Nice Smart Guy, too tough for a 100 level UP course.

Shelton is an awesome proffessor. He keeps the students attention, and keeps them involved, but the involvement is by choice of the student, so there is no risk of embarrasment. His class is one of the most fun classes I have had. yet you still learn a lo

Great Class

Loved the class, Learned a ton, energetic and funny prof. May be kind of difficult to understand, but if you do the reading and listen in class you actually learn a lot. Prof. even answered questions I had over email. Prob not for everyone though

Has a degree from Harvard and it shows. You'll need a profound vocabulary to even stay afloat in here. Not for the less than well-read. Often confuses himself rambling.

The best thing about Shelton is that he expects you to actually do college level work. Philosophy is complex thinking and should take some effort to understand. You shouldn't fault the guy for college-level teaching because you didn't work hard enough.

a true genuis , a brilliant great man and wonderful prof

He is a little hard to understand at times, he makes you think and want to do well in his class, very energetic and will always remember your name, likes to pace back and forth, but overally not a bad teacher

He helps the readings all come together in lecture and is very helpful if you are willing to take the time.

He is probably one of the nicest teachers I have ever had. The class is tough, that's given..it's Philosophy. So, if you don't want a hard class, don't sign up for it - it has nothing to do with his teaching. He is SO NICE.

Very nice guy but needs to learn more about how to teach. He doesn't explicate the philosophical arguments well enough. If you're not a philosophy major or minor, avoid. If you are, take him with a higher level course.

I honestly enjoyed this class and even if you don't show up for his entertaining lectures...you can still understand the information because whether it seems like it or not, he teaches straight from the book.

great overall prof, and he isnt that hard I got a B and wasnt there half the time

Great teacher... Very enthusiastic about his subject and he memorizes your name, so he recognizes your face. He has real teacher quality even though he is a little hard to understand sometimes. Great Job Shelton!!

Dr. Shelton is a great guy and knows a lot about 19th cent. philosophy. This class is very difficult, but you will KNOW the material when he is done with you. If you are a PHL major take this class and work hard. It is well worth the effort.

I realy enjoy his lectures a lot. The book material is difficult, but he breaks it down well. He does expect a lot of his students, so this isn't an easy A. But it's worth the effort.

This class is really hard. He's a really nice guy, but he expects way too much out of you.

Expects A LOT...but he explains things fairly well I think...he's very energetic for the class being in the morning...:S

Very high energy and quirky. Willing to work with students, and I suggest taking advantage of it. The tests and papers are do-able if you go to class. Be prepared to work for your A.

Crazy man, way too excited so early in the morning. But he presented his information well. He knew what he was teaching and liked it. It was a fun class to go to, even if he was was too strung out.

He graduated from Harvard and it shows. He questions everything, so don't even try to talk him in a circle when arguing about something you got wrong. Isn't very clear on what he expects, but ironically his expectations are extremely high.

Okay he is a very nice man willing to help and essays fyi are not hard. i got an A on everyone so dont say the class is impossible you didnt try hard enough. his words are not that big either words every college person should know. EX Rhobust come on people just cause you did bad doesnt mean the teacher sucks.

Very good guy, hes nice and willing to help. The material for the class, however is another story...

Pretty okay

He is really nice as a person but he only grades on exams and the material is really hard! He's a bit of a tough grader. His personality is a little "out there" and he bounces around the room. I like him though, he's a cool guy.

The guy is from Harvard....he remembered everyones first and last names after the first class and never forgot a single one. Everyone complains about this class, but just read a little each day and throw in some sparknotes along with the books he gives and you'll get an A..really interesting class though..most enthusastic prof I've ever had.

He's gives interesting lectures and is VERY enthusiastic about what he teaches. The grading scale is a little funky and the class might be a little harder than it should be. He's crazy but it makes it fun.

He's a really nice guy and is very enthusiastic about the subject matter. He's extremely intelligent and knows his stuff - the only problem is that he doesn't treat the class like an intro course. If you have no interest in philosophy and are just looking to pick up a UP, I'd advise you not to take this class.

I took this as just an elective class. And not going to lie sometimes the subjects went over my head, but he could tell when you were lost and worked to help you out. His test were hard but like he said instead of a bunch of bull**** ?'s he'd rather have more hard ?'s to get you thinking and then grade more curved. It's challenging but fair!

For a UP this class is hard! Mark is a great teacher but he intentionally makes his exams super hard. He also does this weird curving. Once your done with this class you will know your stuff. If your like phillosphy take him if you just want the UP or do the business requirement take another teacher. Overall good teacher hard class

My Favorite teacher of ALL TIME! i have about a 3.5 gpa and i took this as an elective class and it was probaley the hardest class i have taken to this point.However This class is awesome and Shelton is so enthusiatic about the subject. Shelton got his Doctorate from Harvard. He is a genious and wants to make you one too!you wont regret taking it!

Great Professor if you are into philosophy. He knows his stuff and if you want want to actually learn something or engage in an intelligent conversation than he is the professor to take. Don't let his Harvard credentials scare you, he is very approachable and not at all full of himself.

Shelton does in fact teach a hard course, but all the comments about him being a prick and not caring about his students are completely irrational. I loved the class and enjoyed going to it. I'd definitely suggest taking this course.

He is a nice guy and very helpful. However his exams are really hard. Even if you study for hours you will be luck to get a B. And the final is worth either 40% or 50% of your final grade depending on what test you are doing. If you are stuck with him, read your book before class, go to every class, and participate. And try taking it with a friend.

Really smart teacher. It's the kind of class that you remember and apply often. Difficult but it wouldn't work any other way.

Very interesting class if you like engaging in or even just listening to intelligent conversation. Participation is key and is good practice making sure that you are actually grasping the concepts he tries to convey. This is a class that really makes you think and are likely to remember.

He's by far the most difficult professor I've had yet at CMU. He learned the names of everyone on the first day. He's a genius, and went to Harvard. It's a tough class but if you go to class, take good notes, and write your essay based on what he says you should get at least a B. The first topic you learn is the hardest, but it gets better(:

Shelton is very hard to get an A from. There were 3 papers totaling 35 pages. However, Shelton will help out in any way he can. Overall the class was great but hard.

The reviews of this guy are very indicative of the attitude and intelligence of the average CMU student. He is a very smart professor, and he knows what he is teaching. If you enjoy being in the company of an intellectual, and having intelligent conversation, take Shelton. This class wasn't that hard. CMU needs to stop letting these kids in...

Dr. Shelton's class was challenging in the sense that it required you to challenge yourself.Class discussions forced you to think about real life issues and seriously question yourself about what is moral/fair/right and WHY.Intellectual conversation with open and honest thought was encouraged.I continue to say,"my favorite class at CMU" 4 yrs later

This course is abstract thinking, it broadens a person's perspective on many issues(if you allow yourself). Shelton is very knowledgable on the topic. Sometimes he speaks bit fast his lectures, it may be difficult to understand given that he is very articulate; a recording device would be very helpful in his class. I recommend Shelton.

Professor Shelton is brilliant. I've remarked several times at how I can follow his line of thought much like an outline. If you open your mind to the readings and class lectures, you will be impressed by how much you learn. Read, participate, and listen; you won't regret it. Also, listening to him talk will improve your vocabulary immensely!

I left this class confused every day. It was probably because I have no interest in philosophy but he talked in circles and I wasn't sure of the points he was trying to get across. 6 exams total and 3 of them are essay exams. I got the same grade when I studied as when I didn't study. Customizes mandatory textbook so its expensive.

Dr. Shelton makes you work for your grade, but if you do the readings before class and participate, you will get a good grade. He's very passionate about the topic and really makes you think about tough issues. He's always available to help anyone in need. It's nice to have a teacher who cares.

The class consisted mainly of lectures during which students are expected to participate. Be sure to read the material in order to participate and get points. The grading scale is strange. Although it appears at first that the class will be easy, the tests are difficult and he is a tough graders on essays. The class challenges you but is worth it.

I personally loved this class. I'm not even a philosophy person, but you talk about topics that are very interesting and relevant. He is a very quirky, funny teacher. He is incredibly smart which means he expects you to keep up, but if you ask for help outside of class he's awesome. I did well in his class because I tried! Lectures can be entertain

The classes are long and boring if you aren't interested but you defineey need to go and take notes on the lectures or you won't pass the class. He's was very helpful and understanding. He was one of the only professors that was willing to help so that you pass the class. We use 5-6 books but they're cheap.

Dr. Shelton is one of the most clear & consistent lecturers I have ever taken a class with. He takes the material seriously, carefully dissecting as much as possible in a short 50 minute period. You will be challenged, no doubt. You must read, you must think, and you must *try* in order to successfully complete this class. You won't regret it.

Makes you really think about the subjects. Cares about the students. Really entertaining to watch him teach.

He is a very quirky and smart guy, and if you can follow, his lectures will be interesting and the logic of it all will make perfect sense. He cares about his students and challenges your beliefs. This is my first semester as a freshman and I have an A- with minimal effort. Do the readings beforehand and pay attention and you will do fine.

Loved this class! I would Recommend it.

A very dedicated and caring professor. He makes great analogies and explains things in very understandable terms. Prepare to get deep on subjects. Read weekly, it's not overbearing material. If you work hard you should be able to get a B- or higher. Definitely grew from the class, interesting all around.

He's very enthusiastic about what he teaches. He's wicked smart and moral problems is already a rough class so it might be hard for you to follow. It wasn't necessarily easy but it wasn't hard either. If you're struggling, ask questions because it will only get harder if you don't. Do the reading. Just do the reading he assigns.

He's awesome, it's one thing to go to class and it's another to go and learn something. If you're true goal is to learn something and you're not solely focused on getting an A every time. You will love it, please take this class. We need more people who know stuff in the world!

This guy is a great person and really cares about his students. If you don't understand something, go and see him at his office hours. I will admit he is a tough grader and says it is hard to get an A in his class. Put in the work, start caring about what you're learning and it's absolutely possible!

Mr. Shelton is a fantastic professor. He's funny, smart, and clearly enthusiastic about the subject. The way he grades is different, but overall great. He makes it so that the exams are hard, but grades in a way that even if you get only half right you pass the exam. Read, show up, and you'll pass.

Dr. Shelton was a very passionate professor. He would really get into his lectures, and you can tell he is passionate about the subject. If you take PHL100, I would 100% suggest him. The work isn't plentiful, one 500-600 word assignment every other week with only every other one graded, your choice. Easy A if you follow the requirements listed well

He is kind and very easy to talk to. Lectures are like mini-seminars, although he talks more than the students do. Often he is more interested in what you are thinking about the material rather than if you have the "correct" answer. There are 8 small question/response papers every 2-3 weeks, 600 word min. Very unique class and professor.

Loved the Prof. but way to smart for an intro class to understand. Get ready to read and not understand lectures! Any papers assigned and are difficult to understand his questions. I have never missed a class but struggle and literally don't get what we talk about. He is funny but again a really tough intro class!

If you are not gifted and brilliant, skip this class.

Dr. Shelton is one of the brightest professors I have had the pleasure of working with. He sets the bar high for all of his students. His lectures are some of the highlights of the semester as he is funny and passionate about the topics he teaches. He can be a little harsh in emails, but he does care about his students and gives the tools to pass.

Professor Shelton is a tough grader, but lets you pick and choose which assignments to be for credit and which to be for completion. Fantastic lectures, but has high expectations for a 100 level class. Overall a fantastic professor that makes you think.