3.6

Lisa Zilney

Justice Studies - Montclair State University

3.6
Quality
3.9
Difficulty
58%
Would Retake
114
Reviews
3.6
Quality
3.9
Difficulty
3.6
Helpful
3.7
Clarity

58%

Would Retake

114

Reviews

Rating Distribution
Official
114 total ratings

5

55

4

18

3

12

2

12

1

17

What Students Say

She isn't helpful at all

JUST101 - 2.0 rating

Took her for a 3 week summer course and was easily the worst decision I've ever made

JUST400 - 3.0 rating
Class Info

Online Classes

100%

Attendance Mandatory

29%

Textbook Required

0%

Grade Predictor

Your expected effort level

LowHigh

Predicted Grade

B+

95% confidence
Based on 24 grades
Most common grades:
A (8)
B (3)
A+ (3)
Grade Distribution
A(11)B(6)C(2)D(0)F(1)A-/B+(4)
Based on 27 reported grades
A: 8
B: 3
A+: 3
Not sure yet: 3
Common Tags
Get ready to read (11)
Tough Grader (9)
Clear grading criteria (7)
Gives good feedback (5)
Tough grader (5)
Respected (3)
EXTRA CREDIT (3)
SO MANY PAPERS (2)
Rating Trend

Declining

-0.65 avg change
May
Jan
May
Jan
Apr
Nov
Last 6 months
Ratings by Course

221

5.0

(1)

SOC301

5.0

(1)

SOCI101

5.0

(1)

JUSTICE

5.0

(1)

ENVIROJUSTICE

5.0

(1)
+31 more courses
Difficulty by Course

SOCI30103

5.0

JUVENILEJUSTIC

5.0

JUST202

5.0

DRUGS300

5.0

JUSTICE300

5.0

Reviews (113)
1.0
5.0
JUST221
Oct 25, 2004

sucked

4.0
4.0
JUST221
Nov 2, 2004

Lisa is great!The course is hard because of the material,not her!Exams are tough but she is very generous with extra help & extra credit. She's very willing to help you do the best you can. She's intelligent and has a good sense of humour. Take her if you like a challenge! College isn't easy!

5.0
5.0
SOCI301
Nov 15, 2004

This class is extremely difficult, though the professor does everything possible to help students understand the material. She is tough, but fair. You will learn a great deal, but have to 'earn' your grade.

5.0
3.0
SOCI301
Nov 22, 2004

this class is required as you all know but must be done...lisa is very helpful considering the material and wants her students to inderstand to the best of their ability. Her canadian/southern accent makes her a true individual!!!! She's very cute and likeable...

5.0
5.0
JUST221
Nov 27, 2004

Very difficult class but Lisa tries to make it understandable/interesting. Many opportunities to improve your grade for those who put in the effort. The course material is horrible, but Lisa is energetic, fun, and cute which makes the class okay. I think she'd be great for another class!

5.0
2.0
SOCI301
Dec 2, 2004

The course material is not terribly interesting, but Prof Zilney does her best to make it so. She offers lots of extra credit opportunities and will respond to email very quicly if available take her courses!!

5.0
4.0
SOC301
Dec 15, 2004

ok class is hard but lisa does a lot to make the class fun, and mind you she is nice to look at so it makes the class go by. Especially when she writes on the blackboard! If you know what i am saying.

1.0
5.0
SOCI301
Apr 22, 2005

She gives too much work and not enough time to complet the work. She makes you stressed out. She makes the class very hard and I woudl not recommend her!

1.0
5.0
SOCI30103
May 10, 2005

she is very unfair, and very hard grading, i will not recommend her at all. if she likes you, you'll not problems but if she doesn't you're in big trouble.

1.0
5.0
SOCI30103
May 12, 2005

sucked!!!do not take her, avoid her...not a good teacher, can't teach...

1.0
5.0
JUVENILEJUSTIC
May 17, 2005

Takers herself WAY to seriously. Get ready for a crazy workload and no exceptions.

4.0
3.0
SOCIALRESEARCH
May 17, 2005

Dr. Zilney's tests are very hard but so is the subject matter. She gives 3 additional projects which she will spend all weekend correcting via email until you get an A. If you don't seize those opportunities, you won't do as well, but utilize that, show up for class, do the extra credit and you will do well even if you did bad on the exams.

5.0
5.0
SOCI301
May 19, 2005

This class is so hard! Prof. Zilney works harder than any other professor at MSU to help you succeed. There is a lot of work, but if you put in the effort and take advantage of blackboard and office hours, you will earn a good grade. Lisa knows a lot about methods and tries to make the class interesting. Great professor, very hard class.

5.0
3.0
221
Jun 30, 2005

No Comments

5.0
5.0
JUST221
Grade: B
Aug 19, 2005

This was a very difficult class. However, she does her best to make it interesting. I have learned more from this class than any other. Professor Zilney is very intelligent and I would highly recommend her.

5.0
2.0
SOCI101
Aug 25, 2005

She is great. Easy if you follow her instructions and summer classes with her are easy. Dont take the class if you are unwilling to put effort into it though.

5.0
4.0
JUST200
Aug 30, 2005

Intensive summer writing class crammed into 3 weeks. Very interesting material with a lot of opportunity for discussion. No exams but over 11 reflective papers are assigned. Lisa does a great job leading this class and it's very informative. You will learn something! Be prepared to read and write!

5.0
4.0
JUSTICE
Sep 4, 2005

lisa is the the best professor i have ever had, and i am awesome so take her!!but get ready to work (this is college)

4.0
2.0
JUVDEL
Nov 8, 2005

class is easy. 2 page paper due every week..very helpful will let you redo a paper if you dont like the grade you got

1.0
5.0
JUS200
Dec 17, 2005

Very strict, not very helpful, poor people skills

5.0
4.0
ENVIROJUSTICE
Jan 10, 2006

Came off really tough in the first week. But really turned on that around during the semester as 80% of the class dropped the course. No exams,a 4 page reaction papers are due every week on readings/videos. Also a 7 page case study paper that you need to give a CASUAL speech on. A great professor, but the workload was a lot. Pleasing to eye as well

3.0
4.0
SOCI301
Jan 13, 2006

Miss Zilney is SEXY!!! Class was hard because it was incredibly boring, and at times Miss Z was sort of a smart A**. Hard to give her what she is asking for, but if you choose a easy topic, ot makes the class a little easier.Wish i could of worked sumtin out wit her on a date to better my grade and for myself.

1.0
5.0
JUST200
Jan 16, 2006

TO MANY PAPERS REQUIRED AND GRADING PROCESS WAS VERY HARD

5.0
4.0
SOCI301
Jan 18, 2006

Lisa's class is very challenging. Isn't that what college is about? She is very willing to help and also gets to know who you are and remembers your name-which does not happen very often with professors at MSU. If you want to be very prepared for senior research- take her for methods it will help you more thant you know!

5.0
3.0
ENVSTUDIES
Feb 20, 2006

Lisa is the best !

1.0
5.0
JUST200
Feb 28, 2006

Nice looking lady...but a real nightmare and she is not clear. Do not waste your time because she does not explain herself and wants you to but in much more work than needed to past the class.

5.0
4.0
JUST200
Mar 13, 2006

Course material interesting. Lots of writing, but you can redo all assignments for a higher grade. Lots of comments on papers, very helpful if you go to office hours. Not an easy class, but info is good, prof is informed (and hot!)

2.0
5.0
JUST202
Apr 9, 2006

REQUIRES TO MUCH WRITING

5.0
4.0
JUST200
Apr 24, 2006

Films and lectures good. Very helpful one-on-one! You must go to class and participate and read hte book to get a good grade. Great prof.

5.0
5.0
JUST221
Apr 26, 2006

good professor, but class is way too hard. too many notes, tests are CRAZY HARD, project is 6 stages & a pain in the @ss. unfortunately u need it to do an internship though. great professor tho-always available outside of class 24/7!

5.0
4.0
JUST200
May 12, 2006

Just a really great teacher, very smart, gets you thinking about the reality of our society. Discusses material other prof. ignore. Recommended!

2.0
3.0
SOCIALTHEORY
May 25, 2006

No Comments

5.0
3.0
JUST200AND22
Jul 21, 2006

She is very grounded and real (she will be like, ok this is boring and we need a break), demands your best performance and you cannot sneak anything over on her. if you do, she will call you out on it and laugh at you. Relates course info to interesting topics, ie violence, etc.

5.0
5.0
JUST221
Aug 25, 2006

She is very nice and approachable but dont confuse that with an easy grade. She's very demanding and expects a lot - Yes, being late will cost you! However, the course is hard on its own. No way around the 6-step project cuz is required by the dept. She offers lots of extra credit (you'll need it). Hard course = The best professor for the subject.

5.0
3.0
SOC240
Sep 13, 2006

class is hard in general, had it in the summer, strongly suggest taking this class in summer if you can. down to earth professor, knows that the subject is boring and helps to make it less boring, cuts class time in summer to get out early

5.0
5.0
JUST221
Sep 23, 2006

very very very hard class!!! lisa is a huge help! available 24/7 on email, easy to talk to, has candy in her office, very down to earth. if u want a good grade u really need to work hard but this is the prof to take! be on time for class and pay attention and u wont hear the smarta** comments

5.0
3.0
JUST199
Jan 9, 2007

She makes you work alot for just 1 credit and she grades hard at the start of the semester but if she see's that you are trying and putting in the effort your grades will improve alot

4.0
3.0
JUST221
Mar 25, 2007

Extremely hard class but she is such a good teacher!! The material is really hard to grasp but she always explains it in a way that makes it understandable. Completely down to earth, lets class out early, but expects work to be up to par. GREAT and really fast at responding back to your emails-always a plus!! TAKE HER!

5.0
1.0
JUST400
Apr 25, 2007

coolest teacher at montclair, very friendly with students and as long as your not a prick she will like you. def recommend her for any class she takes,some papers but as long as ur not an idiot u get an A...great professor

5.0
5.0
JUST318
Apr 27, 2007

very interesting class about justice and animals! wasn't all that interested in the course at first, but it got clear thru the semester ~ learned a ton of things that i wouldn't learn in another class!

5.0
5.0
JUST221
May 4, 2007

Lisa is the best professor ever!!! She makes this very difficult class much easier. She knows what she talks about, very clear. Besides that she is easy to talk to, helful and ALWAYS there for you if you need any help. if you have to take this class take her!

5.0
2.0
JUST321
May 16, 2008

At first I really did not like her, but she grew on me. By the end of the semester, I understood her and I actually enjoyed her. Follow the syllabus EXACTLY as it is written and do the required readings (I can't stress that enough) from the beginning of the semester (there are weekly quizzes based on the reading). Not a bad teacher, at all.

3.0
5.0
JUST321
May 22, 2008

I think that she gives way too much work for a 3 credit class.. And I felt that she favored certain ppl.

5.0
4.0
JUST221
May 27, 2008

She definitely has her favorites, but she is a very intelligent, humorous and open-minded professor. You must "work" to get a good grade, because class materials can be very new sometimes. The hardest part about this class was step 1 of the methodology project.

4.0
3.0
JUST221
Aug 1, 2008

Lisa's methodology class, not easy. At first disliked her though she was biggest pain in the behind but she grows on you. By the end of the semester hottest instructor ever, MUY CALIENTE! Very accomodating if you need help. Study chapter extra credit & handouts questions are on exams.

5.0
2.0
JUST318
Dec 16, 2008

Animals&Justice was a great class. There was a lot of work but it was definitely an experience. 2hr community service/wk (which can be used on resume), wkly reflections, 20 slide ppt & 5pg paper for the end along w/ the occasional wkly assignments/readings but it was material that was easy to reflect on esp. if you care at all about animals.

5.0
2.0
JUST499
Apr 7, 2009

She is wonderful! Not an easy class but once you get the hang of how she likes things, you can def get an A. Everything is worked out from a points system. She is very helpful and always available outside of class. You need to read! Otherwise you will lose out on In-class assignments

5.0
4.0
JUST300
Aug 5, 2009

Very "no-nonsense" professor, you must be prepared to work and hand things in on time! Otherwise, she is very helpful and easy to get in touch with if you need help. She is also probably the hottest professor at MSU!

5.0
3.0
JUST300
Aug 6, 2009

Great professor! Extremelly helpfull in-class and after! This course requires a lot of work, yet she is there to help. Possible 20pts extra credit!Plus exams are not hard.

3.0
4.0
JUST321
Jan 21, 2010

Professor is a good teacher but she gives a load of work and you need to study to get a good grade and she may be very anal about little mistakes on papers and so follow every direction. Your grade counts.

3.0
4.0
JUST300
Jul 18, 2010

She is a terrible teacher I dont know who is leaving all these comments about her being a great teacher?She doesnt explain herself She doesnt help people if they seek her out Her test are impossible. Avoid her!!!

5.0
5.0
JUST300
Jul 25, 2010

Class is very hard but prof is willing to help whenever you need it! Go to office hours, meet after class, if you ask her she will stay as long as you want. I have emailed her tons of times and she always gets right back to me with help. Test was hard but was a take home-if you cant pass a take home you should be taking the class again.

2.0
5.0
JUST300
Jul 27, 2010

This lady gives waaaay to much work for one class if you want to pull your hair out youll take this terrible professor who makes you rely on the textbook instead of teaching you stuff!This class will bog you down if your taking a full load.

5.0
2.0
JUST300
Aug 18, 2010

Had her for Criminology. Very easy and clear. She required students to show up to class for each lesson to take the quiz, but the quizzes were always 10 multiple choice open-book -so needless to say, it wasn't hard to get a good grade. The very few papers we had to write were fairly easy as well.

2.0
5.0
DRUGS300
Sep 22, 2010

AWFUL PROFESSOR!!!! SAVE YOURSELF!!!!!!!!! DO NOT TAKE HER!!! WROTE HER OWN BOOK!!! SHES A LAME!!!!!!!!!!

5.0
3.0
JUST300
Oct 5, 2010

Lisa is amazing and helpful. If you're ready to actually do work, think, and participate in class she is more than willing to help you with whatever you need. Not easy, but fair- and really funny. If you don't like her, you're probably an idiot who can't effectively use grammar, or their brain, in general.

4.0
4.0
JUST102
Dec 4, 2010

First of all, she's not hot. Second, she can be EXTREMELY rude in emails because shes not brave enough to say it in person. Her class is not that bad as long as you do the work and ON TIME! late assignments are unacceptable. But all in all good class to take and it can be fun.

5.0
2.0
JUST102
Dec 29, 2010

I loved this class online! If you follow directions and do all assignments you will have no problem. She responds to emails fast. Everything was great for me. I didn't need this class but took it and didn't regret a dime spent. She also is a great listener. Take her!!! (o: SC

5.0
5.0
ABC123
Jan 8, 2011

Took one of her classes 6 years ago and still talk about what I learned. A lot of work, but well worth it. Hopefully the book "Damned Lies and Statistics" is still a requirement - what an eye-opener. You may not realize now what a great professor she was, but you'll remember her for years to come. (don't remember class code or #)

4.0
5.0
JUST101
Jan 15, 2011

Crazy hard winter session class! Would not allow late assignments no matter what, and was a smart a$$ in emails when I needed an extension. Graded fair, great feedback on papers, overall awesome online course but alot of work!!!

2.0
4.0
JUST101
Jan 17, 2011

if you are already enrolled in this class get out fast shes the worst shes rude immature and doesnt know the material she teaches

5.0
4.0
JUST101
Apr 19, 2011

Really enjoyed the material & the way it was taught! Grades hard but fair! If you have questions just ask and she'll answer...I don't know what others are complaining about, she's WAY helpful and answers email right away if you have a last minute question!!!!

3.0
3.0
JUST400
Jun 6, 2011

She is very very very unclear on her assignments she gives you opinionated questions to answer when you answer them you get no credit she want you to copy from her book

5.0
5.0
JUST314
Dec 19, 2011

Class is very difficult. She wants you to read, and expects that you will do so. There are also 4 LARGE projects due throughout the semester, + other assignments + reading. No tests. Heavy workload, but she is a good professor. Lots of work, show up to every class, do every assignment. The ppl who did poorly never showed up, and didnt do the work

5.0
1.0
JUST314
Mar 27, 2012

It's the easiest class I've ever taken. Yes you have to read. Yes you have to put effort in. I actually learned something and I love taking her classes.

5.0
3.0
JUST314
Apr 30, 2012

One of the best and easiest professors I've ever taken. The effort put into the class is worth it, if you really want to learn something new a different. Course layout is clear, direct and not that difficult. You pretty much have to be an idiot or a bum or even both to fail this class. No exams and plenty of opportunity for extra credit.

5.0
3.0
JUST318
May 30, 2012

syllabus is clear and she gives ample time for assignments.Good amount of work but it is more to prove that you have done the reading. No exams just essay's and projects. I love her classes I think I actually learn something. She is also very willing to help and work with students as long as they are willing to put the work in. Take her!

2.0
3.0
JUST402
Nov 7, 2012

Avoid her if you can. Her class is not that bad but there is a lot of work. She is a very tough grader! She assigns work without even explaining how to do it. She assigns work and won'teven mention it in class, except to say that it is due. I have received my first C EVER from her. My English teachers didn't even grade papers as hard as she did.

5.0
3.0
JUST402
Dec 7, 2012

This was my fourth class with her & she is an amazing teacher. She requires a decent amount of course work but it is all laid out in the syllabus, which she goes over in the beginning of the semester. She gives good feedback and is knowledgeable about the subjects being taught. I've learned so much and have interests in other areas because of her

1.0
5.0
JUST400
May 8, 2013

Professor Zilney is an extremely tough teacher that wrote the textbook for the course. If you do not cite almost every line from homework, she will deduct a lot of points. Basically she wants to know that you are looking over every word in this book because she wrote it. Also had a lot of work assigned, would not recommend.

2.0
5.0
JUSTICE300
May 20, 2013

She is a very difficult professor. If you don't have time to visit her during office hours, do not take her. She is a very tough grader and picky. She not always clear about her directions. The class is boring and hard as it is and she does not make it anymore pleasant. She is not a bad person but avoid her for this class if you can.

2.0
5.0
JUST402
Nov 5, 2013

She is by far the worst professor I have ever taken and I am strongly considering dropping her course. She is EXTREMELY rude and her sarcasm is unappreciated. I take my school work very seriously and she's NOT helpful. She also gives ENTIRELY way too much work. As if her class is the only one you're taking. Stay away if possible.

5.0
5.0
JUST402
Nov 17, 2013

Really interesting class. Alot of work, but she teaches mostly 400 classes, so I expect more work than a 200 class. She really knows about sex offenders and this will teach you things you'll never learn anywhere else! Definitely take it!

4.0
4.0
JUST318
Mar 24, 2014

LOVE this class! Learned so much about animals I never knew about before! Great videos and lectures, interesting readings. Alot of work, but fair grader.

1.0
4.0
JUST318
Apr 7, 2014

She's terrible. She is very rude, immature, and does not care about her students. She is also very sarcastic. She can be nice, but it is very rare. It is not exactly a hard class but she is a tough grader. If you can avoid the class, do not take it, I know I regret taking it.

4.0
5.0
JUST101
Apr 8, 2014

interesting material. hard grader. i had a problem in the semester and went to talk to her and she was very helpful. is sarcastic but that seems to be her humor. i really like this class and learned alot.

2.0
5.0
JUST101
Grade: B
Apr 30, 2014

does not care about her students. She is also very sarcastic. REALLY HARD GRADER! gives way too much work too many essays and too many disscussions! i dont recommend this class

4.0
4.0
JUST300
May 8, 2014

Professor is great. There's a lot of work but, as long as you follow her directions from the syllabus and hand everything in on time the course isn't too bad. Tests are open book and done online. Also do the extra credit.

3.0
5.0
CRIIMI101
May 9, 2014

Does not really teach gives outrageous amount of assignments not helpful hard grader. Over all lost all interst in this class

2.0
4.0
JUST101
May 15, 2014

She isn't helpful at all. I took her course online and the first few weeks were confusing eventually she made a routine for posts and quizzes. Maybe she's nicer in person but she online she comes off a bit rude. She's a hard grader! I wouldn't recommend her if theres an easier professor teaching the course.

3.0
4.0
JUST400
Aug 21, 2014

Took her for a 3 week summer course and was easily the worst decision I've ever made. Assigns a ridiculous amount of work and holds such high expectations for it to all be perfect. Gives ridiculously harsh feedback on outlines basically degrading you. Does not understand that there is more to life than her course.

4.0
4.0
JUST400
Sep 2, 2014

This was a post session 3 week course. Alot of work. Definitely had to read the book and make that clear in the assignments. Grading was harder than in many classes in JUST. Gave alot of feedback on work. Liked the class overall and learned alot about drugs.

2.0
5.0
JUST101
Grade: C+
Oct 19, 2015

Do not ask this professor any questions. She seems bothered when her students email her regarding questions on assignments. She is a tough grader and will drop your grade if you incorrectly site sources. She is unhelpful in her instructions and will respond to your emails in a way that makes you feel helpless and inferior. She makes you feel stupid

4.0
3.0
JUS200
Dec 8, 2015

I definitely enjoyed her class! It's a fair amount of work.. she gives you 4 options for paper topics and requires you to do two of them, 4 pages minimum each, which is not bad! The due dates for the 2 papers are spread out throughout the semester! There's online quizzes based on the reading which helps your grade! No midterm, no final! Great prof!

4.0
3.0
JUST200
Grade: A-
Dec 8, 2015

Assigned two out of four options of 4 page papers, but first day of class gave notice of when they would be due. Attendance not mandatory, but show up, do the quizzes (really help grades) and submit the papers on time and you should be good. Good professor and planning on taking for another class

5.0
3.0
JUST101
Grade: A-
Dec 13, 2015

Lots of discussion boards and a couple of quizzes. No big tests. One paper that is two pages long and then you can revise it. You choose from four topics with different due dates. Then one three page paper about a sex offender. Extra credit assignment if you want. Interesting films over the semester, discussions are good, but quite a bit of work.

5.0
3.0
JUS200
Grade: A+
Dec 19, 2015

i loved her and this class. She tries to scare you away from saying how much work it is, but it wasnt hard at all. 2 four page papers, and weekly quizzes online but the answers are right in the textbook. no midterm or final. class isnt mandatory. this is an easy a if you just put effort in. would def take this class again, shes a great teacher

1.0
5.0
JUS200
Grade: Not sure yet
Nov 2, 2016
Wouldn't take again

DO NOT TAKE THIS CLASS I'm warning you if you want an A do not take her, she gives a quiz every week online its timed but you have to read more than 20 pages for one quiz , she's a very tough grader not very approachable, when you ask her a question she's very sarcastic not helpful at all the quiz, wish i had a different professor for this course

Tough Grader
SO MANY PAPERS
TEST HEAVY
3.0
3.0
JUST342
Nov 3, 2016
Would take again

This is the first class online ive taken with her. The class started in September and its now November and she hasnt graded one single thing, and we have had things do every single week since the school l year has started. i have no idea what my grade is. in person she isnt bad, but probably wouldnt take another online with her

ACCESSIBLE OUTSIDE CLASS
GRADED BY FEW THINGS
5.0
3.0
JUST200
Grade: Not sure yet
Nov 14, 2016
Would take again

Overall great professor, quiz every week online through canvas its hard to fail if the book is in front of you (easy quizzes), 2 essays and she gives extra credit. No midterm , no final. She doesn't lecture heavy she loves to hear our thoughts on subjects as well. I recommend her.

Tough Grader
Respected
Get ready to read
3.0
4.0
JUST200
Nov 17, 2016
Wouldn't take again

Don't be afraid! If this class is the only one available you could do it! Make sure that you READ! There is a quiz every week, (pay attention to the stats. in textb, and mini details for quizzes) (11 total). Participate in class, do the extra credit (2)! You will learn alot, but you definitely work for your grade! Don't be discouraged!

Tough Grader
Gives good feedback
Get ready to read
5.0
4.0
JUS200
Grade: A
Nov 30, 2016
Would take again

Professor Zilney is wonderful! I would 100% take another class she teaches in a heartbeat. She engages in active discussion with the class. There are quizzes every week, but they are online. The material is super interesting. She truly is passionate about Justice in our society. There is also extra credit available a few times over the semester.

Clear grading criteria
Amazing lectures
EXTRA CREDIT
4.0
3.0
JUST205
Grade: Not sure yet
Dec 4, 2017
Wouldn't take again

no midterm or final - but 2 major research papers - its not that bad but you definitely have to pay attention in class, she helps & tells you exactly what to write in class for the paper - DO NOT PROCRASTINATE the paper

Tough Grader
Gives good feedback
Get ready to read
1.0
4.0
JUST300
Grade: F
Mar 28, 2018
Wouldn't take again

1) cruel grader, unforgiving with criteria guidelines. Missing an assignment or two will lead to an F. She will tell you to withdraw. 2) requires way too much work and reading for all major assignments, be prepared to pretend you're a grad student 3) recycles old material, uninteresting lectures, requires text but never uses in class 4) 2/5 ��

Tough Grader
Get ready to read
SO MANY PAPERS
1.0
3.0
JUST101
Grade: B-
May 8, 2018
Wouldn't take again

I took her online and we just finished our final paper and she is very demeaning and belittling. Shes a hard grader. She was very disrespectful in her comments on the paper. The discussions were fine and so were the quizzes. She just is very rude and beligerant at points. I don't plan on taking her again.

Tough Grader
Get ready to read
LOTS OF HOMEWORK
1.0
5.0
JUST342
Grade: B-
Jul 12, 2018
Wouldn't take again

I took this professor online for an elective, thinking the class would be interesting. She completely ruined the subject for myself. She is one of the worst professors I have ever dealt with. She is a harsh grader and a citation maniac. If your citations are not correct you will lose a lot of points. I would suggest finding another professor.

Tough Grader
Participation matters
LOTS OF HOMEWORK
4.0
4.0
JUST342
Grade: B+
Sep 13, 2018
Would take again

Wildlife trafficking class. Interesting material. Discussion boards and power point assignment. She is ridiculous about citations. Make sure you cite and you will get a good grade! Not too many assignments, extra credit. Available during office hours and for help if you need it.

Tough Grader
Get ready to read
Clear grading criteria
4.0
5.0
JUST300
Grade: A
Sep 13, 2018
Would take again

Crazy hard class. Don't miss class or you won't pass. Cite papers or you'll lose a ton of points. Helpful teacher if you ask during office hours. Can be sarcastic. I've had her for four classes once you know what she wants its pretty simple.

Tough Grader
Skip class? You won't pass.
Clear grading criteria
1.0
5.0
JUST300
Apr 25, 2019
Wouldn't take again

Extremely tough grader, do not take her class.

Tough grader
2.0
3.0
JUST342
Grade: C-
May 8, 2019
Wouldn't take again

This was an online class that the professor took way too serious. She marked my paper down from 20 points to 16.4 because i was ONE sentence shy of a 2 page paper that is due almost every week for the semester. The work load is a lot. Although I did find the books interesting, I began to skim through them because of how many assignments were due.

Lots of homework
Get ready to read
Tough grader
5.0
4.0
JUST318
Grade: A
Jul 9, 2019
Would take again

Really interesting class on animals. Not a ton of work. She is particular about citations, so be careful. I loved this class though! Mostly discussion boards, and a book essay on a great novel. Learned a lot!

Gives good feedback
Get ready to read
Clear grading criteria
4.0
3.0
JUST342
Grade: A
Jul 9, 2019
Would take again

Not as interesting as the animal class, but still good. Not a lot of work, but you have to read and you will get deductions for not citing, ugh! Short papers, discussion boards, and a PowerPoint of whatever you want. Pretty easy elective and the topics are good. Easy to reach if you need help.

Gives good feedback
Get ready to read
Participation matters
1.0
4.0
ABC123
Sep 11, 2019
Wouldn't take again

Honestly the worst professor at MSU. DO NOT TAKE. If I could giver a 0, I would.

1.0
4.0
JUST101
Apr 29, 2020
Wouldn't take again

Absolutely do not take. One of those professors that makes it clear they don't care about their students, especially now during a pandemic. Extremely tough grader and is rude while giving feedback or sending out announcements.

Test heavy
Tough grader
5.0
4.0
JUST318
Grade: A
Jan 27, 2022
Would take again

So much interesting material in this class! Really made me think about issues I had never thought about before regarding animals! You need to read and complete all assignments, but grading is fair. Make sure to use citations!

Accessible outside class
Inspirational
Tough grader
5.0
4.0
JUST402
Grade: A
Jan 27, 2022
Would take again

Very interesting class that focused on laws for sex offenders. Interesting discussions about how laws impact family members. Good relation to other JUST courses.

Respected
Accessible outside class
3.0
2.0
JUST102
Grade: A+
May 9, 2022
Would take again

Took this class because I had an extra slot in my schedule. I do not regret it! Professor Zilney's criteria was straightforward and her feedback on every quiz was helpful. You have to be self-reliant, as with any online class, but I would recommend this course to anyone with an interest in criminal justice.

Clear grading criteria
Gives good feedback
Graded by few things
5.0
4.0
JUST300
Grade: A
Jan 16, 2024
Would take again

Very good professor that always gets the lecture across. She is quick and concise with her points and she wastes no time explaining what are on the slides. You will always leave early and attendance is not mandatory. She can be a tough professor but she is fair and the assignments are not that bad for a mandatory course.

Amazing lectures
Caring
Respected
5.0
3.0
Just230
Grade: A
May 1, 2024
Would take again

Great professor

Get ready to read
Inspirational
Graded by few things
4.0
4.0
JUST300
Grade: B
Jan 5, 2025
Would take again

Tough grader, but lectures are clear. Use Unstuck ai and stay on top of assignments to do well. Not the most engaging, but fair if you put in the work.

3.0
4.0
JUST402
Grade: B-
Jan 20, 2025

Professor Zilney does communicate on the syllabus on what she expects. There are four discussion posts and quizzes throughout the semester. She also provides the opportunity for extra credit. There was a lot of reading excepted but it wasn't a surprise since it's a level 400 course. Just make sure you make time to read and take notes from the text

Get ready to read
EXTRA CREDIT
Clear grading criteria
5.0
3.0
JST300
Grade: B+
Apr 3, 2025
Would take again

I took two classes with her and going to take another one next semester. She's great. She gives a lot of easy quizzes/homeworks, she gives 3 day period grace for every assignment and quiz. She reviews your homework if you send it to her 48hrs before is due, so it's an easy A.

Clear grading criteria
Caring
Lecture heavy
5.0
3.0
JUST402
Grade: A+
Nov 6, 2025
Would take again

I loveeeeeee Professor Zilney. Her classes are heavy reading, but I enjoy the readings, and she cares about her students. If you do the work it is an easy A.

Tough grader
EXTRA CREDIT
Lots of homework
Class Info

Online Classes

100%

Attendance Mandatory

29%

Textbook Required

0%

Grade Predictor

Your expected effort level

LowHigh

Predicted Grade

B+

95% confidence
Based on 24 grades
Most common grades:
A (8)
B (3)
A+ (3)
Grade Distribution
A(11)B(6)C(2)D(0)F(1)A-/B+(4)
Based on 27 reported grades
A: 8
B: 3
A+: 3
Not sure yet: 3
Common Tags
Get ready to read (11)
Tough Grader (9)
Clear grading criteria (7)
Gives good feedback (5)
Tough grader (5)
Respected (3)
EXTRA CREDIT (3)
SO MANY PAPERS (2)
Rating Trend

Declining

-0.65 avg change
May
Jan
May
Jan
Apr
Nov
Last 6 months
Ratings by Course

221

5.0

(1)

SOC301

5.0

(1)

SOCI101

5.0

(1)

JUSTICE

5.0

(1)

ENVIROJUSTICE

5.0

(1)
+31 more courses
Difficulty by Course

SOCI30103

5.0

JUVENILEJUSTIC

5.0

JUST202

5.0

DRUGS300

5.0

JUSTICE300

5.0

Similar Professors