3.3

Ofer Meilich

Business - California State University San Marcos

3.3
Quality
3.8
Difficulty
39%
Would Retake
84
Reviews
3.3
Quality
3.8
Difficulty
3.3
Helpful
3.2
Clarity

39%

Would Retake

84

Reviews

Rating Distribution
Official
84 total ratings

5

34

4

13

3

4

2

12

1

20

What Students Say

He is engaging but the material is tough

BUS444 - 5.0 rating

one of the best teachers at cal state because he makes the subject interesting

BUS444 - 5.0 rating
Class Info

Online Classes

100%

Attendance Mandatory

100%

Textbook Required

29%

Grade Predictor

Your expected effort level

LowHigh

Predicted Grade

B+

95% confidence
Based on 15 grades
Most common grades:
B+ (5)
B (3)
A (3)
Grade Distribution
A(3)B(4)C(2)D(0)F(0)A-/B+(6)
Based on 20 reported grades
B+: 5
B: 3
A: 3
Not sure yet: 3
Common Tags
Lots of homework (7)
Hilarious (6)
Tough grader (6)
Participation matters (6)
Group projects (4)
So many papers (4)
Gives good feedback (3)
Get ready to read (3)
Rating Trend

Declining

-0.21 avg change
Nov
Sep
Nov
Dec
May
Oct
Last 6 months
Ratings by Course

BUS493

5.0

(1)

BUS442

5.0

(1)

BUS444

3.4

(75)

BUS

3.0

(2)

GBM444

2.0

(1)
+1 more courses
Difficulty by Course

GBM444

5.0

BUS302

4.7

BUS442

4.0

BUS444

3.8

BUS493

3.0

Reviews (83)
1.0
2.0
BUS444
Feb 16, 2003

Confusing, Not helpful at all, No real world business experience

1.0
4.0
BUS302
Feb 17, 2003

As bad as they get, Avoid at all costs

1.0
4.0
BUS444
Feb 20, 2003

Boring, bad, would not take another class from him

1.0
5.0
BUS302
Feb 20, 2003

Very bad, no clarity, major confusion on his behalf on material

5.0
4.0
BUS444
Mar 9, 2003

Tough Class, Tough Test, but you learn a lot, if you put the effort in. Definately not a class if you want to skate by, but if you want to benefit out of the Tuition you pay and learn something take him.

1.0
5.0
BUS444
May 8, 2003

Very cold and unfriendly, confusing and unfair in grading. Personal issues come up way too often.

1.0
5.0
BUS444
Jun 14, 2003

Very unclear on what he wants for the exams. He is a very subjective grader!

1.0
5.0
BUS444
Jul 1, 2003

Very confusing, and not clear at all on assignments, Gets very frustrated if you ask questions

1.0
5.0
BUS302
Aug 20, 2003

Makes test days very stressful and chaotic, very difficult to understand, lacks real world business knowledge

2.0
5.0
GBM444
Dec 23, 2003

Takes pleasure in making everyting as complicated as he can make them; not necessary. Thinks this class is the only class students have. Has deluded himself into thinking he is promoting learning.

4.0
5.0
BUS444
Mar 14, 2004

This course covers a lot of key material that will help you out in the long run if you pay attention. Crazy number of assignments but it isn't all busy work. I would recomend this class based on his sense of humor alone. Also, its required.

5.0
3.0
BUS444
Grade: B+
Mar 24, 2004

Great teacher, great class if you truly want to learn how to learn.... I got an A in his class, and it is possible, despite what others say... if you learn to think differently! Don't memorize... understand, and it will be a piece of cake!

3.0
3.0
BUS444
Apr 3, 2004

This class is definitely time consuming but not hard. The IAA was my only nightmare. The rest could be worse. All i have to say is get good team members and you'll be fine. Ofer is funny at times and sorta weird but he is a good teacher overall.

2.0
4.0
BUS444
Apr 19, 2004

ofer is extremely hard to understand and does not facilitate learning of difficult concepts.

5.0
2.0
BUS444
Nov 18, 2004

His class is a little time consuming and challenging. You can still pull a good grade in the class. He makes us go to a field trip to Biggs Harley Davison. What are all you ****es babbling about? If you cannot handle his class then you should not graduate.

2.0
4.0
BUS444
Nov 19, 2004

Make sure you do not take him. He is insecure, not sure of himself, and has Napolean complex. I'm actually doing very well in his class- but I don't respect him. He believes our class-Bus 444 is the only class we are taking. Although the material is interesting, he makes it drawn out.

1.0
5.0
BUS444
Nov 23, 2004

HATE THIS CLASS!!! So boring and don't learn sh**!

5.0
4.0
BUS444
Dec 20, 2004

Ofer was too much fun over the semester! He was not hard to understand and he was more than willing to take an extra couple of minutes to clarify a topic. Also, the anonymous posting board was a blast. There was a lot of really interesting reading there. PS. IAA was tough but worth it in the end. A+

4.0
5.0
BUS444
Dec 21, 2004

Ofer is a great professor. He REALLY tries to make sure you understand the concepts and is very easy to get ahold of if you have any questions. I've never had a professor that was so passionate about teaching. Plus, he was really entertaining and made class as fun as he could. :o)

2.0
5.0
BUS444
Dec 31, 2004

His syllabus itself is very confusing. The class is very demanding and although you start with learning new cases the nightmare begins with the IAA, continues through the midterm exam and ends on the last day on submitting the TIN P.

4.0
4.0
BUS444
Jan 1, 2005

444 is a major pain regardless of your professor. Ofer grades hard, but is fair overall. Very enthusiastic, tries to get you to be, too.

5.0
2.0
BUS444
Jan 18, 2005

Ofer was a great teacher who was very enthusiastic about conveying course material to students. He has high expectations and expects students to be involved and think critically. He is very organized, and has a great website with message board. Hard class, but Ofer made it bearable. -dr. vicodin

5.0
2.0
BUS444
Apr 18, 2005

BUS 444 is a difficult class no matter what professor you have. Ofer is a great professor and is always available to help his students. Up to a certain point it isn't the professor's fault if you don't "get" the material.

5.0
3.0
BUS444
May 3, 2005

Funny quirky guy, runs a fun class. Sometimes you have to repeat something a few times before he hears you. Always avaialable outside of class. Lots of writing, Tons of reading. Do the PO's they aren't graded/free points. Allows for creativity in assignments. Intensive course but not too difficult.

5.0
4.0
BUS444
May 16, 2005

The class will be hard no matter what prof. you take....it's just a lot of work in general. But Ofer is AWESOME. He makes the material fun and has a good sense of humor and is always willing to help in and out of class. I recommend taking 444 with him. The class is a bummer, but he makes it a little bit easier.

5.0
3.0
BUS493
Nov 5, 2005

Ofer is super nice and dedicated to helping his students. He brought us PIZZA! He is always nice and patient. He's like a big brother / father figure.

1.0
3.0
BUS
Nov 9, 2005

No Comments

5.0
4.0
BUS444
Nov 16, 2005

Ofer is an great teacher. This class is hard no matter what and I am glad I got to take it with him. He really cares about his students and wants to help you 100%. He is also funny and quirky which makes sitting through a 2 hour class that much more bearable. He really seems to enjoy teaching students. :)

4.0
3.0
BUS444
Dec 16, 2005

He is grest in class. Although is unclear in response to questions outside of class. He is somewhat strict on grading, but extremely nice prof. I'm glad that I took the class with him overall. Overall I would recommend him.

5.0
4.0
BUS444
May 3, 2006

Great professor - very clear and also fun. Teaches you to think. Go everyday, pay attention, participate and take notes. Ask questions if you don't understand.

5.0
4.0
BUS444
May 4, 2006

Ofer is great. I like the class' format. We do the readings and then go over them in class. He grades tough, but I can't complain 'cause I got an A- on the midterm. The grades are spread through a ton of team projects, but I enjoyed them, so I can't knock him for that. Good job Ofer

4.0
3.0
BUS444
May 9, 2006

expect simultaneous group projects.Course material was really interesting and it was easy keep interest since his lectures are fun and full of information. great class but it will definetely keep you busy.class structure is organized and instructor makes best effort to stay on schedule as indicated on the syllabus/contract.his pet peeve = yawning

5.0
4.0
BUS444
Aug 14, 2006

This class was great! Very difficult and a lot of work, but I learned a lot from the material. There is no B.S.ing meilich as he has already developed an opinion on most issues you will discuss. There is no easy A in 444, but ofer is very quirky and really keeps the students interest. Overall, he does a great job and i would recommend his class

5.0
3.0
BUS444
Aug 16, 2006

Ofer is a very effective professor! The class is not easy, but he gives many opportunities for you to get a good grade. He explains the material well and the class structure is fun. I recomend him!

1.0
4.0
BUS444
Dec 29, 2006

The best statement which fits Ofer is: For those who can't make it in the real world, they teach. He truly has no clue about business outside of CSUSM. His projects were so confusing and have no real world application whatsoever. I highly recommend any other teacher.

5.0
5.0
BUS444
Apr 16, 2007

He is one of the best. It is hard work. You would have hell all the way but it is worth it. Take him:) You would become another person in the end and you would think differently.

4.0
4.0
BUS444
Apr 19, 2007

More work than other profs but its not as difficult. He makes you think outside of the box and apply concepts to the real world. He is def a goofy guy so class is entertaining for such a hard course.

5.0
5.0
BUS444
May 17, 2007

I dont think I would take any other professor for capstone.He is very hard, yes, but all you have to do is attend try to answer some questions in class and do well on most of the quizzes and try to do all the PO's.I got a B and thought I was going to get a C, hes is very passionate and positive about learning you will learn a lot and he is funny.

2.0
5.0
BUS444
May 21, 2007

Hard and takes pride in it!

3.0
4.0
BUS444
Jul 11, 2007

Ofer is an interesting guy, but you need to speak up so he can hear you. Study for the tests and quizes, and my recommendation is to take the class over the summer...TRUST ME!!!!

5.0
5.0
BUS444
Aug 9, 2007

Ofer you are hot!!!! If I was not married I would of ask you out:) The best class I ever had. Take him you would love him but it is not easy at all.

3.0
2.0
BUS444
Aug 18, 2007

if you are serious about business DO NOT take this guy. HORRIBLE. his degree is in aeronautical engineering. if you like to learn from a book and not from someone with ACTUAL bus experience take him. He is the absolute worst teacher i have ever had from preschool to college. the people below are waayyy wrong trust me.

4.0
5.0
BUS444
Sep 25, 2007

Totally great teacher. Guy below was just threatened by Ofer's sense of humor which may take some brains to understand. Great class, learned a lot, very out of the box thinker, and although some concepts were a bit over my head, he tried his best to make sure everyone kept up with the pace of the class

5.0
4.0
BUS444
Dec 14, 2007

Ofer Meilich is one of those professors that you won't forget. He is funny and it seems as if he genuinely cares about his students. The class isn't difficult, it is just time consuming. His exams are fair, he gives lots of quizzes, and his projects are intense, so be prepared to study smart, not hard. Overall, Meilich is great.

5.0
4.0
BUS444
Dec 14, 2007

Ofer Meilich is one of those professors that you won't forget. He is funny and it seems as if he genuinely cares about his students. The class isn't difficult, it is just time consuming. His exams are fair, he gives lots of quizzes, and his projects are intense, so be prepared to study smart, not hard. Overall, Meilich is great.

5.0
3.0
BUS444
Mar 25, 2008

Great teacher!!

5.0
3.0
BUS444
Jul 3, 2008

Ofer is a great teacher. He is very entertaining and he teaches with passion. I have never laughed so much in class before. Take this class over summer if you can! You have to work hard, but it is not too bad, he is very fair.

4.0
4.0
BUS444
Jul 7, 2008

Ofer is an awesome teacher! I had heard horror stories about BUS 444 with Antinou and Gannon.....I'm REALLY glad I took this class with Ofer over the summer. The class is alot of work, lots of reading, quizzes everyday but Ofer made it an awesome class. I recommend taking him 100%!

4.0
4.0
BUS444
Aug 27, 2008

Took BUS 444 two Semesters ago. If you are worried about this professor. BE NOT AFRAID. Work smart not hard!

4.0
4.0
BUS444
Dec 4, 2008

I was really scared to take this class. Don't worry if you take it with Ofer. 11 quizes, 2 presentations, NO FINAL, NO TESTS, one big paper. There is a lot of reading...but nothing difficult. Just read his power pts. Don't buy the book. Waste of money!

5.0
3.0
BUS444
Dec 5, 2008

Ofer is awesome!! He was one of the most entertaining professors I have ever had. Very fair grader. I would definitely recommend him.

2.0
4.0
BUS444
Aug 8, 2009

DO NOT be decieved! Sure...he seems funny, and nice, and entertaining...but that's just a game to him. Attendence is mandatory, READ THE ENTIRE syllabus...including the fine print! DO NOT be late, DO NOT miss class...and if you are a woman..you will have to work twice as hard. He plays favorites-creates drama-GOOD LUCK!

5.0
1.0
BUS444
Dec 27, 2009

He is open-minded, fun professor

2.0
5.0
BUS444
Jan 21, 2010

Looks and feels nice, but that's it. Midterm takes place a month before school ends. If you fail the midterm, you're finished. Very hard grader, which leaves you in a confused state at times. Avoid this guy if possible.

5.0
3.0
BUS444
Dec 16, 2010

way better than the horror stories from the other professor. this guy is funny, and very educational. how people don't pass this class is beyond me. there is a quiz each class and you need a remote. the test is late in the semester. there are 2 group projects as well. one of the best teachers at cal state because he makes the subject interesting.

5.0
4.0
BUS444
Dec 19, 2010

Lots of work, but you know what is expected of you. There are 2 group projects that are time consuming, but not difficult. Midterm is hard, but he curved it. He is always responsive and willing to help. He is a hard grader, but expects you to known the material which is understandable! I enjoyed his class and would recommend him.

2.0
5.0
BUS444
Oct 25, 2011

Insanely confusing. Meilich is a perfect example of someone who is so laboratory research based he has lost sight and comprehension of how the business world actually works. His obsessive focus on attendance is silly. You would be better off finding any other instructor.

4.0
4.0
BUS444
Feb 6, 2015

I graduated four years ago. Three things that stand out: 1) This is what a university level 4th order course should feel like. I learned more than my money's worth and worked hard. 2) "Indeed" 3) Judging from friendly advise, and then seeing it with my own eyes, take Meilich instead of Antoniou at all costs.

5.0
2.0
BUS444
Apr 24, 2015

Great teacher, long lecture but not boring.

4.0
3.0
BUS444
Dec 17, 2015

I think Ofer gets a bad rap. He is a funny, genuine guy who wants to see his students succeed. There are no presentations, midterms, or finals. Instead, much of the class is focused on groupwork, as well as weekly writeups and quizzes. Be sure you get a good group. He is probably the best professor to take for BUS444 (behind Cata Ratiu).

5.0
3.0
BUS444
Dec 11, 2016
Would take again

Best to take Ofer for Bus 444 over the other professors, trust me. There's a lot of work being a capstone class, but the majority of it group work, and you actually learn a lot. The material is pretty interesting and Ofer's pretty hilarious. Definitely recommended.

Respected
Hilarious
GROUP PROJECTS
3.0
3.0
BUS444
Grade: B
Apr 28, 2017
Wouldn't take again

Ofer is very humorous. He has a great way to keep people engaged. His jokes are very corny but he does his best to get everyone on the same page.

Gives good feedback
Hilarious
GROUP PROJECTS
2.0
4.0
BUS444
Nov 28, 2017
Wouldn't take again

he's a nice guy but I didn't like his class at all. Very unorganized, alot of work and he is very hard to get a hold of if you need help

Tough Grader
LOTS OF HOMEWORK
Hilarious
5.0
4.0
BUS442
Grade: B+
May 7, 2019
Would take again

Super dorky professor. He'll make you laugh all class. There is no midterm or exam, but like 12 papers so be prepared to read/write! You have to think of a lot of product ideas. His class was super beneficial because he uses real world applications. He gets you excited for next class, leaves little hints. Would take again, he's fun! Lots of work

Lots of homework
Get ready to read
Hilarious
5.0
4.0
BUS444
Grade: A
May 15, 2019
Would take again

Professor Meilich is possibly the best professor I've had overall. He seems genuinely interested in ensuring you are learning the material. Allows you to improve grade on written assignments within a time frame. Allows Cheat-Sheets for mid term, no final. Fun class, always making jokes. Respect his class and his time and he will do the same to you

Gives good feedback
Group projects
Amazing lectures
5.0
3.0
BUS444
Grade: A-
May 20, 2020
Would take again

Ofer is a great professor who is passionate and willing to accommodate to students. Bus 444 is a tough class so expect to put time in. Ofer outlines exactly what he expects from students and as long as you pay attention you will get good results. One of the more meaningful classes I have taken. Cant recommend him enough.

Gives good feedback
Skip class? You won't pass.
2.0
4.0
BUS444
Grade: B+
Mar 16, 2021
Wouldn't take again

I really like the professor overall but he seems to be a really tough grader for many of his assignments. He will have you write many papers and grades poorly. He gave us 6 days to write a 5 page report and presentation to share with the class. After each group had gone, he criticized everything those students had to say. Nobody did good.

Lots of homework
Tough grader
1.0
5.0
BUS444
Grade: C+
Nov 16, 2021
Wouldn't take again

time consuming. harsh grader. too many assignments, don't recommend.

Lots of homework
So many papers
Tough grader
1.0
5.0
BUS444
Grade: B
Nov 18, 2021
Wouldn't take again

Ensures that you do not enjoy the material with excessive amount of papers to submit. Highly recommend McDonald, especially if you have a full load of work and classes. Grades poorly, hard to reach, and is a hilarious and disrespectful instructor. Don't question anything as he will not take the time to see any view other than his own.

Lots of homework
So many papers
Tough grader
1.0
5.0
BUS444
Dec 24, 2021
Wouldn't take again

Do not take Ofer. He might seem nice but his handling of class makes it so you will struggle. He gave us less than a week to research a company and give a presentation on IT support and then graded us on how much we know about it. He also does not grade assignments until the last week so if you fell behind you're out of luck without even knowing it

1.0
5.0
BUS444
Grade: B-
Feb 2, 2022
Wouldn't take again

Worst teacher at CSUSM, by far. Horrible experience. He is so focused on outdated methodology. It is clear he has not been in the business real world in a long time, if ever. His projects, requirements and due dates are all beyond reasonable. After all the work I put in he marked me down due to attendance. Keep in mind I missed two classes. Avoid

Lots of homework
Skip class? You won't pass.
Tough grader
1.0
5.0
BUS444
Grade: Rather not say
May 23, 2022

Don't take it if you don't want your semester miserable. Too much Group Projects and too many writing assignments.

Participation matters
Group projects
Lots of homework
5.0
3.0
BUS
Grade: A
Jun 28, 2022
Would take again

.....

Participation matters
Group projects
Amazing lectures
5.0
4.0
BUS444
Grade: B+
Nov 1, 2022
Would take again

Took his 4 hour evening class once a week, was very entertaining. He is engaging but the material is tough. If you're a business or management major you have to take this class anyways, so I'd recommend taking it with him. He actually cares about you as a student, wants you to get a good grade, and will explain whatever you want on quizzes/tests.

Get ready to read
Participation matters
Hilarious
2.0
4.0
BUS444
Grade: Not sure yet
Sep 3, 2023

I am 99% sure this guy has never had any real world business experience; I would not recommend him to anyone who is looking to get some real, helpful insight to the business world. Not super flexible, schedule on syllabus is unclear. Beware, 1 class session is actually 2 sessions so if you miss one class meeting, you're missing two sessions..

2.0
3.0
BUS444
Grade: Not sure yet
Nov 13, 2024

I think his teaching style is a fake front. He comes off as a very goofy and funny professor, but his teaching is horrible. He is not helpful when needed and his lectures are 3hr55mins of nothing and squeezes the important stuff in the last 5 min. Easily can get on your nerves.Lots of busy work and case studies that don't help. Just a weird class.

Participation matters
Lecture heavy
1.0
5.0
BUS444
Grade: C+
Dec 13, 2024

This professor is a joke, don't take this course with him. He doesn't provide any grades in canvas and waits till the end to provide grades. Your far better off by taking it with another person. Most, if not all, of the graded assignments were pointless and had no value outside of the classroom. Save yourself the trouble and take it w/someone else.

4.0
1.0
BUS444
Grade: B+
Dec 19, 2024
Would take again

4 hours of this class is too much but that's not Ofers fault. You literally have 1 assignment +1 quiz a week, a FEW group projects, and that's it. if you actually engage in class discussion you'll realize that Ofer makes the topics very entertaining, but people don't realize that because they just sit on their MacBooks. Great professor &easy class.

Participation matters
Group projects
Caring
5.0
2.0
BUS444
Grade: A
May 1, 2025
Would take again

I am confused by the bad reviews because he was genuinely one of the best professors I've had throughout my time here. As long as you put in the effort to study, pay attention to lectures, and follow instructions on assignments there's no reason why you can't get an A.

Get ready to read
Amazing lectures
Clear grading criteria
5.0
3.0
BUS444
Grade: B
May 11, 2025
Would take again

Overall, a great class and teacher that has a lot of insight into what he is talking about! Won't lie, at first I thought it would be difficult due to the mandatory attendance and quizzes, but as time goes on it became one of the best classes ever taken at csu. His lectures are funny, engaging, and he really tries to make connections with students!

Amazing lectures
Hilarious
Lecture heavy
1.0
2.0
BUS444
Oct 2, 2025

Professor is TERRIBLEEEE! I'm in his 444 class- and wish I chose another professor, don't take his class! Instructions are unclear and content is weak!

1.0
4.0
BUS444
Grade: Not sure yet
Oct 18, 2025

I wish I didn't take this class with Ofer. Halfway through the semester and I haven't learn a thing. Very paper heavy and he is the toughest grader. His feedback is really disrespectful and not helpful at all. Preaches that he wants his students to succeed but wont give you the tools. Don't take his class period.

Tough grader
Lots of homework
So many papers
1.0
4.0
BUS444
Grade: Incomplete
Oct 22, 2025

I am currently taking his class and HIGHLY recommend other professors or 442 + an elective. We have 3 4-5 page papers and a 1 page summary weekly. His instructions and feedback for assignments are super vague. Says that attendance is mandatory and he counts 1 4hour session as 2 separate classes. Very strange prof, took a picture of us the first day

Tough grader
Participation matters
So many papers
Class Info

Online Classes

100%

Attendance Mandatory

100%

Textbook Required

29%

Grade Predictor

Your expected effort level

LowHigh

Predicted Grade

B+

95% confidence
Based on 15 grades
Most common grades:
B+ (5)
B (3)
A (3)
Grade Distribution
A(3)B(4)C(2)D(0)F(0)A-/B+(6)
Based on 20 reported grades
B+: 5
B: 3
A: 3
Not sure yet: 3
Common Tags
Lots of homework (7)
Hilarious (6)
Tough grader (6)
Participation matters (6)
Group projects (4)
So many papers (4)
Gives good feedback (3)
Get ready to read (3)
Rating Trend

Declining

-0.21 avg change
Nov
Sep
Nov
Dec
May
Oct
Last 6 months
Ratings by Course

BUS493

5.0

(1)

BUS442

5.0

(1)

BUS444

3.4

(75)

BUS

3.0

(2)

GBM444

2.0

(1)
+1 more courses
Difficulty by Course

GBM444

5.0

BUS302

4.7

BUS442

4.0

BUS444

3.8

BUS493

3.0

Similar Professors