her class is NOT BORING! Her class is pretty good but you gotta know your basics otherwise it will feel like you are missing a load of stuff since she goes over things as if it were a review. But if you ask her about your problems she is very helpful.

Too prush a too is four! I terr a yoo, is four! This woman rocks Harper like a hurricane! Take her. If her antics don't entertain you, you're probably a vegetable. Easy class. Minhua is a blast.

MULTIPLE CHOICE TESTS WHAT IS EASIER THEN THAT!!!!

BEST HARPER MATH TEACHER! 1. Multiple choice tests 2. HW is extra credit 3. Coming to class is extra credit 4. Teacher is very nice 5. Grading style is clear. I took Azad first semester and dropped. I hate the ****. Take Lui, i love this teacher!

she is the awesome teacher. she explains so clearly that within a second u get it. and also helps personaly. her test are hard but in test she ask from notes and homework only. so not a big deal.

Folks, she not that hard. If you do what a student is suppose to do you'll be fine with Lui. That doesn't mean you're get an 'A,' but you'll be alright.

helps out when needed

helps out when needed i disagree with the others when i had a question she always answered it and i believe her teaching style is great... but if you dont get the problems with at least one or two examples then you should not take her.....she knows how to teach

IF YOU WERE AN HONORS STUDENT IN HIGH SCHOOL YOU WILL LOVE THIS TEACHER........SHE WAS GREAT TESTS ARE EASY IF YOU STUDY BUT GIVE HER A CHANCE SHE IS GREAT AND ALWAYS ASKS THE STUDENTS IF THEY GET IT..... BUT YOU NEED TO SPEND TIME STUDYING......

Two prusha two is four. It's about that easy!

dont listen to them she's good. all you need to do to pass the class is do all the homework which is easy and come to class. she's kinda hard to understand but she's actually funny and she wants u to pass not fail and gives lots and lots of extra credit.

yea do not listen to all these comments. she is a great teacher. you have to get to kno her. if u dont go to class and jus expect to get an A then good luck. her lectures are pretty clear. she might go fast but you have to talk to her and she will go back. the more you ask questions the more she gets helpful. just dont sit there only ...talk to her

She is not as bad as people make her out to be. She's a good teacher, goes a little fast but will slow down and explain more, if people ask questions. She's tough but fair.

I heard lots of bad things about Ms. Liu, but I personally liked her. She's really nice and funny. The tests are kind of hard though.

Mrs. Liu is awesome! She makes sure you understand everything really well. If you have questions she encourages you to ask them. Her tests are based off the review that she does with the class the day before, but they are not easy so be prepared to work hard. She is a great teacher and extremely smart! TAKE HER!! YOU GET NOW!

I've taken 3 classes with her as the teacher and every one of those classes I've gotten a B or higher. Very good teacher and easy to understand as well as very helpful to the students. If you're having trouble with work in her class she can really help you easily catch up. She's also really good cuz she goes around the class helping each student.

I failed and it was ALL MY FAULT! The class is really hard, but she will give you everything you need to succeed she is also hilarious. She makes sure everyone gets it before she moves on if you don't speak up it's your fault. I've never had a teacher that cares so much! Great teacher!

Not an easy teacher , but she is really clear and approachable , she explains the material very well. she ha a review session each time before the test which basically prepare you 80% for the test

My favorite teacher at harper. Took for Calc 1 and 2. Got A's in both classes. Very prepared for class and her number one goal is to get her students to understand the concepts. Wish she was teaching Calc 3 but I couldnt convince her. Do you homework and BE THERE for review days before the test.

She is a great teacher. Please take her. I took her for Computer Science. Everyone in my class that payed attention and studied the notes she gives us before the test got a B or higher. You do not need to study from the textbook. The notes she gives you are enough to get an A in class. Just make sure you study the notes you take in class.

She is a great teacher. She wont move on until everyone understands it she offers help when you need it. She does sometimes yell but if you care about your grade in the class and put effort then take this class. She teaches it really well and is helpful im not a big math person but she made this class easier to understand

She was a great teacher. She barely used the book (Big C++). She was very knowledgeable about CS and she was always ready to help anyone who needed it. Her tests weren't too bad as long as you follow her guidelines for the format of the code. I would recommend her.

She is a rather hard grader, don't come into the class thinking you can skim by and get an A. If you do the homework, and study for the tests you definitely won't fail the class. She expects you to memorize all the formulas you need to know. If you put forth the effort you won't fail the class.

I had her for Calc this past semester, and was initially worried due to the ratings on here. I was pleasantly surprised to find Liu is very kind and passionate about her subject. She wants you to learn and is willing to help. Her accent may be tricky for some to understand, but this is common amongst many teachers at Harper. I would have her again.

Talks fast but if you watch the examples you'll understand test are short and if you go to the review you'll be fine for the test. Go to class and do the honework

Great teacher to take calculus with. She provides example problems. She checks homework but does not collect or grade it and goes over it in class the next day. There is a review day before each test where she outlines the test for you. The textbook is a reference tool but good to purchase. Attend class, do the homework, and ask questions.

Test every 2 weeks-30 points each. HW is graded on effort. Lowest test is dropped and replaced with your attendance score. Lectures were useless to me, though some liked them. She shouts math at you until it's pounded into your brain. "U get now! Hello!". She is actually very nice and helpful though. She's funny too. There are worse profs out there

She is pretty cool, explains well, gives examples, checks hw daily and drops lowest test with hw. I really recommend her. She funny too which is a plus. cool proffesor

I don't understand these reviews aboout her here. She is by far one of my favorite teachers, I had her for Calc 1 and Calc 2. When I needed help, she agreed to meet me right away. She does go fast sometimes but she's a really cool teacher who's willing to help. I love her grading system. She will help you acheive the best grade possible.

This professor is an amazing teacher. Even though sometimes you may find that the material she is teaching is confusing, she will do many examples until you get the problem. Would recommend to everyone!!!

This was my first year in college, and I needed to take Calculus 1, so I took her. She is a great professor, and there is no good excuse not to get an A in this class. She tells you what will be on test and does a review day. Test are 3 free response and 20 multiple choice. She will try to give partial credit and sometimes let's you retry.

I am confident in my belief that those who wrote negative reviews for Mrs. Liu did not apply themselves or pay attention in her class and then blamed her for their bad grades. Calculus is tough sometimes, but Mrs. Liu only tests you on the concepts that you should be an expert on, as long as you go to class.

Very good Calc 1 teacher. You truly have to earn the A, but you learn so much in the process. If you are a hardworking student, take this class because she is very rewarding to someone like yourself. I would definitely take her again.

She is an amazing teacher, but you have to be willing to work hard and study. Otherwise, you won't pass. Attend class and do your homework!

She is honestly one of the best math teachers ive ever had, she spends a lot of time making sure all of her students are understanding the material and spends a lot of time trying to explain things you don't understand. She is very easily reached and is by far one of the best math teachers on campus :^)

If you really want to learn calculus and are willing to give your time Mrs. Liu will meet with you and help you understand. She provides an awesome final review for the online course. Highly recommend her.

Mrs. Liu is very under rated. She has an accent so it can be hard to understand her at first but you get used to it. Her tests are very easy and she is very helpful. She also gives a lot of extra credit. She was one of my favorite math teachers and I would take her again.

She has an accent but you can understand he as you get more used to it. She is such a great teacher that goes over everything and gives so many example problems. She grades really easily on tests and doesn't grade the homework. She wants you to pass. Her tests are pretty easy and she's funny. I wish she was teaching Calc2 next semester.

She was a good teacher. Used to go around class to check whether students were doing in-class assignments and help us if we had any questions. Never used the book. Her accent was a little distracting at times. I took her in the summer and got A, but I also had a good background in calc.

I wish that Prof. Liu taught Calc 2. I took calculus in high school and mostly already understood the course, but she made the concepts so much clearer than I remember learning them. Her accent isn't that hard to understand and she will do everything to make sure you pass the class. Homework is completion, tests are short and the class isn't long.

Took MTH200 over the summer. She talks really fast when she's giving the lessons, but if you're confused, she slows down and explains for you. Very lenient grader for tests and goes over every homework problem. Courseload is very little, just study for tests, and you pass. Her accent is a little hard to understand at times, but you get used to it.

Phenomenal teacher, took her for my calc 1 class during the summer and it was much easier with her as the teacher. She makes sure you understand the formula, constantly asking whether you have questions or not. If you do have a question she will happily answer it with a response that often makes the issue go away. Would recommend to future students

Took Her Online Class. Gives 3 Chances For Each Homework Assignment, & For Each Problem. Homework Assignments Are Long. Are Given 2 Chances On Each Quiz. Final Is Taken On Campus & Allows A Cheat Sheet.

Took Calc 1 over the summer with her, amazingly attentive toward every student, and extremely helpful both in and out of the classroom. I have nothing but great things to say about her

Fantastic. As long as you do the homework and projects in CS121, you will easily get the hang of it. Attendance replaces your lowest test score. So go to class. If you're learning a programming language, you really don't want to miss class anyway. Did not use the book at all.

One of my first Professors at Harper. She is amazing. Her homework and lectures are straight. i.e you will get an A if you learn. If you can't pass the class or find programming is too difficult, I suggest you shouldn't take higher-level CS classes after CSC121. Take time to practice and learn more.

I took her online calculus class, being calculus its already difficult. She did have good lecture videos, they were sorted nicely as well. Occasionally there will be a question on a quiz/test that wasnt gone over which is frustrating. Though if youre naturally good at figuring things out, you should be fine.

I though that I was terrible at math, but Mrs. Liu was fantastic. Take this professor if you get chance. You will not regret it.

Super sweet teacher! Only grades based on tests though no quizzes or homework grades. Pretty easy class as well if you understand the lectures. Go to class, she will replace your lowest test score with your attendance grade!! She does care about her students & is willing to put in the time. Can look a little intimidating but super understanding!

Minhua Liu is great and does a very well job at meeting expectations as a college professor. She cares about her students a lot and will help you work through a problem if you don't understand. She encourages to ask questions in her lecture you should not shy away from it, it definitely helps in the long run.

Very glad I got to take this professor in my first and second semester. Highly recommend her as she is extremely straight forward and elaborate with every single lecture she does. As long as you do the homework that she gives frequently then it is impossible to not get an A in this class. If you are taking math then definitely choose this professor

Such a great teacher. She will always find time for you to help with any questions you have. She responds to emails as fast as it possible, which is a great thing, if you struggle in math as me.

Do you want to pass? AND ACTUALLY LEARN. Take this class i promise YOU WILL NOT REGRET

TAKE HER! Biased b/c I have taken calculus in high school but her class was one HW a week, quizzes every two weeks, midterm, and a final. Multiple choice (everything) and on Pearson. She responds to her emails fast and can answer anything. It's self paced, so you can finish the class like half way through the semester. Calc never felt more simple.

Took CALCI and I truly enjoyed it. She will respond on your emails as fast as she can. Also, she will help you with your questions. She is great.

It's a pretty straightforward syllabus, a manageable class. As long as you don't miss the deadline, there will be no problems. One of the best professors in mathematics. Definitely get it without hesitation!

She doesn't make the lectures herself. Lectures are not congruent. Everything is multiple choice. If you actually want to learn the material, choose another instructor.

Best prof ever