3.8
Quality2.7
Difficulty80%
Would Retake108
Reviews80%
Would Retake
108
Reviews
Rating DistributionOfficial
5
53
4
21
3
13
2
14
1
7
What Students Say
“Very opinionated and selects who she wants to excel”
AMD141 - 3.0 rating“The worst teacher I have had at CMU”
AMD252 - 1.0 ratingClass Info
Online Classes
100%
Attendance Mandatory
38%
Textbook Required
71%
Grade Predictor
Your expected effort level
Predicted Grade
A-
Grade Distribution
Common Tags
Rating Trend
Stable
+0.02 avg changeRatings by Course
HEV141155252
5.0
(1)HEV256447
5.0
(1)AMD141
4.8
(9)HEV141252
4.7
(3)FMD141
4.4
(5)Difficulty by Course
EVERYONE
5.0
AWFUL
4.0
HEV256447
4.0
AMD547
3.8
AMD252
3.5
Reviews (108)
No Comments
Very good teacher, helpful
This class was so easy that I only showed up on days that something was due and still managed to ace every test. Must read book, gives notes online.
Go to class, take notes, you wont have to read the book, her assignments are easy. I really enjoyed her class and never dreaded going. She's very nice and a great teacher. Easy A for sure.
fun class....easy assignments
She is awesome!!!!
good teacher.. she tries to stay young and in style. her tests are ok.. need to study for them
fun projects but she can be ****y when you talk to her out of class :(
She's not helpful and ****y when you see her during office hours!
Easy class, but tests are hard if you don't study. Study the notes; DON'T READ THE BOOK!
she always has interesting material, we are always learning something new and she is a fun teacher to have in class.
Dont bother even buying the book.I didnt and still got an A in the class. Notes on blackboard and powerpoint in class. Fun in class, but dresses like a ****. Lose the fishnet hose!
Applies lessons to real situations in life.
My favorite class and prof! She is very nice! Have fun with the class.
Don't buy the book, just waste of money. Tests off of notes. Okay, but kind of bitc#y. Dresses like a hooch. Not nice out of class, went to her office and she only spent 1 minute with me.
during class she seems nice.outside of class she's rude. She said that i had the wrong styles on my project, and they came from a fashion magazine that already had labels, so be careful on projects. I did well on tests but got a D i should change majors:(
These people are SO jealous- just cause Ms. M looks hotter than them even though she's 20 years older! grow up, there's always somebodier sexier and that's life- learn from the woman, she knows her stuff-
Cute teacher, makes class fun. I haven't noticed that she is ****y out side of class though....
I had this class and it was not only a ton of fun, but the prof is awesome!!!! Anybody that left negative feedback on here is obviously stupid and just jealous because she didn't give them a good grade. GET A LIFE PEOPLE
she is also the advisor for apparel merchandising and design...she sucks...she ****ed up my schedule 2 times and now i have to go an extra semester and have 6 hard courses in one semester...oh yeah and as a teacher she is extremely dumb...airheaded...
Dont hate on Mac G. because you didnt follow the directions. she is the hottest prof in the AMD program. She is so smart in the apparel field and stays up to date on industry news. Best teacher in the department by far.
She knows what she is talking about but doesnt always make it very interesting. Tests take a lot of studying because she expects you to know the notes and book inside and out. It was an OK class.
No Comments
Very nice teacher. Very helpful. Class is a little boring.. but it's an easy A class if you put a little effort into it! She is great!
Really bad teacher. disorganized and unhelpful, thinks she's better than all the students.
I don't know what you all are talking about. Ms McG is great! She is so nice and the classes are easy! I already took 2 classes w/ her and got As! the tests aren't very hard as long as you study. she takes it right off the study guides too!
nice and cheerful...lectures can be boring, but knows what she is talking about. passionate about apparel industry. also grades easily, tests are not too hard
She is so nice! Her lectures are fun and humorous. Awesome lady! Very interesting comments.
I agree! A total wench! She designed the course so she thinks she can make up the rules as she goes along. Boring, repetitive and based on stupidity! Even for fashion majors. And in my opinion any of the positive comments she posted herself!
I think she's a GREAT teacher. Her class is structured, her notes are clear, and she tells you exactly what is expected of you. She's always on top of her game. Take the class if you like organization and you're willing to work for your grade. I'm a HUGE fan, I'd take her again.
Awesome professor! She is always willing to help you when you need help. Her exams are easy as long as you study. Papers are very easy...the lowest grade I've have got from her on a paper is a 95%! make sure to take her
I have had her in previous classes and i really liked her but for this one she comes off like she is better then everyone else and her lectures are hard to follow because of the wording that she uses and her exams can be difficult! take her ONLY if you don't have a heavy class load!
In class she comes across as the greatest woman ever then on a one to one basis she is very evil. Do not email her or go to her office hours because she feels it to be an inconvience. Her projects are easy but her exams are kinda hard. Not a great prof. and I wouldnt take her unless you had to.
No Comments
Apparently, this professor didn't get the job that she really wanted. She berates students while bragging about herself, her comments on papers are not intended to help you but vague. If you bother her during her office hours, you will not make that mistake again.
No Comments
I've heard in her other classes she's horrid, but in 252 she's really nice and non evil.
wat r u guys talkin about?! maureen is great and the best teacher ever!
Wow- you must not have paid attention. This is college, people, and you are going into a competitive profession. If your performance and commitment to detail sucks, CHANGE MAJORS. If you think it is hard to explain to your parents that you failed, try telling that to an employer.
I don't know what you guys are talking about. She's been the best teacher I've had here! She's very willing to help others and is always cheerful. her lectures can be boring but what she says is importatnt to design. She's awesome! Take Her!!!
She is willing to help you if your are willing to ask for help
This teacher obviously didnt get the job she wanted, she is rude and talks very fast and will not help you if you ask her. Her lectures are very boring and all her information is about ten years behind the times.
No Comments
Awesome Prof.!!!!!!! Her exams are very easy if you follow the sudy guide she gives and scan through the notes. All multiple choice examzz, which r really easy. If you want an "A" take any of her class.
Maureen is a rotten teacher, she mumbles incoherently during class and is dangerously hostile and rude if you make the mistake of stopping by her office. Makes unprofessional faces in class. Her teaching is very behind the times and she does not seem very bright. She is the reason I transferred to State!!!
Maureen seems nice on the surface, and is, if you are one of her favorites. She can be unclear and will mark yo down for things she never told you to do. I had a hard time with that. I don't like feeling like I have to suck up to a teacher to get her to like me :(
Dr. MacGillivray is a caring and excellent professor. Highly recommended!
Maureen is one of the best teacher IO have ever met but it would be nicer and she would have made me enjoy her class better if only she is well organized. Pls maureen try to arrang your web notes in good order only the "INNOVATION AND DIFFUSSION seems to be well organized.
Are we talking about the same person here? Dr. MacG is fantastic - she is energetic and interesting and has a genuine interest in students. Her Dress and Culture class is the most interesting UP course I have taken. What is the deal with the comments?
This is one of the best professors at CMU. Always interested in students and willing to make things clear.
I have no problem with this teacher! This is the second class I've had with her and I've never seen her as anything besides enthusiastic and super nice. Her project directions are a bit ambiguous; so make sure you ask questions. I admit some of the material in this class is boring. I think it should be taught in the first Apparel Merchand. class.
Not what I thought this class was going to be like. I didn't learn anything useful and Maureen really irritated me. The group project was a complete waste of time and absolutely ridiculous and lowered my grade cuz my group sucked. Prof trys to be 21 again and she should act her age and grow up! A really pointless class that I was disappointed with
This was a really good class. The group projects weren't so bad... if you had good members! I'm looking forward to another course with Dr.M next Fall!
I have mixed feelings about her. She definitley acts like she's something, but when you talk to her, she's nice. Although I had a situation where she did not stick to her word at the end of the semester and I got a lower grade than what I should have. She's not very understanding!
Omg, I miss this professor. She was full of energy and enthusiasm; extremely knowledgeable about industry; integrated real world design methods into her courses; integral to creation of Threads, growth of FAMD; I'm out now...and boy do I appreciate what I learned from her. Just wait you guys!
This teacher is awesome!! She is nice, helpful, and tries to get everyone involved. I can't wait for her to be back inthe fall.
The best possible teacher in the Dept.!
Simply the best! (who is this person leaving such stupid comments?)
I had her for 252 & 141, and she doesn't put up with anyone's crap, but her teaching is clear. IF you go to class, you'll be fine. For your projects, check in with her often to make sure what you're turning in is up to her standards. GOOD Prof, though :)
She is a very nice teacher and is very stylish.
Most professional and knowledgeable prof I've had in two years at CMU
I have absolutly no interest in Dress and Culture so the class naturally- sucked. But she's a good teacher, helpful with students with disabilities, notes are online, gives you a break if you miss an exam and pretty friendly. If you like this kind of thing, take it, it won't kill ya.
professor macgillivray makes the class very easy to get an A in. the tests are not hard and she puts all her notes on blackboard, so it helps to come to class but you could probably do ok not going everyday. the last group project is really repetitive and boring and you spend about 3 weeks doing nothing but that. all in all she is a good teacher.
Love this teacher! I wish she taught all the HEV classes. This class isn't extremely har but it's easy to fall behind and you must turn in all your work to receive a passing grade. Extremely stylish and classy professor!
Absolutely great! Passionate about her field. I love this class!
She is extremely passionate about her field. She is extremely enthusiastic about coming to class everyday and presenting her material to you. She wants you to succeed. The class is very interesting - not just for AMD majors.
interesting class, but big group project... we had a ton of fun with ours though! all the notes are on Bb so that's easy and she gives you study guides, but i still didn't do great on the exams
She is amazing. She cares a lot about the success of her students.
Positives: very upbeat for the most part and does try to make the class interesting. Negatives seem to outweigh positives. She only seems to have a very basic understanding of material but that's where it stops. No deep knowledge. I found her condescending and insulting at times. FYI I got an A so this isn't out of spite for getting a bad grade
I had some doubts going into this class (based on comments) but it was really good.
OMG! Don't not take this lady. Where do I start, the material she gave is useless nothing ever worked and if you asked her she didn't answer you. UNORGANIZED!!! but she thinks she is I hated this class, worse class I ever took at CMU. Didn't learn a thing. What a waste of money!
I loved the class - learned a ton. Took the online version - am looking forward to a face-to-face class with dr. MacG.
Great Prof; first online course I have ever actually learned anything in; all her lectures were narrated; course notes; video reminders; weekly discussion forums; didn't like the quizzes; got a B
For a UP course, this class was good. Prof stuck to the outline, was organized, provided coures notes, interesting lectures - especially on Postmodernism and fashion. Really liked the class.
Not a fan of functional. Learned to use some cool tools like the digital camera for heat design. We could either shine or fail; final projects demonstrated who did what!
It would be helpful if the instructor would not contradict herself. Said that she has to dummy things down for her students however, this professor has her PHD and cannot scroll a mouse. Only cares about herself and not her students.
I liked her and her quirky sense of humor and how she put everything out there for students to either take advantage or ignore. Would be better if class was smaller.
This class was very intersting, she was engaging and made you get involved. There was a group project that went on for three weeks, that I hated, but other than that its a good class. She is fair, and presents the material in a clear and concise manner.
She's "ok"
I loved this class. It was interesting and she used a lot of pictures in her powerpoint, so it made lecture a lot less boring. However, her exams are impossible to study for. She said if we did the assignments we would do good on the exam. She lied. It's hard. It's all matching, but it's matching info, not definitions. Fun class, but GPA killer.
Never really knows what she's talking about, messes up on grades when it's too late to fix them
Great class; got to put on a major fashion production and learn all elements of its design. Prof guided the class but let the students take the lead.
She was a horrible teacher. She always thought she and only she was right. She was very misleading and confusing and what she said did not correspond with the assignment instruction sheets. She was rude when I would go up and ask about a grade received on a project. She made easy concepts very wordy and difficult. I would not recommend this class.
Her notes are not helpful at all, and they don't even have that much information on them, but then she gets angry when we wanted her to stop on a powerpoint slide. There is no order and organization in her lectures. Overall nice lady but I would not suggest this class to anyone.
She makes everything 100 times more complicated and wordy than it needs to be. Don't bother even studying for exams because even if you know everything the way she words things will make you fail. was excited about the class but the way she taught, graded, and made exams made me literally hate it.
Very interesting class. I don't agree with the negative comments. She clearly knows her stuff and has high expectations for the students in her class. I actually studied so I did not have a problem with the exams.
I would highly recommend taking Maureen’s class! There are two time consuming projects but otherwise the class is very educational.
Funny, fashionable, fresh; really enjoyed her class.
great teacher, well prepared and enthusiastic. notes on blackboard, exam reviews, decent lectures
Awesome class; can't wait to continue with this major.
Tough course but projects added a lot to my design portfolio
Loved this class! She kept things fun and entertaining. Don't wait until the last minute to start your projects and you should receive an A. She will also look at projects before you turn them in and tell you if your on the right track. Attend class and get extra credit to boost your grade.
Dr. MacGillivray knows her stuff. She is very helpful to new students. She is fun, too.
love, love, love this class and this prof
She was not very helpful and I would NOT recommend this class unless you absolutely need it! There were questions on her quizzes that were not apart of the lessons or they were asked in such a way that you were confused. The class could be fun and educational. But, she takes the fun out of it and makes it harder than necessary. Best of luck.
Really not to hard of a class, if you screen shot the power points and then look at them while taking the quizzes you'll be fine. The final project wasn't to bad, a little tedious though. Overall not to bad and worth taking online for the U.P.
If you want to go into design - take this class. If you want real world advice, take this class. If you are just looking to graduate without being serious, think again. You won't make it unless you are totally committed to this course!
Super unhelpful to any student. She is very rude when she emails you and doesn't care about you or passing the class. I don't recommend. The worst teacher I have had at CMU. Don't take this class or anything she teaches.
I averaged an 87.23% and received a "B". I emailed professor and told her that I was never late on any assignment and that I expected a "B+". She told me that "your grade is a B and will remain a B, happy holidays". Rude, not willing to budge on the grade. I earned a B+ not B. Course material is interesting. Worse professor at CMU.
As other students have said her email responses are very immature and rude! Very opinionated and selects who she wants to excel. No desire to help if you are not in that selection of students. She takes it upon herself to determine who she sees fit for this major.
Make sure you are serious about fashion before taking this class. The only exams are weekly quizzes online with one final exam at the end of the semester which are all pretty easy and you can take twice. I would recommend this professor because she was in the fashion industry and knows what she is talking about.
I loved her class. She gives weekly quizzes, but they are all online and correspond with her powerpoints in class which she also posts online. A few projects along the way as well and lots of in-class group work. Very fun class overall.
Her quizzes weren't too bad, they were straight forward if you payed attention to her lectures. Her lectures are pretty long but they are also helpful. Her lab is super easy and can be really fun some days.
I LOVE, love, love Dr. MacGillivray. Other kids in my class aren't as fond and I can't see why. The labs are fun and help set in the info from the lecture, and the quizzes are online and give you enough time to use materials. She will help you figure out classes and will help if you have problems with other teachers. I highly recommend!
She was a very good professor. She gave you lots of information about the major and you can feel her passion for fashion.
Taking this online was a breeze. Obviously, there was lots of reading, but she was straight forward with everything that she was expecting. I took this as an 8 week course and it was worth it, while trying to get that last writing intensive requirement out of the way!
Professor MacGillivray could be kind of ditzy at times. She didn't really understand how to work technology and her lectures were boring and sometimes confusing. If you miss class, her powerpoints are not very helpful on learning the material, and there were no textbooks but online material that took hours upon hours to read.
Macgillivray is great. Her lectures are dry, but the class is pretty easy. You just have to do the work with effort and youll pass!
Class Info
Online Classes
100%
Attendance Mandatory
38%
Textbook Required
71%
Grade Predictor
Your expected effort level
Predicted Grade
A-
Grade Distribution
Common Tags
Rating Trend
Stable
+0.02 avg changeRatings by Course
HEV141155252
5.0
(1)HEV256447
5.0
(1)AMD141
4.8
(9)HEV141252
4.7
(3)FMD141
4.4
(5)Difficulty by Course
EVERYONE
5.0
AWFUL
4.0
HEV256447
4.0
AMD547
3.8
AMD252
3.5