Ingber is one of the best professors you can possibly take. He quite clearly knows his stuff and forces you to think critically. The work can be tough, but you will learn the material AND come out many times smarter at the end.

He might be kinda hard at first, before you get the pace of the class, but he is really good teacher. You think you know the answer, then he gives a slightly different situation and you have to think in totaly new light.

Ingber is a good professor and he may you think. The assignment are challening and if you want a easy class this is not the professor you want.

His class can be a little intense. He puts people on the spot to answer all the time and you better have one. Not for the faint of heart.

At first the class can seem daunting but by the time you finish a case he makes you understand every aspect in great detail. He is a wonderful professor.

Make no mistake, this prof is not easy. On the other hand, you will learn. He teaches via Socratic method, so come to class prepared. If you want to get the education you paid for, take his class. If you want some cutesy prof who gives easy A's, then don't. This is what college should be.

I loved Ingber. Ingber is the reason I went to law school. He does teach using the Socratic method, but if you want to go to law school, take him and get an idea. Not for the faint of heart...hes not an easy A and he can be abrasive but I loved the hell out of his class. Hes the best.

One of the best professors ive had in college, exactly what the college experience should be like. Tough grader but those who are really in school to learn should expect teachers such as him. Ive taken all his classes and would highly recommend him.

This professor was the best. I learned so much from him and i still continue to use the analytical skills he taught me. For anyone who is interested to go to law school he is perfect to help you prepare. He's not easy though so you have to have your**** together

HE is a very hard prof. If you're looking for an easy A don't take him because your not going to get it. You have to do work in his class, a lot of work, but in the end its all worth it. I've been in John Jay for 3 years and he is the best professor I had so far. I learned a lot in his class!!

One Grade extra credit for doing the homework and one grade extra credit for participating in class how can anyone complain. He is the only teacher who would assign a 7 page paper and have it grade and corrected by the next class. He is an amazing teacher

Oh come on! Professor Ingber is a GREAT professor. He is very helpful when asked. He gives two 3-5 page papers, a midterm and final - two page scenarios (you figure out the convictions) thats all. He clarifies his concepts with great stories and examples. He asks for name tags just as it is done in law school. HELLO, THIS IS COLLEGE. GROW UP.

A very demanding but worthwhile class. Be prepared for the Socratic method. Do the work, never come to class unprepared and you can get an A. 2 3-5 p. papers a final and a midterm based on hypotheticals and weekly case logs...lots of work but you will learn a lot.

Hard professor, DEFINITELY encourages you to think! Not easy at all but you will learn a lot. Very thorough in his teaching. Sometimes unfair in his expectations, but very clear in his lessons.

had in undergrad,love this prof!Learned more here then from anyone else b4 or since,not even my major!Not 2 hard,u just have 2 think & reason,so interesting!he doesn't tell u what u should think bc point is 4 U 2 think &reason on own not regurgitate facts people tell u.b prepared 2 think & participate u'll get more out of this class than any other

the guy warns all students the very forst day of how the class will be. he lets you know to make sure you come to class prepared other wise expect the unexpected. all you have to do is learn from his ideas and come up with you own hypothesis. he is a very tough grader, which teaches you to learn or go to writing center.

Ingber is a brilliant professor, but he is tough. A lot of work, weekly assignments, so don't take if you want an easy course. Worth it if you are interested in Crim Law.

He is hard but the best practice for law school you can get. Law school is just like his class, thank you prof ingber, without you I'll be lost in law school, thank you!

Challenged me and the other students to read the material for every class, didnt take many notes but i was very involved in classroom discussion. He requires every student to do a short case log every week.. which isnt that hard.. i found his 2 papers for the course a bit challenging.. I learned a lot in his class though.

Professor Ingber, is a difficult professor. He will introduce law to you,as if your in law school. I dropped his course because I could not keep up with the amount of work. if you are planning to take a class with him make sure you dont have any other classes on your plate,because he will overload you with work.

Professor Ingber is a brilliant mind.Those who want to learn and better themselves at thinking effectively will appreciate and see his greatness.He sure challenges his students,but with their best interest in mind.If u do not have any interest in the field or in upgrading your thinking processes,u won't be able to appreciate him or enjoy his class.

If you are looking for an easy A don't take his class. His class is very demanding but if you never took a law class before take his because you will learn alot. He requires you to do case logs, 2 critique papers, final and a midterm. if you do all of your case logs and only fail two he raises your grade and the same with attendance

The professor is very nice, BUT the course is hard. He's a very smart, knowledgable person. Expexts students to participate & have discussions on what the topic is that day. Cases must be brief for every class, he collects them. The exams are somewhat hard, not very hard if you understand the class, make sure 2 ask Qs. VERY strict on attendance.

This is the best professor for law. I highly recommend him. you should take him. He is very helpful. easy midterm open book and only two paper cases for the entire class.

excellent professor. for those people complaining about how hard/confusing his class is they are the people you who just do the bare minimum to get an A and dont pay attention. dont take him if thats you because you will fail. he is a very good prof and is very knowledgeable. he does give alot of work but you will easily benefit in the end.

Just finishedthis Fall2011 semester withprof Ingber and let me tell you...it definitely was not easy. This class is very demanding of your time. You be required to do allot ofcase logs each week along with 2 MAJOR term papers, a midterm and a Final. Hes a tough grader (since he was an editor) and has no problem failing u.

Great Professor

Brilliant professor that knows what he is teaching.

Great professor he knows his stuff

Ok, I have been reading how hard this teacher is. I tell you, His class is not hard. If you pay attention in class you will do well. Try to participat and please do not say "I don't know?" as an answer to a question. He would ask WHat do you think and people would answer I don't know. Obviously he doesnt know what you think...

Brilliant, great teacher, I learned alot

One of the smartest teachers at JJAY

Brilliant

Great Professor taught me stuff that I use in other classes related to his. I think if you show up to class and participate you get a minumum of 5 percent increase

This professor is very intelligent. Requires a lot of reading but its interesting. People are always complaining about the work but its not really hard, just time consuming. This class requires you to think and really helps you learn how to analyze situations from different points of view. Other professors acknowledge the fact that he is brilliant.