3.9

Nancy Guy

Music - University of California San Diego

3.9
Quality
2.5
Difficulty
65%
Would Retake
90
Reviews
3.9
Quality
2.5
Difficulty
3.8
Helpful
3.9
Clarity

65%

Would Retake

90

Reviews

Rating Distribution
Official

5

45

4

23

3

4

2

8

1

10

What Students Say

Guy is clearly experienced & an expert in the field

MUS110 - 5.0 rating

It offers a great deal to learn about a different culture

MUS111CO - 5.0 rating
Class Info

Attendance Mandatory

54%

Textbook Required

70%

Grade Predictor

Your expected effort level

LowHigh

Predicted Grade

A+

95% confidence
Based on 22 grades
Most common grades:
A (9)
A+ (7)
A- (6)
Grade Distribution
A(16)B(0)C(0)D(0)F(0)A-/B+(6)
Based on 27 reported grades
A: 9
A+: 7
A-: 6
Not sure yet: 4
Common Tags
Lecture heavy (7)
Test heavy (7)
Inspirational (5)
Get ready to read (5)
EXTRA CREDIT (5)
Clear grading criteria (4)
Graded by few things (4)
Respected (3)
Rating Trend

Declining

-0.36 avg change
Nov
May
Jun
Jan
Nov
Dec
Last 6 months
Ratings by Course

MUSIC13AS

5.0

(2)

MUSIC114

5.0

(1)

MUS13AMUS111

5.0

(1)

13AS111111

5.0

(1)

MUS87

5.0

(2)
+16 more courses
Difficulty by Course

MUS110

3.5

MUS120B

3.5

CAT3

3.5

MUSIC111

3.3

MUSSEC1

3.0

Reviews (90)
5.0
3.0
MUSIC13AS
Nov 21, 2003

She is a great lecturer. Is straightfoward and very clear. Class is awesome and very interesting. I would highly recommend this class.

5.0
3.0
MUS13AS
Grade: A+
Feb 22, 2004

No Comments

4.0
2.0
MUS111
May 2, 2004

passionate, informed, straightforward. interesting, quirky personality; congenial, cultured, pleasant professor. speaks mandarin. good class, good music :)

5.0
1.0
MUS13AS
May 14, 2004

Highly recommend this class.

4.0
1.0
MUS111
Sep 15, 2004

AWESOM CLASS. AWESOME PROF.

5.0
2.0
MUS111
Nov 9, 2004

great professor, makes class fun and flexible. interesting topics and great materials.

5.0
2.0
MUSIC114
Nov 13, 2004

Her tests/quizzes are super easy as long as you do the reading because everything is very straight forward. She's the only teacher that made me think Peking Opera is interesting

4.0
3.0
MUS13
Nov 20, 2004

She is kind of intimidating- very vocal about things that bother her. Taking notes in lecture is a must.

5.0
1.0
MUS13AS
Dec 20, 2004

make sure you turn off your cell phone before going to her lectures

5.0
1.0
MUS13AMUS111
Feb 21, 2005

Makes things interesting. Straight foward. Has fun. Test are easy as long as you have read the material and listened to the songs (not much studying required).

5.0
2.0
MUS111
Mar 9, 2005

Professor Guy is awesome. She is a strong female professional who is still funny and personable. She truly cares about the material and her students. Class isn't very hard either.

5.0
1.0
MUS13AS
Mar 29, 2005

Fun class & fun professor. She's honest, helpful, and likes her job -- good stuff!

4.0
3.0
MUS110
May 6, 2005

she's nice, yet oddly her TA's screwed me over on one of the mid terms. But it was an interesting class if you are into that stuff

4.0
1.0
MUS111
May 11, 2005

wow他講講中文! Impressive professor.

5.0
1.0
MUS111
Jun 7, 2005

i think this class is a joke (in a good way). either she's getting extremely lazy or this class is just getting easier compared to previous years..

5.0
1.0
13AS111111
Jun 7, 2005

I took her class every quarter for the past year, and got A+ for all classes. Very easy and interesting. Definitely GPA booster classes.

5.0
1.0
MUS87
Jun 13, 2005

Could get personal at times, but she was very informative. She impressed me enough with her deep knowledge in Chinese language and music.

5.0
2.0
MUS111
Jun 13, 2005

Awesome professor! She knows what she's talking about (talks TOO much sometimes) and is very funny and very nice. I didn't think music from Taiwan could be that interesting, but prof Guy made it a great subject to learn!

5.0
1.0
MUS111
Jun 18, 2005

she rocks! she speaks fluent mandarin too.

5.0
1.0
MUS111
Aug 30, 2005

Best teacher ever!

4.0
2.0
MUS13AS
Nov 24, 2005

she tries to be funny, but sometimes it just comes out cold. she singles people out for stupid reasons sometimes. other than that the topics are interesting and i learned a lot about asian and oceania music. she is very knowledgable about chinese and taiwanese music. her lectures get kind of boring sometimes and very repetative. the TAs r cool

5.0
1.0
MUS13AS
Dec 15, 2005

Def a gpa booster class.Tests not bad at all. Pro. Guy is truly caring about the students.Although a bit unstructured at times, her lectures were very clear and easy to understand.Take really good notes in class. The ta's were not too helpful, felt like they were learning it at the same time we were. Jason Ponce is hot though!

5.0
2.0
MUSIC13AS
Jan 6, 2006

Prof. Guy is an awesome lady. Her lectures aren't too bad and all the reading is online so you don't have to spend money on a textbook. Tests come 99% from lecture, so it is important to go. Section was a waste for the most part. Don't take Jason, he might be okay to look at, but he is a horrible TA. Interesting class, not too difficult.

5.0
1.0
MUS111TAIWAN
Jun 28, 2006

NOt a bad class to take. Prof Guy is funny and approachable. There's a no curve for the class since everyone does so well on the quizzes and midterm. No reading necessary for the midterms, everything is from lecture notes and listening. Highly recommended.

5.0
1.0
MUSIC111
Aug 5, 2006

Ended up taking three classes tought by Prof. Guy. Very nice professor. Very approachable and helpful. Fun classes. Attending class is a must. Makes the midterms and finals much more easy. Most material on tests is material which was reviewed in class. Highly recommend this professor.

4.0
2.0
MUS13AS
Dec 14, 2006

Readings are practically unnecessary; interesting and easy class. The TA (L. Lin), despite being a nice guy, dragged things out for way too long and was generally incompetent when it came to actually teaching. The grading on any written stuff is weird, but I heard that the other two TAs were far more clear and concise in explaining those items.

5.0
2.0
MUS13AS
Jan 13, 2007

a very good professor... very into china and taiwan... tests are pretty easy, but you still have to study... she assigns reading, but dont really have to read it.... tests are mostly based on lecture so take good notes... listen to the music a couple times before a test

1.0
5.0
MUSIC111
Mar 1, 2007

her test requires you to know everything!!

1.0
5.0
MUSIC111
Mar 1, 2007

hsrd!!!!

5.0
3.0
MUS111
Mar 9, 2007

Terrific teacher. I have a feeling the ppl on here who gave her a poor rating bombed the midterm and just don't like doing work.... Passionate about what she teaches. I recommend her so long as you're not afraid to study for a music class.

4.0
2.0
MUS111
Mar 30, 2007

Nice teacher. Need to study for this class.

2.0
2.0
MUS111
May 18, 2007

Prof. Guy is fairly nice, but this class isn't as easy as I thought it would be... expect the same amount of work as a History class

1.0
5.0
MUS111
May 20, 2007

I don't know about the very first ratings about her but she is NOW really hard! Especially if you don't know Chinese/Taiwanese since she talks in it all the time and expects you to know it for the tests! She also goes off tangent all the time and loves to talk about herself. She even asks questions that she didn't go over in lecture! Worst teacher!

2.0
4.0
MUS111
May 31, 2007

She's a horrible lecturer & for the things you need to know for the tests, she barely talks about (so those facts seem trivial to know but she put them on the test!)She talks more about herself than the actual topic. And her TA's that grade the essays can barely speak English and grade the papers ridiculously! Their comments don't make sense at all

2.0
4.0
MUS111
Jun 7, 2007

Try not to take this class. This is ONLY a pretty easy A class if you understand Taiwanese/Chinese, which is not very fair to the other students. She tends to brag about herself a lot. She also tends to mumble when she lectures (because she often just reads straight from her papers) and goes off tangent many times.

4.0
3.0
MUS111
Jun 7, 2007

She is very knowledgable about taiwan and taiwanese music. Attending class is a MUST. Makes the midterms and finals much more easy. She can be fun, but doesn't suffer fools, as some of her recent ratings seem to show.

3.0
4.0
MUS111
Jun 7, 2007

This is not an easy A class. The professor is kind of strange/awkward. She does know a lot about Taiwan/Taiwanese music but she also tends to mix things up (which is not good for when you need to take the tests). She lectures horribly since it's hard to take notes because you don't really know what things you should concentrate on.

3.0
2.0
MUSIC111
Jul 1, 2007

The lion's share of material she tests on, comes from lecture. I would agree with the recent posts; this class is not as easy as it may have originally been. A lot of what is tested on is written in languages other than english, so it is difficult to prepare for exams if one cannot understand Asian dialect. I did not find the class interesting.

4.0
2.0
MUS13
Nov 17, 2007

She is a really great professor, she is very approachable and quite knowledgeable. The class focuses very heavily on China.

5.0
1.0
MUS13AS
Dec 6, 2007

attending lecture is a must. makes it easy to take notes as long as you listen. shes really funny and i absolutely loved this class even though im not asian. i would recommend this to anyone especially because theres no book and youre never tested on the readings, only stuff from lectures. take this class, you wont be disappointed!

5.0
1.0
MUS13AS
Dec 30, 2007

She assigns readings but you can usually make do in lectures without having read them (She knows nobody reads them :P) Just make sure you take good notes during lecture cos that's where all the test material comes from. Most of the time she gives ridiculously obvious hints as to what the essay questions will be on the test. It's a fun class :)

2.0
3.0
MUSSEC1
Jan 11, 2008

This professor is not clear in lecture. However, attendance at lectures is a must and watch out for questions on the test that ask for obscure details. I agree with the previous rating that said she was "strange/awkward". I wouldn't take her again.

4.0
1.0
MUS13AS
Nov 18, 2008

AMAZING professor. that is if you are asian. She can really relate to you. Very interesting. Easy quizzes and hw assignments.

5.0
3.0
MUS120B
Jun 6, 2009

I Love this professor, she is so enthusiastic in her teachings!! :) always so into her lectures, I find her class very fun. She is nice, helpful, CLEAR! , and her midterm was not bad at all if you read, attend lectures, and use her study guide.

5.0
1.0
MUS192
Jun 7, 2009

I took this senior seminar on opera and madness because I needed a 1 credit course & it fit my schedule. It turned out to be great! Prof Guy is NUTS about opera and now I am too! The class is fun and there's no serious work. Just go to class and fall in love with Lucia & other operatic mad women.

2.0
2.0
MUSIC13
Mar 23, 2010

Her class was incredibly problematic. She made very offhand comments about genocide, incorporated her awkward personal stories into unrelated matters, and just didn't have very well put together lectures. I learned very little.

5.0
4.0
MUS110
Oct 23, 2010

Very harsh in the beginning (I was literally scared to come to class), but by the end I couldn't wait to come & participate in discussions with her. Dr. Guy is clearly experienced & an expert in the field. I quickly learned this & trusted her when she said the assignments would be useful. Probably the most literate and educated professor I've had.

2.0
5.0
MUS111
Mar 29, 2011

terrible teacher, i don't recommend taking her if you don't want to lower your GPA, unhelpful most of the time and is an egomaniac, be wary

1.0
5.0
CAT3
Apr 21, 2011

Horrible teacher for CAT. Ridiculously difficult listening quiz where you have to memorize a million bird songs, whale songs, names and dates of musical compositions. Really close-minded. TA's were pretty bad too.

2.0
4.0
CAT3
May 9, 2011

Horrible teacher for CAT writing class. Lectures have nothing to do with papers. Expects us to memorize different bird and whale songs among other sounds that have nothing to do with class. DO NOT TAKE.

3.0
2.0
CAT3
May 15, 2011

She's kinda melancholic. Sometimes she's very nice and helpful, other times she's really mean and close-minded. She's very into her own interests (Taiwan and opera) and tries to bring them up even when it's not relevant. The class is not too hard, not too much reading. The essay prompts are broad and kinda confusing. Sometimes gives EC for lecture.

1.0
3.0
CAT3
May 15, 2011

Honestly, the worst prof I have had my entire college life. She is so into her ownself and her studies that she expects the class to memorize ever stupid detail. She makes 30 % of your grade based of quizes that are from lecture and even though the entire class did poorly she wouldn't curvre because it was as she says our fault. NEVER TAKE HER

4.0
4.0
MUS120B
Jun 9, 2011

I understand that some students do not like Professor Guy because she is strict. However, I appreciate her stern attitude towards studying and heavy workload. This is balanced nicely with her humorous personality. Perhaps a criticism is that she is sometimes intimidating.

2.0
5.0
CAT3
Jun 9, 2011

This professor graded based off of a short paper (4-5pgs), 2 "quizzes," cat events, and a final paper. What was stupid is that the 2 "quizzes" weigh more than the final paper. You'd think a writing course would be based off your writing...Horrible professor. Didn't learn anything. Shes very condescending and expects people to have musical knowledge

4.0
3.0
CAT3
Jun 16, 2011

not as hard as other people said, the quizzes are doable if you use the notes from her lecture, i managed to get a decent grade

4.0
3.0
CAT3
Jun 16, 2011

not as hard as other people said, the quizzes are doable if you use the notes from her lecture, i managed to get a decent grade.

4.0
3.0
CAT3
Aug 7, 2011

Very interesting class. I definitely learned a great deal. Her lectures held my attention, and she usually explains the materials pretty well. Quizzes were very fact oriented, but fair.

5.0
3.0
MUS120
Apr 15, 2012

Prof Guy is passionate about music, especially opera. She got us through 150 years of music history in one quarter which wasn't easy. I enjoyed going to lecture and am glad to have had a chance to write a music research paper. She walked us through the research and writing process.

5.0
1.0
MUS87
Sep 18, 2012

She knows her material and wants her students to learn. I've learned a lot about Taiwan and music in general.

5.0
1.0
MUS87OPER
Feb 5, 2013

She is very interested in opera, and that interest spills out onto the students.

5.0
2.0
MUS111CO
Grade: A-
Jun 6, 2014

Despite the fact that I have no interest in Chinese Opera, I've actually really enjoyed this class and would definitely recommend it. It offers a great deal to learn about a different culture!

5.0
3.0
MUS111CO
Grade: A
Jun 15, 2014

Extremely passionate and awesome professor! I entered the without the realization that it was going to be solely on Chinese Opera. Definitely not my favorite music form, but it was truly a good learning experience and Professor Guy present the material so that you always stay intrigued.

5.0
2.0
MUS111
Grade: A-
Mar 25, 2015

Prof Guy is very knowledgeable about Chinese opera (of course) and is also quite entertaining at times, referencing pop culture or making other slight tangents. She's definitely very strict about classroom etiquette (and not without reason).

4.0
2.0
MUS12
Grade: A
Jun 9, 2015

I like music, but I wasn't expecting to get so into opera just from this class. Prof. Guy is really passionate & knowledgeable about the subject & her enthusiasm is contagious. There were only 3 quizzes but they aren't difficult, she explicitly states that she doesn't want them to be difficult. She's really just focused on students' learning

5.0
1.0
MUS12OPERA
Grade: A
Jun 17, 2015

Fantastic instructor with a passion for her material. Even if the course material weren't interesting (which it is) Professor Guy alone is enough reason to take the course.

5.0
2.0
MUS12
Grade: A+
Jun 17, 2015

She is wonderful, I've never seen a professor that really loves their subject so much and it really makes the class so much more enjoyable. She tells fun stories and clearly explains the material so that you never feel left behind or confused (as long as you go to class). I went in not really liking opera but will now make the effort to go see one

5.0
1.0
MUS13AS
May 24, 2016

There are readings but you don't have to do them. Just go to class and she'll tell you what will be on the exams. There were 3 quizzes and no final. The quizzes are easy if you review the listening list and just again, go to class and pay attention. She occasionally speaks Chinese which is funny because Chinese Internationals get surprised lol.

5.0
3.0
MUS12
Grade: A-
Aug 31, 2016
Would take again

Professor Guy is an amazing teacher who is extremely passionate about Opera and truly cares about her students. She makes the class very enjoyable with various videos and personal stories.

Inspirational
ACCESSIBLE OUTSIDE CLASS
Amazing lectures
5.0
1.0
MUS12
Grade: A+
Apr 7, 2017
Would take again

I really like this opera course! It inspires me a lot on classical music! Her exams have many extra credit so do not worry, lecture is interesting (and I personally like the lecture's length) discussion is mandatory.

Get ready to read
Inspirational
Clear grading criteria
5.0
4.0
MUS111CO
Grade: A
Jun 22, 2017
Would take again

I was never interested in Chinese opera until now; I thought it was a strange art form. But since Professor Guy has incorporated the art along with Chinese history, I've come to appreciate it and what it stands for.

Respected
Skip class? You won't pass.
Inspirational
5.0
3.0
MUS13
Grade: A-
Nov 2, 2017
Would take again

Knowledgable, awesome, and speaks Chinese!

Gives good feedback
Inspirational
Amazing lectures
4.0
2.0
MUS12
Grade: A
Mar 27, 2018
Wouldn't take again

Really great professor who is super passionate about opera. Large portion of grade were quizzes which weren't bad if you engaged in lecture. Didn't like or know much about opera coming in but this class made it aight coming out

Respected
Skip class? You won't pass.
Caring
5.0
2.0
MUS12
May 8, 2018
Would take again

Professor Guy is really passionate about what she's teaching and truly cares about her students.

ACCESSIBLE OUTSIDE CLASS
Clear grading criteria
EXTRA CREDIT
1.0
3.0
MUS13
Dec 17, 2018
Wouldn't take again

She's so mean. She did not care about her students and her classes is SO boring. Def won't take her again.

TEST HEAVY
4.0
3.0
MUS12
Mar 24, 2020
Would take again

She's really passionate about opera and also has a lot of interesting discussions with students in class. Overall the class was well-organized and had fair tests. Lecture atttendance is not mandatory but you really should go because a lot of the material in lecture could come up on quizzes.

Clear grading criteria
Caring
EXTRA CREDIT
5.0
1.0
MUS13
Grade: A+
Jun 8, 2022
Would take again

Professor Guy is very passionate about the content of the course. The quizzes and content checks were very straightforward meaning you're already well prepared as a result of attending the lectures and discussions alone. A large portion of your grade are quizzes, but you'll be just fine as long as you stay up to date with the material.

Amazing lectures
Graded by few things
4.0
3.0
MUS13
Grade: Audit/No Grade
Jun 17, 2022

lots of memorization of non-English contents if you are not Asian it could be tough for you there are essay questions on test the grading is not very lenient, but you still can get extra credits on exams. take this class for pnp(lots of people do) so it is easy. Discussion is mandatory. No video recordings of lecture.

EXTRA CREDIT
Lecture heavy
Graded by few things
4.0
3.0
MUS13
Grade: A+
Jul 11, 2022
Would take again

Great professor who likes her subject and what she teaches. The lectures are very interesting, but she does not podcast them, so DO NOT SKIP THEM! If you skip the lectures, you will not pass. Also has a no-devices policy in class, but I don't think you have to follow it. Section is mandatory, and very useful, so don't skip. Enjoyed the class a lot!

5.0
3.0
MUS13
Grade: A-
Nov 10, 2023
Would take again

The course was test-heavy, and so studying with flash cards, going over notes, etc. was the main work in the class. The professor is nice, and the content was mildly entertaining. Taken as a GE, but I found the course enjoyable, and the effort I put in I thought reflected the grade I received.

Amazing lectures
Respected
Test heavy
1.0
5.0
MUS12
Grade: Not sure yet
May 3, 2024

This class is boring and difficult. Her Lecture is unclear and she goes over the slides super fast. The slides are filled with words which you have to memorize. This class don't help you with any thing related to Opera, it helps you to learn how to memorize boring information and how to cope with unreasonable requests, like printing out papers.

Tough grader
So many papers
Test heavy
4.0
4.0
MUS12
Grade: A-
Jun 5, 2024

The tests are on paper with listening, fill-in-the-blank, and matching. They're also tedious and some of the info I don't remember seeing in the lecture. Makes you attend an opera. Boring lectures, but you don't have to even attend them just study the slides. She's pretty funny though. Had to write two papers and print them out. Not the worst class

Tough grader
Lecture heavy
Test heavy
5.0
2.0
MUS12
Grade: A+
Jun 6, 2024
Would take again

Please do not skip class on this on purpose and or often, despite everything being posted online afterwards. Important to show up to watch and listen to operas and hear Guy's commentary on it and usually what is being said will be referenced indirectly or directly on the quizzes. Easy to fail but even easier to walk out with an A. Listen and attend

Caring
Test heavy
Graded by few things
1.0
5.0
MUS111
Grade: Not sure yet
Jan 28, 2025

SHE IS HORRIBLE

So many papers
Lecture heavy
Test heavy
1.0
5.0
MUS111
Grade: Not sure yet
Jan 28, 2025

Worst music teacher.

So many papers
Lecture heavy
Test heavy
1.0
5.0
MUS13
Grade: Not sure yet
Nov 19, 2025

Don't take, she expects to much from students when she doesn't even help with her lectures. The first midterm was fine, the second one was way much of history rather than music. For two weeks she doesn't even teach she posted videos that you can't even understand what the people say, and it was mostly history than music.

Get ready to read
Test heavy
4.0
3.0
MUS13
Grade: A
Dec 11, 2025
Would take again

Clearly cares about students and is very interested in the material. I disagree with the other recent reviews, I think if you genuinely get interested in the material and take the time to learn it, the class is not too bad.

5.0
2.0
MUS13
Grade: A
Dec 11, 2025
Would take again

The class is super easy and enjoyable if you engage with the content. I would say, her TA's helped a lot for the quizzes so definitely go to discussion (it's mandatory), but everything was already talked about in lecture or canvas. The lectures can put you to sleep, but she is a nice professor who just wants you to learn.

Get ready to read
Inspirational
Lecture heavy
4.0
3.0
MUS13
Grade: A
Dec 13, 2025
Would take again

Overall very passionate professor who cares about the material she is teaching. Lectures are not mandatory, but TA discussion sessions are. Course was more difficult than expected, with more memorisation of facts than actual music knowledge. Lots of reading, especially during the second half of the quarter when it's asynchronous lectures.

Get ready to read
EXTRA CREDIT
3.0
3.0
MUS13
Grade: A
Dec 18, 2025
Would take again

UCSD course description LIES it's entirely an East Asian music class which I wasn't expecting. Lectures not recorded, discussion mandatory, lectures are extra credit sometimes. Questions on tests are random sometimes and are just memorizing facts. Lectures were fine but slides were mildly bad and hard to study off of.

Clear grading criteria
Lecture heavy
Graded by few things
5.0
2.0
MUS13
Grade: A+
Dec 18, 2025
Would take again

Professor Guy is v passionate & funny! Many questions are based on odd lecture-only/discussion-only/reading trivia, so I highly recc going to lecture(!!) & discussion, and noting EVERYTHING. If memorizing random facts is your thing, it'll be fun for you (I'm neurodivergent lol, but also I kept forgetting the weekly(ish) content checks). EC on tests

Get ready to read
EXTRA CREDIT
Lecture heavy
Class Info

Attendance Mandatory

54%

Textbook Required

70%

Grade Predictor

Your expected effort level

LowHigh

Predicted Grade

A+

95% confidence
Based on 22 grades
Most common grades:
A (9)
A+ (7)
A- (6)
Grade Distribution
A(16)B(0)C(0)D(0)F(0)A-/B+(6)
Based on 27 reported grades
A: 9
A+: 7
A-: 6
Not sure yet: 4
Common Tags
Lecture heavy (7)
Test heavy (7)
Inspirational (5)
Get ready to read (5)
EXTRA CREDIT (5)
Clear grading criteria (4)
Graded by few things (4)
Respected (3)
Rating Trend

Declining

-0.36 avg change
Nov
May
Jun
Jan
Nov
Dec
Last 6 months
Ratings by Course

MUSIC13AS

5.0

(2)

MUSIC114

5.0

(1)

MUS13AMUS111

5.0

(1)

13AS111111

5.0

(1)

MUS87

5.0

(2)
+16 more courses
Difficulty by Course

MUS110

3.5

MUS120B

3.5

CAT3

3.5

MUSIC111

3.3

MUSSEC1

3.0

Similar Professors