2.7

Vandana Pednekar-Magal

Communication - Grand Valley State University

2.7
Quality
3.3
Difficulty
29%
Would Retake
94
Reviews
2.7
Quality
3.3
Difficulty
2.8
Helpful
2.6
Clarity

29%

Would Retake

94

Reviews

Rating Distribution
Official

5

20

4

13

3

19

2

23

1

19

What Students Say

She never responds to a single email

CJR236 - 2.0 rating

Mostly everything must be done in person

COM372 - 5.0 rating
Class Info

Online Classes

100%

Attendance Mandatory

56%

Textbook Required

57%

Grade Predictor

Your expected effort level

LowHigh

Predicted Grade

B

77% confidence
Based on 9 grades
Most common grades:
B (3)
C (2)
B- (2)
Grade Distribution
A(1)B(5)C(2)D(0)F(0)A-/B+(1)
Based on 11 reported grades
B: 3
C: 2
B-: 2
Not sure yet: 2
Common Tags
GROUP PROJECTS (2)
Tough Grader (2)
Respected (2)
Get ready to read (2)
Participation matters (2)
Clear grading criteria (1)
LECTURE HEAVY (1)
Skip class? You won't pass. (1)
Rating Trend

Stable

+0.20 avg change
Aug
Mar
Jan
Jan
May
Jun
Last 6 months
Ratings by Course

MGT452

5.0

(1)

CJRA

5.0

(1)

COM275

4.0

(1)

COM372

3.6

(16)

CJR270

3.5

(2)
+15 more courses
Difficulty by Course

NEWSINSO

5.0

ALLCOURSE

5.0

MGT268

5.0

NEWSWRITIN

4.0

ARTICLEWR

4.0

Reviews (94)
1.0
5.0
CJR236
Dec 8, 1999

Tricks students in multiple choice tests, grades unfairly, not friendly!

3.0
3.0
CJR364
Dec 23, 1999

She seems to change her mind often.

1.0
4.0
CJR236
Jan 12, 2000

She is indecisive and difficult. Not approachable and just outright mean

2.0
4.0
CJR236
Mar 28, 2000

Stay away from this unclear and unfriendly prof

5.0
1.0
CJR256
Oct 30, 2000

May come off snotty but very friendly when approached, willing to help students!

1.0
5.0
CJR236
Oct 23, 2000

Very unclear, not friendly, STAY AWAY FROM!

2.0
5.0
NEWSINSO
Nov 1, 2000

She never has any idea what she's talking about or trying to convey.

2.0
4.0
NEWSWRITIN
Nov 29, 2000

Never has enough material to fill a whole class; thoughtful, tough grader

2.0
5.0
CJR236
Dec 13, 2000

She does not teach!She grades only on the reading done outside of class and pick

5.0
2.0
COM372
Dec 20, 2000

very nice, always willing to help

2.0
4.0
COM372
Jan 5, 2001

SHE IS VERY UNCLEAR, AND DOES NOT KNOW HOW TO TEACH. SHE TALKS ABOUT INDIA.

2.0
4.0
ARTICLEWR
Jan 10, 2001

Unclear. Does't fill up time. Doesn't really teach and her expectations are high

2.0
4.0
CJR236
Jan 23, 2001

Unclear, unfriendly, uninspired teaching...beware!

1.0
5.0
CJR236
Feb 19, 2001

You will leave this class very frusterated! Very unclear & tests are tricky!

1.0
5.0
CJR236
Jan 30, 2001

Picks favorites, unorganized, unprepared lectures, disrespectful, unfair grader.

4.0
4.0
CJR236
Feb 28, 2001

she is a great resource for writing but tests are very vague in media & society

1.0
3.0
CJR236
Mar 1, 2001

you will feel unity in the class as you band together over your mutual hate

1.0
5.0
CJR236
Mar 28, 2001

You will want your money back after this class, as well as a deserving grade!!!

1.0
4.0
COM2563
Apr 24, 2001

doesn't care about you, doesn't like you; gives undeserved grades

5.0
4.0
CJR256
May 22, 2001

Exc. professor for the serious writer. You will be better writer after her class

1.0
5.0
ALLCOURSE
Jun 6, 2001

Has no idea what she's trying to convey. Cant speak clear English. Very rude!!

2.0
4.0
CJR256
Sep 26, 2001

Very wishy-washy and does not specify well.

1.0
4.0
CJR256
Oct 30, 2001

i'd rather fight a rabid bear than having to be in this class

3.0
3.0
CJR256
Oct 30, 2001

Very hard to understand, but willing to help students

3.0
3.0
CJR356
Nov 26, 2001

I like her but she can be very vague. The class is kind of challenging

5.0
3.0
CJR256
Jan 25, 2002

Good writers will do well. She is nice, intelligent, and helpful.

2.0
3.0
CJR256
Dec 24, 2001

i think she was a hard teacher to understand, and you dont learn anything at all

4.0
4.0
COM371
Jun 18, 2002

Difficult content, but good Prof. Would recommend.

3.0
4.0
CJR236
Sep 21, 2002

Class would fall asleep, very boring, getting teeth pulled is more exciting

5.0
3.0
CJR236
Oct 15, 2002

She's a good prof and I've learned a lot. It's hard to understand her at first.

1.0
5.0
MGT268
Oct 24, 2002

No Comments

4.0
3.0
CJR236
Nov 28, 2002

You shouldn't be in this class if you're not serious about english/journalism

1.0
5.0
COM372
Nov 20, 2002

Very hard to understand...unclear, incredibly boring lectures

5.0
1.0
MGT452
Jan 13, 2003

Nice and fun!

5.0
1.0
CJR256
Mar 11, 2003

Very good teacher. Very helpful. You must work hard in her class.

1.0
4.0
CJR256
Apr 3, 2003

No Comments

2.0
3.0
CJR270
Aug 26, 2003

boring lectures in the agitating, hair-pulling way, seems to favor female students, near impossible to understand sometimes

5.0
3.0
CJR236
Oct 30, 2003

I think this is a difficult class to teach, and professor magal does a fine job with it. Her accent takes a little getting used to, but she really knows her stuff. The only problem is she doesn't take a lot of time to get to know students individually.

2.0
4.0
CJR256
Nov 6, 2003

She does not respond to e-mail so don't bother getting ahold of her that way. Class is boring. Don't bother taking unless you want to prusue journalism.

5.0
2.0
CJR236
Dec 4, 2003

She is a very interesting professor and was very flexible with the schedule. If you read and write a little bit, you get all of the points. She gives you the questions for the exams too!

4.0
1.0
CJR236
Jan 3, 2004

Easiest CJR class I've ever taken. Kiss butt in there and you'll be fine. She likes the kids who ask questions and talk alot. Show up once in a while, do the writings and you'll be all set.

4.0
3.0
CJR236
Feb 4, 2004

The topics are interesting. Generally, she leads a good discussion in class. She likes people who participate in discussion. Her grading seems a bit arbitrary. Not too bad

2.0
3.0
CJR256
Apr 23, 2004

This lady is awful! Cancels class, grades terribly hard and makes the final worth way too much. She never answers email and is not passionate about what she does.

5.0
3.0
COM372
Aug 8, 2004

Excellent professor, very interesting class material. It helps to participate.......

2.0
4.0
ACOUPLE
Sep 9, 2004

She is extremely scatter brained, usually unprepared, and she never remembered which class she was there for. She's extremely arrogant and has no passion for teaching. On top of all, her grading makes it impossible for most to do well, talented or not.

1.0
5.0
COM372
Nov 18, 2004

EXTREMELY boring class, very vague about assignments. Don't try asking questions because she'll won't answer it, she'll just answer some random question that she made up in her head. Wants you to just regurgitate the EXACT words from the book/lectures on tests otherwise you will get marked down.

3.0
2.0
COM372
Nov 18, 2004

OK, she knows her stuff and you can learn a lot from her if you pay attention and participate in class. Some of the readings are dry but she does her best to explain them. Large group project at the end of semester and 3 tests total. Final is not cumulative. I liked her and the class.But I talk.

3.0
3.0
CJR236
Dec 8, 2004

Her 3 tests consist of ONLY essay questions. That makes her grading system suck. Has no homework to help your grade, one paper. Hence, don't take if you're bad at essay questions. Embarassed me in front of some class members (she could have sent me an email/pulled me aside after class). Watch out.

5.0
1.0
COM372
Dec 8, 2004

NOT BAD! Grade=3 essay tests, and 1 group project. Outlines test Qs and reviews. Class can be boring, so I read the material as she talked about it. Take notes, offer your opinion, DO the study guide, and you'll be FINE! Very approachable..often confused by student's q's. Not a bad class at all.

4.0
3.0
COM372
Dec 14, 2004

I did bad on the first test, then she explained what she wanted and i did fine after that. She handed the test out before our second exam and the final was a take home. It was an easy enough class and she grades pretty easily too.

3.0
3.0
CJR236
Jan 6, 2005

She is a nice lady and will try to answer questions but many times she becomes lost in her own explanations and very rarely did her answers help me at all. Just try to actually read what she assigns and take notes, you'll do okay.

3.0
4.0
CJR236
Jan 7, 2005

Adorable lady, but could do a little better with the class. I got a much lower grade then I was expecting. Just study a lot before the exams and do the readings more then once (they're fairly easy) and you should be fine.

1.0
4.0
CJR256
May 6, 2005

lazy. she doesn't want to grade papers so she has your peers do it. she doesn't want to grade tests so she cancels them. there isn't enough work to be graded! i'm a senior in this sophomore class i forgot to take and did terrible!

3.0
3.0
COM371
Jun 21, 2005

The class was okay. A little boring, but she did try to make us understand the readings that we were required to read. We did a lot of class discussions and that helped me understand better. She's not overly enthusiastic to listen to, but not impossible. She's do-able.

2.0
2.0
COM371
Jun 22, 2005

The work is easy, the class discussions are drawn out, and her grading is out in left field.

4.0
3.0
COM371
Jun 28, 2005

If you put in effort, she will acknowledge that and reward you for it.

2.0
4.0
COM371
Jun 29, 2005

If you are a PR, MKT or ADV major, try not to take this course with this professor. Assigned readings only presented negative aspects of capitalism. Homework was graded but not returned so there was no feedback. Midterm was the only assignment returned but comments were illegible.

5.0
2.0
CJR270
Sep 7, 2005

Class was fun and interesting. Always got out early. As long as you ask for help she's wonderful in helping you improve your grade. Has a lot of experience and is very understanding. She's a really cool person.

4.0
1.0
CJR236
Grade: A
Dec 5, 2005

Class is pretty unorganized. She lets you out early quite a bit. There are only 4 grades: 3 Tests (including final; 2 of them were take-home) and a group presentation. If you show up to class often and talk every once and a while she will notice and give you participation points. Class is pretty boring but won't cause you a lot of work or worry.

4.0
2.0
CJR236
Dec 11, 2005

Not a bad professor at all. Very unclear of her expectations in the beginning so make sure you are very thorough on your test answers. Very nice, flexible, and knowledgable.

3.0
3.0
CJR236
Dec 14, 2005

she was decent. i guess she was just sort of unclear of what she expected from us.

3.0
3.0
CJR256
Dec 19, 2005

Very Qualified for teaching Newsreporting, but she's so unclear. There are no guidelines for assignments and good luck reading the comments. She's nice and helpful, but vague. Tells students that everything is good, but then we'd get an 8/10. No clear grading scale as to what makes an "A" article.

3.0
4.0
CJR236
Dec 25, 2005

Aviod for this class. Essay tests- no clear grading guidlelines. Not enough work to be graded, 3 tests and one group projects.

2.0
2.0
CJR236
Jan 4, 2006

She means well, but she just shouldn't be a professor. The class is pretty much an opinion class, but at the end of class discussion, she wants you to think only her way. If you don't, and you show that on the test, she makes comments like "Remember the class discussion?" Just find out what her opinion is and write that down on the test.

4.0
2.0
COM371
Feb 1, 2006

This Prof is wishy-washy. I never knew what she wanted on essay tests and all we did was have class discussions.

1.0
5.0
CJR256
Dec 11, 2006

This Prof, is very wishy washy, you will only do well in her class if you agree with her political views. Her teaching style is odd and she is VERY un clear as to what she wants. The readings are rediculous and should only be read by those who want to obatin a job in a liberal world. She gave me a bad grade simply because i gave her my opinions in

5.0
2.0
CJRA
Feb 17, 2007

This is one of the best journalism professors at GVSU. She is always there for you when you need her the most. She responds to students e-mails very quickly. It is not true she wants you to the way she does. Those students who took her classes and did not enyoj them.... OH well that just means they have no ideas what journalism is all about.

1.0
4.0
CJR236
Apr 24, 2007

AVOID THIS CLASS!

5.0
1.0
COM371
Jul 10, 2007

Knows the topic she is teaching well. She is also clear and easy to follow along if you pay attention. As long as you are taking notes you m shoul dend up with an A. Some of the material provided by her could be a bit hard, but if you are alert in the classroom don't worry.If you really want to know more about COM Vandan Magal is a way to go.

5.0
1.0
CJR256
Jul 26, 2007

Vandana is professor with dignity, integrity and respect. She loves her students as if thy're her children. No matter for what class you take her you will not regred it at ALL. She is everything a professor should be all about: helping STUDENTS. IF you end up taking her you will have lots of fun. For those of you who are GRADE hunters should do fin

3.0
3.0
CJR236
Aug 24, 2007

Very nice lady and helpful too, but be ready the liberal slant...

4.0
2.0
CJR236
Jan 9, 2008

Very easy going and knowledgeable about the topic. Doesn't ask too much out of students, but class discussions are still interesting. Grades tough on the take home exams, but just read the book and don't skip and you'll be fine.

5.0
2.0
COM372
Sep 3, 2008

For those who truly care an belive in educating themselves Vandana is a way to go. She is more than a professor. She is your friend. Extremelly knowledgeble lady. One of the best prefesors that GVSU has. No wonder she is got TEaching Excellence Award. SUPER AWESOME. The best Prof I ever had at GVSU

2.0
3.0
CJR236
Jan 8, 2009

Don't bother with the book if you aren't going to read it. As long as you know the powerpoints she posts/ half listened in class you'll ace the exams. Easy grader and flexible with homework assignments. Put effort into the presentation because she is more critical of that.

3.0
2.0
COM376
Feb 3, 2009

Boring material and hard to making it exciting. Prof is nice but doesn't spice the class up at all. Tests were easy we could use notes and she gave out a study guide. Reading was hard and long.

4.0
5.0
CJR236
Apr 26, 2010

I've had this prof for other classes, and while it's not very exciting, it's not hard. I'm not a CJR major, but enjoyed the class. Work wasn't difficult, and she encourages open discussion. Great Prof!!

3.0
4.0
COM372
Dec 13, 2010

Can seem mean at times, but she's nice & approachable. Readings are tough. Easy grader with essays. Class is boring. She'll tear you apart with questions after a presentation.

5.0
3.0
COM372
Mar 29, 2011

Awesome Professor. Expects you to learn the stuff though. Aims for big concepts, and ability to tie them into real world applications. I use Global Communication ideas in other classes all the time, so the class is useful.

2.0
3.0
CJR236
May 4, 2011

She is awful. She never responds to a single email. She also missed 3 class periods (that were 6-9's) but made us still attend. Her powerpoints are boring and she is difficult to communicate with. She acts like students are an inconvenience to her and her time. The group presentation is graded the hardest out of all of your assignments.

5.0
3.0
CJR236
Feb 10, 2012

I learned a lot about the history & motives of journalism in this class - interesting class. The prof expects students to be engaged & if you're not, you may not do very well in this class. Do the readings, assignments & speak up in class & you'll do fine. She has a lot of real life experience & you can learn a lot from her if you choose.

5.0
3.0
COM372
Dec 13, 2012

Love this teacher! I was in a class of 12 and she made class very fun and personal. She encouraged office visits and tells you that she won't reply via email. Mostly everything must be done in person. She has a very good teaching method where everything is conversational and relatable. Would definitely take her class again!

3.0
4.0
COM371
Aug 1, 2013

She missed 2 classes and I took it during the 6 week summer semester. Very boring discussions and lectures. Tough grader on exams and presentations. Not at all helpful outside of class.

2.0
3.0
CJR236
Dec 29, 2013

This is the second time I had this professor and it was basically the same as my last class with her. All about powerpoints and I already had prior knowledge about this subject so i didn't really learn anything from her. All the exams are long essays and if you do take this class I suggest you take COM 220 with this class b/c it definitely helps.

2.0
3.0
CJR236
Grade: C
Mar 25, 2014

She is very unorganized in her teaching method. She would say something was homework, but it wasn't. She changed the portfolio due date several times to the point that class e-mails were sent out once a week asking when things were due. She also is not very easy to understand. The exams are huge essays in which she grades fairly harshly.

3.0
2.0
CJR364
Apr 2, 2014

Dr. V is very informative on the world of journalism, but she can be unclear about the homework and her expectations from students. This is the second time I have had her. She does not use email or blackboard very much, so that can be a communication problem if you have questions. Overall, an okay professor who has experience in the field.

3.0
4.0
COM372
Grade: C
Jan 22, 2015

Before you think about signing up for her classes know that she is Indian, has a heavy accent, and can be difficult to understand. The book was $65 and is dense & very hard to read. She takes forever to get points across. She's very unorganized. Makes you uncomfirtably step out of your comfort zone with unreasonable projects. Avoid her if you can.

3.0
3.0
COM372
Grade: B
Dec 3, 2015

Dr. V is very knowledgeable. VERY knowledgeable. However it seems her busy schedule takes precedence to the class. This class was a 6-9 and she showed up late almost every time. She gives you random assignments and acts as if they were super clear and concise. That is never the case. She really means well but she misses the mark.

2.0
3.0
COM372
Grade: B+
May 7, 2017
Wouldn't take again

Sometimes confusing on what she wants and a pretty boring lecturer, but you can get through it.

Clear grading criteria
GROUP PROJECTS
LECTURE HEAVY
2.0
4.0
COM215
Grade: B-
Aug 7, 2017
Wouldn't take again

Super nice,she wasn't as clear as she thought she was. Our final short story she said it could be a one to three pages, then later she said it should be no less than 10 and gave no direct feedback on our drafts. Random 4 page assignment bc she thought no one was doing the readings. Allowed 1 absence, anymore it would 25% of your grade each time.

Tough Grader
Respected
Skip class? You won't pass.
5.0
5.0
COM372
Grade: B-
Mar 28, 2018
Would take again

Dr. Magal is a great professor and cares about the her students, but she seems to not be very organized. She tends to forget when assignments are due (not the worst thing) and she also forgets how she described the assignments to students which can lead to a lot of lost points.

Tough Grader
Get ready to read
GRADED BY FEW THINGS
4.0
3.0
COM275
Grade: B
Jan 7, 2019
Would take again

I enjoyed her class. She is very nice and caring. Her class is not hard, just be sure to participate. The only thing that is a bit complex is her test - they are very structured and shes a tough grader. But overall the class was laid back with not a lot of assignments.

Respected
Participation matters
GROUP PROJECTS
2.0
2.0
SCOM2050
Grade: B
Jan 6, 2022
Wouldn't take again

My issue with this class is that the lectures were a bit all over the place. I did not enjoy them. But on the upside, just make sure you read the textbook and the Powerpoints that she makes. Once you take notes on those two things, and participate in her class, you should be completely fine.

Get ready to read
Participation matters
Lecture heavy
1.0
5.0
SCOM2050
Grade: Not sure yet
May 4, 2025

Her announcements are always unclear or missing important details, so you never know what's due or when. She also takes off points for no clear reason, even after you've done all the work. It's really frustrating. Save yourself the trouble and pick a different professor.

1.0
5.0
ALLCOURSE
Grade: Not sure yet
Jun 29, 2025

Made an assignment due before the class semester even started.

Tough grader
Test heavy
Graded by few things
Class Info

Online Classes

100%

Attendance Mandatory

56%

Textbook Required

57%

Grade Predictor

Your expected effort level

LowHigh

Predicted Grade

B

77% confidence
Based on 9 grades
Most common grades:
B (3)
C (2)
B- (2)
Grade Distribution
A(1)B(5)C(2)D(0)F(0)A-/B+(1)
Based on 11 reported grades
B: 3
C: 2
B-: 2
Not sure yet: 2
Common Tags
GROUP PROJECTS (2)
Tough Grader (2)
Respected (2)
Get ready to read (2)
Participation matters (2)
Clear grading criteria (1)
LECTURE HEAVY (1)
Skip class? You won't pass. (1)
Rating Trend

Stable

+0.20 avg change
Aug
Mar
Jan
Jan
May
Jun
Last 6 months
Ratings by Course

MGT452

5.0

(1)

CJRA

5.0

(1)

COM275

4.0

(1)

COM372

3.6

(16)

CJR270

3.5

(2)
+15 more courses
Difficulty by Course

NEWSINSO

5.0

ALLCOURSE

5.0

MGT268

5.0

NEWSWRITIN

4.0

ARTICLEWR

4.0

Similar Professors