2.3

Philip McDunnough

Statistics - University of Toronto - St. George Campus

2.3
Quality
3.9
Difficulty
N/A
Would Retake
87
Reviews
2.3
Quality
3.9
Difficulty
2.3
Helpful
2.4
Clarity

N/A

Would Retake

87

Reviews

Rating Distribution
Official

5

14

4

8

3

16

2

15

1

34

What Students Say

explained concepts well, but his tests are HARD, bad professor in comparison with others, recommend people switching to another professor if you got him, he is such a *^<

STA257 - 2.0 rating

Should be avoided at all costs

STA347 - 1.0 rating
Class Info

Textbook Required

100%

Grade Predictor

Your expected effort level

LowHigh

Predicted Grade

A+

53% confidence
Based on 1 grades
Most common grades:
A (1)
Grade Distribution
A(1)B(0)C(0)D(0)F(0)A-/B+(0)
Based on 1 reported grades
A: 1
Rating Trend

Declining

-0.50 avg change
Jun
Jul
Oct
Jun
Jul
Nov
Last 6 months
Ratings by Course

257347

5.0

(1)

STA257STA347

5.0

(1)

STA257363

5.0

(1)

STA447

4.0

(3)

STA3000

4.0

(1)
+13 more courses
Difficulty by Course

ST257H

5.0

STA261

4.8

STA347

4.2

STA257

4.0

STA257H1

4.0

Reviews (87)
2.0
5.0
STA257
Feb 10, 2002

No Comments

3.0
5.0
STA257
Feb 26, 2002

invites you to asks questions , then insults you in front of the class.

1.0
3.0
STA257
Mar 27, 2002

You will learn absolutely nothing and be bored out of your mind in this course

1.0
5.0
STA257
Apr 4, 2002

totally memorizing........

5.0
1.0
STA255
Apr 6, 2002

clear and a really easy course

1.0
2.0
STA257
Apr 24, 2002

No Comments

1.0
5.0
STA257
May 3, 2002

No Comments

5.0
2.0
STA257
May 15, 2002

Great Prof knows how to give insights on the knowledge and life

2.0
5.0
STA257
Jun 3, 2002

One of the hardest 2nd Yr course i've ever done, and he's not that useful too..

1.0
4.0
STA257
Jun 19, 2002

No Comments

3.0
5.0
STA257
Jun 24, 2002

Avoid the course at all cost, unless you love memorizing...

4.0
1.0
STA257
Jun 29, 2002

the course is not easy...encouraging and wants his students to succeed...

3.0
3.0
STA255
Sep 4, 2002

marking scheme is quite advantageous. memorize for a good grade.

3.0
3.0
STA347
Feb 23, 2003

No Comments

5.0
4.0
STA257
Mar 26, 2003

No Comments

5.0
3.0
257347
Apr 30, 2003

Excellent professor. Shut mouth, stop complaining, open ears, engage brain & you will most definitely learn something.

2.0
5.0
STA257261
Apr 30, 2003

No Comments

1.0
5.0
STA257
May 17, 2003

I guess many comments containing the F word have been taken away. LOL. This prof is horrible, not organized and has absolutely so intention to teach. The course is as useful as this, memorize 1000 numbers and he'll ask u what's the 185th number? LOL.

1.0
5.0
STA257
May 20, 2003

Course mark distribution reflect those who have time to memorize old exams and those who do not. If this appeals to you, take this course. Some people I know have acheived high 90s in this course and told me they learned nothing.

1.0
4.0
STA257
Jun 27, 2003

The worst prof i hav ever seen !!!

3.0
3.0
STA257
Sep 25, 2003

He wasn't bad at all. We had 3 hours allotted for lecture, he let us go after 2. Marking scheme was good: do better on the next test, that's your course mark, so do the best on your exam, that's your final mark. A lot of memorizing though...

5.0
4.0
STA257H1
Oct 30, 2003

Geez..stop complaining (students below). This prof. is actually very good. He explains concepts really well. His tests are pretty fair. It is possible to get a very high mark in the class (providing you have a good memory). What more could you want?

1.0
1.0
STA257261
Nov 10, 2003

very easy if u memomize hard. You dont have to goto the class...read it yourself, and do (or memorize) the past yr paper...you will have the high probability of getting super high mark !!! Trust me !!!

1.0
5.0
STA257
Nov 23, 2003

well, personally speacking, I don't like this prof thought he is very smart.

1.0
5.0
STA261
Jan 3, 2004

what the heck?? hard or not, fair or not, i did not learn ANYTHING from him. i don't care the the F--- my mark is, i want to learn something. i learned everything on my own and McDunno just confused me. WORST PROF EVER

3.0
2.0
STA257
Mar 22, 2004

easy to get good marks in supposedly the hardest 2nd year stats course- what else could you want?? very easy prof!

1.0
5.0
STA261
Apr 4, 2004

the worst prof in history

3.0
3.0
STA447
Apr 24, 2004

funny as hell prof. i used to be intimidated by his personality but i realized that he's all jokes. sta447 is tough but managed a good mark because there were under 30 students. wouldn't recommend taking sta257 with him.

1.0
4.0
STA261
May 15, 2004

Terrible professor, mean and couldn't teach even if his life depended on it

1.0
5.0
STA257
Jun 16, 2004

prof was hard, unclear, confusing...

3.0
5.0
STA257
Aug 8, 2004

very hard course and prof makes it harder

1.0
5.0
ST257H
Sep 10, 2004

Worst professor! Rude and impolite!

2.0
4.0
STA255
Sep 27, 2004

I took STA255 in Winter 2001. This prof basically didn't use the textbook at all (making the course even harder) and seemed to run the course entirely for Stat/Math majors - difficult to get along with for sure.

5.0
5.0
STA257
Nov 9, 2004

AWESOME PROFESSOR!!!!!best prof ever

1.0
5.0
STA257
Dec 15, 2004

The worst prof

3.0
5.0
STA347
Dec 16, 2004

one crazy course, one wild prof, what can i say? too paranoid after the exam!

5.0
4.0
STA257STA347
Grade: A
Dec 16, 2004

He is a great Prof, very smart and resonable. His courses are very tough and harder than other Prof's. Anyway, if you are going to take higher level courses in mathematics Stats, you will find his lectures are very useful ,you really learn a lots from him and you wanna thank him.

1.0
4.0
STA257
Dec 17, 2004

He routinely yells at students who ask questions and doesn't seem to care if anyone understands him or not. In four years of university, this is by far the worst professor I have ever had, and I cannot think of a worse person to be in such a prominent position at a leading university.

1.0
5.0
STA347
Dec 25, 2004

errrrrrrrrrrrr i hate him... he is so rude and makes me want to kill myself...the course was hard and he made it worse

4.0
4.0
STA347
Dec 25, 2004

I think he has very good intentions although a lot of people may not see it. His course is very helpful if you want to learn about Mathematical Statistics. Most students in the class are from Act. Sci, and so they don't care too much about the theory, which is what he emphasizes a lot.

2.0
3.0
STA257
Jan 4, 2005

prof appears to have little interest in teaching. arrives late to class with an untidy appearance.

5.0
4.0
STA257
Jan 20, 2005

Great professor. Teaching all the stuff you need to know to continue your study in statistics related program.

4.0
2.0
STA257
Feb 25, 2005

This prof will teach you theory behind the probability. If you are interested in going into statistics, then you will learn a lot from him. Otherwise you would probably hate him, for all his questions on the tests are theoretical.

5.0
4.0
STA257363
Mar 25, 2005

Took a couple courses with him years ago. I thought he was an excellent professor. Good at explaining topics, approachable, great homework & exam qns. If you are interested in mathematics then I'm sure you'll hold the same opinion that I do. In retrospect, I wish I had taken more of his classe

5.0
4.0
STA447
May 6, 2005

He emphasizes theory a lot. Good for courses like STA447 and if you really want to learn the theory. Knows his stuff and very helpful. Also a very funny guy which made the 3 hour lectures on thursday night bearable. Overall one of the best profs I've had at UofT.

3.0
3.0
STA257347
May 17, 2005

not bad

3.0
5.0
STA257
Jun 19, 2005

No Comments

3.0
2.0
STA257
Sep 15, 2005

ok.. funny guy. do past exam u will do fine.

5.0
1.0
STA257261347
Oct 5, 2005

That guy is very strange to get along with. Try asking a stupid question, and he will make the entire class laugh at you! He likes "smart" students and "smart" question. If you get on his bad side, or talking while he is talking, he will kick you out of the lecture hall, no kidding! If you tolerat his persona, you can get your A.

1.0
1.0
STA347
Jan 29, 2006

Easy to get full mark if you memorize. But you cannot learn anything from him. Take sta347 in summer to avoid this ass.

1.0
5.0
STA257261347
Feb 16, 2006

No Comments

1.0
4.0
STA257STA107
Apr 3, 2006

he did not do a good job in delivering the material

2.0
4.0
STA257
May 4, 2006

Worst prof I've had as an undergrad.

1.0
5.0
STA261
May 7, 2006

No Comments

1.0
5.0
STA257
Jun 26, 2006

take this course if u have a fetish for egyptian hieroglyphics (his notes), or have obsessive compulsive tendencies of or relating to memorizing asteroid formations in the kuiper belt (his tests/exams). if you like statistics, look elsewhere.

5.0
3.0
STA257
Jul 4, 2006

This is NOT an easy course. But if people actually DO the suggested homework, they wouldn't have so much trouble in the course. You'll be fine if you put some EFFORT into the course. That's why you hear about people complaning this course is hard because they don't even bother to do the suggested homework at the least.

1.0
4.0
STA257
Aug 10, 2006

Worst Stats prof ever, wont answer questions and refuses to help. changed to the evening section With Brenner and my mark went up 30% Brenner BTW is awesome, take his secthin not mcdonnough

2.0
2.0
STA257
Nov 17, 2006

His notes are helpful if you understand his writing. And the tests have nothing to do with the textbook and problem sets.

1.0
4.0
STA347
Nov 26, 2006

His proofs are rediculous and he makes students to read them at home from internet, without explanation in class. Terrible!!!

2.0
3.0
STA257
Jan 11, 2007

Just do yourself a favour and choose a different section. You'll learn more and get a better mark.

1.0
5.0
STA257
Jan 14, 2007

Dont take his course. He is the worst professor in the world. Teaches useless stuff. Unfair grading policy, difficult tests

5.0
4.0
STA257
Aug 4, 2007

The reason for so much complaint is not because of the prof; it is due to the nature of the material and the lack of mathematical maturity of students.(not students' fault either, mat137 is not theoretical enough to prepare students for this course) To appreciate his lecture, one needs to do some additional reading and mat157 is absolutely helpful.

4.0
5.0
STA257
Aug 4, 2007

Very steep learning curve. If you read his lectures for the first time, they seem disorganized and proofs jump out from no where. But if you put effort into understanding it, the lecture notes are sufficient and you begin to appreciate smart ways he presents proofs. The TAs were very kind and helpful as well. got 100% with hard work..its doable.

4.0
4.0
STA257
Oct 20, 2007

If you don't have the background, dont take the course. This is not an applied course. It is supposed to be theoretical, and if you are mature enough to handle it, McDunnough does an excellent job! Don't listen to these other people. Just put in some effort and attend lectures.

3.0
2.0
STA257
Mar 7, 2008

This guy is probably not a bad guy, and he's probably very smart, but I did not get anything from his course. Seems like him and I both hated the class. I was trying to understand what he was saying, but he wouldn't even answer my questions properly. I gave up and rote memorized past exams and got 100%. Worst class ever.

2.0
3.0
STA257H
Oct 8, 2008

No Comments

5.0
5.0
STA347
Dec 21, 2008

McDunnough's teaching methodology is absolutely brilliant. :e is very fair and approachable and his online notes are excellent. If you want to succeed in his courses then you need to be willing to put in 5 to 8 hours a week. 5o all of the homework problems and attend all lectures. He does an excellent job explaining the material and if you are stil

1.0
5.0
STA347
Jan 23, 2009

Most intelligent person I've ever met.

4.0
3.0
STA3000
Feb 4, 2009

A good fellow with a very bad handwriting. Can't type his lectures.

4.0
3.0
STA457
Feb 4, 2009

He is the best and the smartest professor of the dept. of statistics. He loves his subject and certainly appreciates those who share that love with him.

1.0
5.0
STA257
Feb 6, 2009

He rambles on about a myriad of unconnected ideas that we are somehow to understand and apply to construct sophisticated proofs. I attended every single lecture, reviewed my notes and took more extensive notes from advanced textbooks , and diligently showed up at my tutorials. I have never attempted to understand a subject and failed so miserably.

4.0
4.0
STA447
Apr 28, 2009

I don't see what the problem is. I did STA257/347 and now 447 with him and liked his style in every class. Sure he's not the most accomodating of people when it comes to answering stupid questions, but after 30 years of teaching, thats understandable. If you make an effor, you can do very well and learn a lot. I got 90%+ in all three courses.

3.0
5.0
STA257
Oct 23, 2009

THEORETICALLY INTENSE BUT YOU HAVE TO REREAD HIS NOTES AND WRITE OUT THE PROOFS YOURSELF TO UNDERSTAND THE CONCEPTS.

3.0
3.0
STA257
Nov 15, 2009

All this guy likes to emphasize is theory. I know STA257 may be a theoretical course, but the amount of theory this guy emphasizes is nuts. For the tests, all you do is just memorize the techniques for proofs, do proofs, and get your 100.

2.0
5.0
STA257
Nov 29, 2009

Prof doesn't respect students at all, never ask any questions, he'll humiliate you

1.0
5.0
STA257
Dec 12, 2009

WORST TEACHER I HAVE EVER HAD!!! DID NOT LEARN ANYTHING!!! AVOID HIM AT ALL COST!!!

2.0
5.0
STA257
Dec 29, 2009

explained concepts well, but his tests are HARD, bad professor in comparison with others, recommend people switching to another professor if you got him, he is such a *^<!!!

1.0
4.0
STA257
Oct 14, 2010

avoid him at costs, he prepare nothing for his lecture, and he talks of all kinds of unrelated topic on his lecture

2.0
5.0
STA257
Apr 13, 2011

The guy just doesn't handle noise very well, handwriting is a problem, marginally readable. The level he wants you to be is very difficult in his class, external materials will be required to do well. Basically he'll make really hard tests/exams and then just bell curve everyone up

1.0
5.0
STA347
Oct 18, 2011

You are either one of 3 students, someone that already knows all the proofs, somebody that will fail, or somebody that will memorize about a hundred past exam questions and pass with a 70. No other way to deal with this course

1.0
4.0
SAT257H1
Jun 13, 2013

rambles on, hard to read notes, gaps in logic in notes and gaps in the notes. if you go through and redo all the notes it helps, midterm == the practise test.

1.0
5.0
STA347
Jul 17, 2013

Uses his own derivations, his own proofs, his own notation which are NOT to be found in "standard" or "accessible" textbooks. His questions are super difficult. He requires proofs to be done HIS way. The material itself is hard as hell. Should be avoided at all costs. Poor lecture notes (chicken scrap), and gets angry and rude very quickly. AVOID!

3.0
3.0
STA257
Jul 24, 2013

STA257 will McD is quite manageable if you pay very careful attention to his notes do the problems that he assigns. It is good preparation for upper year stat courses.

2.0
5.0
STA257
Oct 1, 2013

The worst instructor I've met in UofT. He's very arrogant, often humiliating the ones who raise questions. Like being late, can't tolerate any slightest talking in the auditorium. He doesn't follow the textbook, arrange concepts in his own way.

2.0
4.0
STA257H1
Jun 25, 2014

The worst of the worst. Do not even think about taking his course... I can get 100% in the midterm but fail in the final... I think I am good...

1.0
5.0
STA257
Jul 19, 2014

Worst educator I have come across in my life. I can think of a couple expletives when describing McDunnough. He really wanted to be anywhere but teaching. His lectures were so scattered, messy and did not prepare you for his exams, but the cherry on top was his arrogance towards all students. Good riddance.

2.0
4.0
STA257
Nov 4, 2014

I hated him when I took his course. But now when I turned to Year 3, I found many stuff he taught in second year actually covers many aspects of the third year probability courses. In other words, if you ace in his course, you will find pretty easy to study the consequent courses.

Class Info

Textbook Required

100%

Grade Predictor

Your expected effort level

LowHigh

Predicted Grade

A+

53% confidence
Based on 1 grades
Most common grades:
A (1)
Grade Distribution
A(1)B(0)C(0)D(0)F(0)A-/B+(0)
Based on 1 reported grades
A: 1
Rating Trend

Declining

-0.50 avg change
Jun
Jul
Oct
Jun
Jul
Nov
Last 6 months
Ratings by Course

257347

5.0

(1)

STA257STA347

5.0

(1)

STA257363

5.0

(1)

STA447

4.0

(3)

STA3000

4.0

(1)
+13 more courses
Difficulty by Course

ST257H

5.0

STA261

4.8

STA347

4.2

STA257

4.0

STA257H1

4.0

Similar Professors