack outlines!

1.0
3.0
TORTSII
Jun 13, 2003

No Comments

5.0
4.0
TORTS
Oct 22, 2004

EXCELLENT PROFESSOR!!!!!!!!

4.0
3.0
TORTS
Oct 25, 2004

I had Butler for I and II. She's not a popular proessor, but she was one of my personal favorites. Pros: she knows torts, you'll learn torts, gives very few bad grades. Cons: can be a bit drama queen at times, gives very few A's... an A- got a book award one term.

4.0
2.0
TORTSI
Feb 14, 2005

Smart prof, but a little too condescending in class. Assumes the first-termers are kindergartners. Her class notes that she posts to TWEN assure a good grade.

2.0
4.0
TORTSII
Feb 19, 2005

No Comments

1.0
5.0
TORTSII
Feb 19, 2005

No Comments

5.0
3.0
TORTSIANDII
Mar 12, 2005

Good.

5.0
4.0
TORTSI
Apr 14, 2005

She really knows her stuff, and you will learn Torts from her. She is a very tough grader, gives very few A's if any at all. Can be very condesending in class, and will get on your case if you don't respond to her right away.

3.0
4.0
TORTS1
Apr 27, 2005

Does know her stuff but extremly rude to students and is a bit flighty in class. Be prepared for class or she will ream u out. and have good questions if u want to meet with her, or she will be mean.

5.0
5.0
TORTSI
May 11, 2005

She is hard. But you will learn torts. She is fair, clear and an excellent professor. I think she is the best prof at Cooley. She is also a tough grader. Be prepare for her class.

4.0
4.0
TORTSII
Jun 30, 2005

gives lot of information, very clear, and funny. her power points are awesome and very helpful and she definitely knows what she teaches. exam could be quite demanding though. but she gives you all you need to know for the exam.

4.0
2.0
TORTS2
Jul 25, 2005

You get called on as a part of a group instead of individual recitation. Extremely outspoken liberal. Sometimes she can be offensive to people who do not think like her. Oh and don't even think you will finsh her exam!!! Fair grader though.

3.0
5.0
TORTSI
Aug 30, 2005

No Comments

4.0
3.0
TORTSI
Sep 5, 2005

****y but a good teacher

5.0
2.0
TORT
Dec 14, 2005

Great professor. Really helps you prepare for her exam...but it's a horse race. First one to the end wins the A. (or maybe it's the only one to finish). But if you don't make it, she's very fair.

5.0
3.0
TORTSI
Jan 4, 2006

She is a consummate teacher! Very good at conveying the material. Exam was tough to complete in time alotted, but fair grader. Best teacher so far (just one term completed).

2.0
3.0
TORTS
Jan 14, 2006

Worst professor I ever had a Cooley. Stay away from her.

3.0
4.0
TORTSI
Jan 19, 2006

Goes into great detail, gives alot of practice assignments, not enough time to thoroughly finsh her tests, can be rude at times when trying to arrange appointments or ask for help.

5.0
5.0
TORTSII
May 22, 2006

Arguably, one of Cooley's most competent professors. Really likes to be in control and can be demeaning at times. A born teacher. Lots of great preparation. If she could lighten up a little and become kinder - she could be an awesome professor on par with Tahvonen or Prygoski. If I pass the bar the first time I will have her to thank.

4.0
3.0
TORTS2
May 26, 2006

She was organized with power points, and made each topic make sense. Her exam is impossible to finish and she does this purposely to reward the students who know it dead on. Point spread was ridiculous though, out of 130+ kids only 19 got a B or higher. Bottom line = work real hard to get a B- just like everyone else

2.0
4.0
TORTSII
May 28, 2006

Unless you have extended time, avoid her class. She writes exams that are not manageable in the 2hrs and 45 mins (she is fully aware of this). Also, she gets her kicks out of writing useless disparaging comments on your "Skills Checklist". And she is not interested in any suggestions. I personally would never share any class time with her again.

2.0
4.0
TORTSII
Jun 26, 2006

Let the horserace exam begin

3.0
5.0
TORTS2
Aug 9, 2006

Exam was impossible to finish.

5.0
5.0
TORTS2
Aug 21, 2006

The most demanding professor in the school. However, she makes up for it with her enthusiasm, clarity, and office hours. Definitely meet with her one on one so she can tell you what she wants to see on the exam.

5.0
1.0
TORTSI
Oct 31, 2006

Honestly, I have read the rest of the comments on here and am kind of disappointed. Althought very "left winged" and "political" she is an amazing teacher. If you pay attention, you can't help but succeed. It is what you are willing to put into it. I would take her again if I could. She is enthusiastic and highly intelligent.

5.0
3.0
TORTS1
Nov 4, 2006

Hilarious in class and very helpful in understanding the concepts. I can no longer hear the word "coffee" without thinking "..and sex"

3.0
3.0
TORTSTORT
Dec 23, 2006

not intrested in your CONTINUED use of life stories!!!

2.0
3.0
TORTSI
Mar 8, 2007

Good teacher but very condescending

3.0
5.0
TORTSII
Apr 2, 2007

No Comments

4.0
4.0
TORTS1
Apr 11, 2007

Great prof overall. She has a great way of getting you to understand tricky material. She's methodical and organized. She is VERY demanding on the exam but it's do-able. Essays are very long and most will not finish. MCQs are pretty straightforward. Loved her candor!

2.0
5.0
TORTSONE
Apr 21, 2007

She goes to great lengths to make her classes interesting and clear to students. Prepare for her exam by doing ALL of her practice questions because they are right on point, especially her MC questions. You can only do bad in here if you are lazy and don't put in the effort by doing her practice packet. You will not finish her exam, so hury up!

4.0
4.0
TORTS1
May 8, 2007

Teaching style was OKAY. If asked a question she didn't know the answer to she would insult the student and avoid the question as if it was simply idiotic. Says she doesn't want you to "outline dump" on the exam but that is EXACTLY WHAT SHE WANTS. If you can outline dump and manage to finish (which is a task w/in itself) you should be okay.

1.0
5.0
TORTSII
Jun 1, 2007

No Comments

4.0
3.0
AAAAA21A
Jun 1, 2007

Some were afraid of her but I loved her in-class hypos..even when i was reciting..your hand will fall off during her final..and it will come down to the wire time-wise..that is if you are doing it correctly and getting everything in.

2.0
3.0
TORTHIL
Jun 6, 2007

Good teacher but she is not a reasonable grader. It is true she won’t give lots of Fs and Ds, but she would give the whole bunch of Cs and Cs- that would really screw your GPA. Try to avoid. No chances on appeal.

4.0
5.0
TORTSI
Jul 18, 2007

Unreasonable grader. Focus on one question and finish rather than trying to get something down for both. Won't finish and even if you do, it won't be good enough. Grade appeals, as said before, are a waste of time

5.0
4.0
TORTSI
Jul 25, 2007

I am very disappointed at how many law students are afraid of hard work and difficult exams. I can assure you that the Bar Exam is no walk in the park. A few years from now, when you suddenly have to recall all of the elements of the seven intentional torts, you'll thank her. And yes, I passed on the first try.

3.0
5.0
TORTS1
Jul 30, 2007

Ready, willing, and able to tear you a new one.

4.0
4.0
TORTSI
Aug 18, 2007

Wow, just got done with her exam. She had the best of the bunch and she is notorious for her hard exams. At least she was honest about hers. You won't finish; if you do, you probably failed or cheated. She will take the time to go over things with you so go to her office hours and use our laptop on the exam. Not using one cost me an A for sure.

3.0
4.0
TORTS1
Sep 13, 2007

Professor Butlers exams are possible to finish, and you can do well on them even though you've finished. Professor Butler keeps class funny and interesting and does a good job teaching the material. If you work hard, and study the right things you will be ok, if you fool around youll get smoked. So make sure you JUST WORK AND STUDY HARD!!!!!!!!!!!!

2.0
5.0
TORTS1
Oct 5, 2007

Annoying, looks down on students, so what you went to Northwestern.Its amazing how I got a B in that stupid class with 12.5 out of 60 on the essay. I also got an A in torts 2 with a reasonable, rationale professor. avoid Butler, after your first year.

3.0
5.0
TORTSI
Dec 12, 2007

Tough professor. Finals are grueling and you will be lucky to finish. Class is passible if you study hard. She does have a good sense of humor.

3.0
5.0
TORTS1
Jan 7, 2008

Beware the Butler! She is a good teacher, but will blindside you w/her exam. Just make sure to read EVERYTHING and understand the hell outta neglig. She's very helpful if you meet with her, so i'd suggest that as it takes more than the class lecture 2 understand neglig well enough to be able to avoid the manhandling she's gonna do 2 u on her exam.

4.0
5.0
TORTSII
Jan 28, 2008

If you are even considering transferring from Cooley then drop her class immediately. Her exam is impossible to get a good grade even if you know the material. DO NOT TAKE HER CLASS!

2.0
4.0
TORT1
Jan 30, 2008

If she grades, she's a tough grader. Ridiculous exams I will not take her class again.

4.0
4.0
TORTS2
Feb 9, 2008

She is what is wrong with Cooley. No, she IS Cooley. Makes students believe that they a chance, then puts things on her test not covered in class. Her tests are difficult, not to extract knowledge, but to prove to herself that she is smarter than her students. We are your legacy, and according to your grades we suck. What does that say about you?

3.0
5.0
TRTII1
Feb 13, 2008

I had Prof. Butler for two classes. I got two bad grades. I don't know anyone that got a grade higher than a (3.0/B). Her exams are structered so the student can't finish them in the time given. You don't have time to think about an answer. This is the warning I wish I had: DO NOT RISK TAKING HER CLASS IF YOU WANT TO TRANSFER!

5.0
4.0
TORTS1N2
Mar 2, 2008

I don’t understand all of this negative feedback- Are we talking about the same person? I had Prof Butler for 2 terms and I consider her to be one of the finest profs I have ever encountered. She was always available if I needed anything, even outside of class. Don’t listen to any of these bitter students- They simply did not work hard enough.

5.0
3.0
TORTS1
Mar 11, 2008

Is a great teacher. LOVE her stories and she makes Torts seem interesting. But she's tough as nails on her exams.

5.0
1.0
TORTS12
Apr 17, 2008

She is easier than everyone makes her out to be.Her exam is about issue spotting. People don't finish her exams because they talk about irrelevant material.You guys need to practice issue spotting.She gives you a great exam pack and you can basically cut and paster than answers, smack on a couple of facts and get an A.Wish she taught more classes.

5.0
2.0
TORTS1
May 23, 2008

I had Butler for my 1st term. So many roomers are going around @ Cooley. People told me all bad stuff about Prof. Butler. From all my first term Profs she was the most caring & helpful Prof. Students dont do the work, and then complain about getting a bad grade. I did the work and got an A-. Its possible to do well in her class. (If you want)

5.0
2.0
TORTS1
Jun 1, 2008

I don't know why students are complaining about Prof. Butler. This last exam had 66 MC and if you only got right 45 out of 66 plus 12 out of 20 on the mid term, and 12 points on intentional torst and 18 points on negligence your have Total of 87 points, YOU would get a B-. I don't know how stupid students can't at least an C which is only 75 points

4.0
5.0
TORTS12
Jun 11, 2008

ROOMERS?? ROOMERS??? Are you kidding me.(that is directed to the person 2 ratings down. It's stupidity like that which made me work hard to transfer out of Cooley, and I am so glad i succeeded in my quest. I got an A- in torts1 and a B in torts2 with Butler. I definetly got screwed in torts2,very hard exams, rivaled only by crim-pro

5.0
2.0
TORTSI
Jul 10, 2008

Prof. Butler has been my favorite so far. She may be a tough grader, but her classes are interesting, and she is entertaining. She only gives a hard time to the people that obviously didn't do their work and don't even attempt to hide it. (Even then she lets them off lighter than I would).

3.0
5.0
TORTS22
Jul 19, 2008

First of all... the rumors about Butler failing people ARE TRUE... point blank: DO NOT TAKE BUTLER IF YOU'RE CONSIDERING TRANSFERING OUT OF COOLEY LAW! Consider yourself warned!

4.0
4.0
TORTS1
Aug 24, 2008

I was one point away from an A in her class. My advice: Test = horse race; You will get more points if you finish the test and hit the easy stuff rather then finishing one essay with great detail. Secondly, DO THE COURSE PACK! She loves questions dealing w/ colleges and students. Think outside the box on your analysis. Be brief & get to the point.

5.0
5.0
TORTS1
Nov 26, 2008

One quote that I remembered from Butler is her saying, "If I was your b-ball coach and you kept missing lay-ups, I wouldn't pat you on the back and tell you great job. I'd show you how you can improve you skills." That's exactly what she has done for me and MANY OTHERS. Hard coach= SOMEONE WHO CARES ABOUT MY SUCCESS!

5.0
5.0
TORTS1
Nov 28, 2008

There is perhaps no one in this school who cares more about student success than Butler. In addition to making herself available at any time, she frequently runs after hours seminars on exam success. Her exams are hell, though - pure horse race. Don't finish early. If you think you're done you've missed 90% of the issues.

2.0
5.0
TORTSI
Aug 26, 2009

Had her for tortsI & II. What u should do is sign up for 1 class more than u r going 2 take, if u get Butler, drop her! If u don't, drop that other class! She gives next to no practice essays and the exam will feel like a total blindside! She gets off on it! Other profs actually try to prepare you for the exam by giving you 50 practice essays.

2.0
5.0
TORTSI
Sep 30, 2009

Exam is too long to finish, don't let her convince you otherwise, unless of course you get extra time and then this class is perfect for you. Be prepared to be talked down to.

5.0
5.0
TORTS1
Dec 28, 2009

Exam is brutal and you will not finish. She will go the extra mile to give you help. Take advantage of it!!! If you put the effort in your grade will show it, if not, YOUR GRADE WILL SHOW IT. AS with all law school classes, you have to work for it if you want it. Her grading is very fair.

4.0
3.0
TORTSII
Jan 3, 2010

Just want to make some points that others are not. It is possible to finish...I did. I received an A-, missed A by 1 pt. Just do not listen to her if she tells you that you don't have to expand on an issue when it is obvious. For instance; if its clear its a defamatory statement she will say in class no need to expand...not true got 1 out of 8pts

5.0
5.0
TORTS1
Jan 11, 2010

Prof Butler is an extremely difficult teacher, but is extremely good at what she does. She teaches the material exactly how she expects you to learn and practice it, and will always give help and answer questions. She gives an exam study pack that has past questions and does not stray far from that. She might be overly hard, but she is fair.

5.0
4.0
TORTSI
Jan 13, 2010

Prof. B goes way above and beyond the call of duty as a professor in helping out her students. She is an awesome prof and is often humorous. The exam is going to be the hardest you take this term, but not by much. Just take advantage of the extra sessions she provides and do the problems in her study pack and on TWEN, and you'll do fine.

5.0
2.0
TORTTOEQ
Jan 25, 2010

Take Butler if you plan to practice tort law or to pass the class. She is crystal clear, to the point, repeats material over and over so it gets stuck in your head. Her exams are not hard if you attended all her lectures. DO NOT spend more then 10 min. on the outline (on scratch paper) during the exam. I waisted 35min - bad idea!!! Great teacher

3.0
4.0
TORTS1
Jan 25, 2010

Even if you understand everything in class, she will rip you up on her essay. I went to every class she had on essay writing ended up with a B-! She tells you not to outline dump, but I don't see how else you will pass. Personally, I tried talking to her one on one the other day and she told me "I'm not listening to you now, try again tomorrow".

4.0
4.0
TORTS2
Apr 30, 2010

Prof Butler's class is always entertaining. She is funny and knows her stuff. Don't try to argue with her in class. The exams are extremely long, and she will tear your essay apart. If you work hard, you should do well.

3.0
3.0
TORTS2
May 27, 2010

I will agree that she is easy to understand and would be a great professor IF her exams were refelective her teaching methods.This is the only class where it is impossible to finish her exam. If I could avoid her I would!!

4.0
3.0
TORT102
Aug 2, 2010

Her exams are ridiculous. Why give an exam that is designed for the student not to finish. If you try to finish, you will have incomplete answers. 1 point frim an A...answer was right on the paper, she clearly overlooked it, NO DICE on appeal. I would avoid her like the plague. She has a great abilility to talk down to people...2 much LIB BS.

3.0
5.0
TORTSI
Jan 22, 2011

Teaches well; really brings home the point she's trying to make. The only problem is that she completely degrades her students in the process. There's really no need for her to speak to her students the way she does. Can't really complain about anything else. She provides many means for you to practice on your own (don't approach her w/problems)

5.0
3.0
TORTS1
Feb 7, 2011

First of all, her exam is very long and difficult to finish. She's not an easy grader either. But, if you go to class, do the reading, DO THE PRACTICE questions and exams, there is absolutely no way you should do poorly. I didn't even finish the essay and I got an A-. It's possible. Her curve reflects the fact that she knows she's a hard grader.

1.0
5.0
TORTS106
Jul 3, 2011

She likes male students & can be very rude 2 females. She can be very condescending 2. Most students in their 1st & 2nd terms will get her not knowing anything about her. She has failed so many students I think she was reprimanded by having 2 teach on Sundays. Run! Take some1 else, even wait a term & take a another class. She ruins GPAs bigtime!

2.0
4.0
TORT2
Jul 7, 2011

Knows her stuff but often goes off track about details of things not relevant to passing the class or the bar exam. Too often, actually. Not getting thru the most important stuff & not spending quality time on it is frustrating! outline dumping is necessary. Don't expect to write short concise answers..model answers are long winded.

3.0
5.0
TORTII
Aug 29, 2011

I do not suggest her to first term students. You will be in shock because she tries so hard to be HARD! She is also rude and will talk down to people. To be fair, she does offer extra help but her personality made me never go to meet with her one on one.

3.0
3.0
TRTII2
Dec 5, 2011

AVOID her! She is mean and nasty. she treats her students like garbage. Exam was brutal, but the curve made it not so bad in the end. I scored under a 60% on the test, which ended up being an A-. Don't have to do too well on the exam, just score better than your classmates. This lady gets off on other people's pain and suffering...

5.0
4.0
TORTSII
Nov 3, 2012

Yes her exam is not easy, but there are no surprises. She's extremely helpful, but the hardest thing is to do the practice questions and practice essays. Just do them and she will tell you how you're doing. She gives extra lectures on how to study and even made a study pack. If you don't do it, that's your own fault.

2.0
4.0
TORTSI
Aug 7, 2013

Too many tangents, too many hiccups with presentation, & assignment of homework is constantly changed-- wouldn't be so strict, but c'mon, she's an author of the textbook! Final is on the difficult side, but mostly due to very anal grading.

2.0
3.0
TOEQ304
Sep 14, 2013

She was an English teacher prior to earning a law degree. Her stories about a brief stint at a law firm make you realize why she has spent her career in the classroom and not the courtroom. She is scattered from day one. Responses to student questions leave u wanting her to stay focused and get to the point. Tenured professor -needs quality review.

2.0
3.0
TORTSI
Nov 2, 2013

Overly critical of writing assignments. Tears class down rather than building it up. Knows her stuff if you can get through the terrible attitude and constant insults.

1.0
5.0
TORTLAW
Nov 13, 2013

I think it's time for Professor Kate to retire! This grandma just can't be teaching anymore like this. She is rude, insulting, mood constantly changing, snapping.. She thinks if she could be "tough" that these students will come out of Cooley as Pit Bulls. Kate, go home and relax, you did a great job!

1.0
5.0
TORTS1
Nov 23, 2013

Indeed, she is rude. She had 10+ years to rehearse the material whereas we are new to the concept of Tort law. She loses her patience insanely fast. I heard she gives all zeros on final exams. Yeah, it has been an awful experience so far.

1.0
5.0
TORTSII
Mar 29, 2014

She will damage your GPA! You will not know the mood she's in when she's grading your final exam. You see her in class just losing it. Her moods always appear to be constantly changing. I am not sure that she is in a state to be actually teaching.

4.0
4.0
TORTSII
Apr 20, 2014

Very hard on your writing assignments but her lectures are very clear. She tells you that her test/exams are hard and long and they are. There are no surprises. Just have to devote the time to subject.

4.0
4.0
TORTSI
Grade: A-
May 26, 2014

I loved this class. Of course it is hard, Professor Butler is teaching it. However, she is who she is and she doesn't try and pretend to be something else. The tests are difficult and long, but if you study hard and memorize the coursepack, you should do well! Go into class telling yourself you like Kate, that will help :)

1.0
5.0
TORTS
Apr 10, 2015

This was a negative experience. Very negative environment and degrades the class. Although I do well in my other classes I felt like she thought we were stupid.

Class Info

Textbook Required

100%

Grade Predictor

Your expected effort level

LowHigh

Predicted Grade

A-

53% confidence
Based on 1 grades
Most common grades:
A- (1)
Grade Distribution
A(0)B(0)C(0)D(0)F(0)A-/B+(1)
Based on 1 reported grades
A-: 1
Rating Trend

Stable

-0.10 avg change
Sep
Nov
Mar
Apr
May
Apr
Last 6 months
Ratings by Course

TORTSIANDII

5.0

(1)

TORT

5.0

(1)

TORTS1N2

5.0

(1)

TORTTOEQ

5.0

(1)

TORTS12

4.5

(2)
+20 more courses
Difficulty by Course

TORTSONE

5.0

TRTII1

5.0

TORTS22

5.0

TORTS106

5.0

TORTII

5.0

Similar Professors